COVID-19 pandemic and NCDs services and control - Scoping Review.pptx

Scoping review

1. COVID-19 pandemic and NCDs services and control in primary care settings in Indonesia Review questions and objectives Databases Search strategies Inclusion and exclusion Approach to screening Relevance to Indonesia

2. #01: Review questions How the pandemic has impacted the uptake of NCDs services and control in primary care settings in Indonesia? What are the key strategies, barriers and enablers for strengthening NCDs services and control in primary care settings during and after the pandemic?

3. #02: Objectives Objective 1: To document effects of the pandemic on the uptake of NCDs services and control in primary care settings in Indonesia (REVIEW 1) Objective 2: To identify barriers, enablers, and coping strategies, to strengthening the delivery of NCDs services and control in primary care settings during and after the pandemic in Indonesia (REVIEW 2)

4. #03: Databases Journal databases: Scopus, PUBMED/MEDLINE, Web of Science, CINAHL Grey literature: Google Scholars (by relevance), WHO Websites and Publications, WHO COVID Database, Ministry of Health of Indonesia Websites and Publications, Knowledge Sector Initiatives Publications Indonesian Literature Database: Neliti Sites, Portal Garuda, Arjuna

5. #04: Search strategies Key words for each concepts: Pandemic: COVID OR COVID-19 OR SARS-COV-2 OR pandemic NCDs: NCDs OR non-communicable disease OR chronic disease OR (individual NCD conditions) Primary care: [“primary care” OR “primary health care” OR “general practice” OR “community health centre*” OR “ puskesmas ” OR “family phycisian ” AND NOT “hospital care” OR “secondary care” OR “tertiary care ”] Uptake: [utilisation OR uptake OR coverage OR usage OR referral* OR hospitalisation OR access ] Coping strategies: [barrier* OR enabler* OR facilitator* OR innovation* OR intervention* OR strategy* OR polic *]

6. #04: Search strategies Review 01: UPTAKE/EFFECTS Key concepts: pandemic + NCDs + primary care + uptake Search strategies: #1 AND #2 AND #3 AND #4 Review 02: COPING STRATEGIES Key concepts: pandemic + NCDs + primary care + coping strategies Search strategies: #1 AND #2 AND #3 AND #5

7. #05: Inclusion and exclusion criteria Inclusion: Papers examining effects of COVID-19 pandemic on NCDs services/control/program will be considered Papers that have primary focus on primary care settings will be considered Papers containing primary data will be considered All study designs will be considered Papers published in English or Indonesia will be considered Papers that have primary focus on Indonesia or parts of Indonesia will be considered Exclusion: Book review, conference abstract, letters and short commentaries will be excluded Papers that mainly discuss effects of COVID-19 on hospital care

8. #06: Approach to screening Independent screening by two reviewers Conflict addressed by discussion, if persist a third reviewer will be invited Similar approach will be applied to title/abstract and full-text screening Two steps screening: title/abstract and full-text screening

9. #07: Relevance to Indonesia Review questions and objectives were identified in collaboration with local stakeholders in Bali Primarily looking at studies conducted in Indonesia Involving Indonesia’s databases ( Neliti , Garuda, Arjuna ) Potential approach for Review 2: Also looking at studies outside of Indonesia (especially from the Asia and pacific Region) – context analysis will be performed in the analysis to increase its relevance to Indonesia