Fenômeno de RaynaudFenômeno de Raynaud
NATURE REVIEWS | RHEUMATOLOGY VOLUME 8 | AUGUST 2012 | 471
NO-mediated vasodilatation in Raynaud phenomenon
is highly complex.
14
NO relaxes smooth muscle cells. In
sclerodermatous skin, endo thelial NO synthase (NOS) is
initially increased, whereas in advanced disease, induc-
ible NOS is increased.
15
The roles of the different isoforms
of NOS in cutaneous vasodilatation are currently unclear
10
and reduced NO production via neuronal NOS could also
have a role, at least in SSc,
16
demonstrating the interplay
between ‘vascular’ and ‘neural’ abnormalities. Further
complicating the role of NO, in patients with SSc, the
plasma levels of an endogenous inhibitor of endothelial
NOS—asymmetric dimethylarginine—are increased.
17
However, irrespec tive of whether there is underproduc-
tion or overproduc tion of NO in the digits of patients
with SSc (which could be disease-stage-dependent), NO
supplementation (for example, via topical application of
glyceryl trinitrate) results in vasodilatation. This response
could be as good in patients with SSc as in patients with
primary Raynaud phenomenon and healthy controls.
18
Increased vasoconstriction
Overproduction of vasoconstrictors by endothelial cells
(in particular endothelin-1 and angiotensin II) most
likely contributes to SSc-related Raynaud phenomenon.
The expression of endothelin-1 is increased in sclero-
dermatous skin.
19
An imbalance in the renin– angiotensin
system, in favour of angiotensin II, is thought to occur
in SSc.
20
Although some studies implicated a role for
endothelin-1 in primary Raynaud phe nomenon,
11,21
this
evidence is much weaker than that for SSc. One excit-
ing development in recent years has been the increased
understanding of signal transduction pathways in vas-
cular smooth muscle, as discussed below briefly, which
highlights the fact that ‘vascular’ and ‘neural’ mechanisms
cannot be considered in isolation.
Structural abnormalities
Structural abnormalities of both the microvasculature
and the digital arteries are well studied in SSc,
22,23
and
undoubtedly, contribute to impaired digital perfusion. The
microangiopathy of SSc can be clearly demonstrated non-
invasively by capillaroscopy (Figure 2). Typical changes
are enlarged, widened capillaries (through which the red
blood cells move sluggishly) with areas of avascularity
(Figure 2b). The most striking change in the digital artery
is intimal hyperplasia (Figure 3). The ulnar artery may
also be affected in SSc,
24
and it has been suggested that
the prevalence of proximal large vessel disease is increased
in patients with SSc compared to control population;
25
however, this finding remains controversial.
The pathogenesis of SSc-related microvascular and
digital artery structural vascular disease is well studied.
14,26–28
Although the pathogenesis is not fully under stood, pro-
gress is being made and possible contributors include
endothelial injury (of unknown cause) as a potential early
or initiating mechanism, endothelial cell apoptosis (which
might promote fibrosis
29
), abnormal expression of tran-
scription factors,
28
aberrant production of growth factors
and cytokines, activation of pericytes,
30
and abnormalities
of both angiogenesis and vasculo genesis (with a reduction
in bone- marrow-derived endothelial precursors).
31
A
recent study has shown that the anti-angiogenic vascular
endothelial growth factor (VEGF) isoform VEGF
165
b is
over expressed in SSc.
32
This finding could explain, at least
in part, the marked attrition of microvessels.
By contrast, structural abnormalities do not occur in
primary Raynaud phenomenon: any reported abnor-
malities have been subtle changes
33
and could possi-
bly relate to the unclear distinction between primary
Raynaud phenomenon and SSc. A small proportion of
patients (1–2% per year) with what appears to be primary
Ray naud phenomenon progress to an SSc-spectrum dis-
order or other underlying disease.
34
The thumb is less
affected by Raynaud phenomenon than other digits:
35
the reason for this reduced effect is unknown, but could
imply that its shorter length is in some way protective for
structural (and possibly functional) change.
Neural abnormalities
Several different neurotransmitters and their receptors
are implicated in the pathogenesis of Raynaud phenom-
enon, as many of these neurotransmitters mediate either
vasodilatation or vasoconstriction. Both autonomic and
small sensory nerve fibres are likely to be involved.
Nerve bres
(sympathetic
and sensory)
Smooth muscle cell
Endothelial cell
Endothelin-1
from endothelial cells
Oxidative stress
Endothelial damage
Reduced blood ow/
procoagulant tendency
NO
from endothelial cells
Platelet activation/
aggregation
Reactivity of smooth muscle
α
2
-adrenoceptors (via
Rho/Rho kinase activation)
Thrombin
Viscosity
Fibrinolysis
Red blood cell
deformability
Vasoconstriction Vasodilatation
Vasodilatatory neuropeptides
(e.g. CGRP) from sensory
afferents
Figure 1 | Schematic representation of some of the key elements and
mechanisms contributing to the pathogenesis of Raynaud phenomenon. Some of
the mediators contribute to disease pathogenesis via different mechanisms. For
example, reactive oxygen species (resulting in oxidative stress) may damage the
endothelium via lipid peroxidation, but may also activate Rho/Rho kinase resulting
in increased vasoconstriction. Abbreviations: CGRP, calcitonin gene-related
peptide; NO, nitric oxide. Modified from Herrick, A. L. Pathogenesis of Raynaud’s
phenomenon, Rheumatology 44, 587–596 (2005), by permission of Oxford
University Press.
R E V I E W S
© 2012 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved