IMA 5001 :Commercial Law
Module 5: Company Act, 1956
Bit Mesra, Jaipur Campus Contact :
[email protected]
PUBLIC AND PRIVATE COMPA NIES
Generally speaking, public companies are ones which can raise money by inviting the public to
purchase their shares. This is a considerable advantage for public companies but not every public
company will be able to make the fullest use of it, since they will not necessarily have access to a
market. A company’s shares will be much more attractive to investors if they can be traded on a
properly regulated market because, not only will they be easily and safely purchased, but, also,
they will be easily disposed of. The major market place for shares in the UK is the Stock
Exchange 5 but by no means all public companies have access to this market. Companies can
only gain admission to it by complying with certain conditions , and notably by demonstrating
a satisfactory trading record. The distinction between public and private companies first
appeared in the Companies Act 1907. A ‘private company’ was defined as one which, by the
company’s constitution, restricted the right to transfer its shares, limited the number of its
members to 50 and prohibited any invitation to the public to subscribe for any shares or
debentures of the company. The 1907 Act was concerned with increasing the protection for
investors who were considering subscribing for shares in a company by requiring it to provide
relevant information when offering shares for sale to the public. This was to be done either
through the established practice of issuing a prospectus or, in lieu of that , by r enquiring the
company to furnish the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies with a statement containing the
same information as would have been included in the prospectus. A private company was
exempt from filing this statement. Thus, the distinction was born as a recognition of the existing
state of affairs which had, by then, emerged and it was, by the beginning of the 20th century, too
late to separate the provisions applying to each type of association into different statutes. The
approach to company law reform is almost always inherently conservative lest anything is done
which jeopardises the use of registered companies by businesses and, thereby, hinders the
development of the economy. Certainly, nothing as radical as the enactment of two entirely
different statutes, one applying to small companies and one applying to companies which offered
shares for sale to the public, could then have been contemplated. The way in which the
distinction was framed, namely, by defining private companies and classifying the remainder as
public, lasted until the Companies Act 1980, when considerable amendments to the law were
made, again for the protection of the public and those dealing with public companies
COMPANIES AND PARTNERSHIPS
In contrast to the company, the other main type of business association is the partnership. This is
an unincorporated association, where two or more persons associate for the purposes of business.
No other separate legal personality is brought into existence on the formation of the partnership,
and the business and all its assets remain the property of the partners. The Partnership Act 1890
defines a partnership as ‘[t]he relation which subsists between persons carrying on a business in
common with a view of profit’ and it specifically excludes the relationship which exists between
the members of a company. But, while companies can never be considered as partnerships,
companies themselves can be the partners in a partnership, for example, as part of a joint venture