Earliest challenge: Napoleon
Bonaparte (1769-1821)
*Emperor of the French Empire
*Sought to spread the principles
of the French Revolution across
Europe (Napoleonic Wars, 1803-
1815)
Napoleonic code:
◼Forbade birth privileges,
freedom of religion,
meritocracy in
government service
An Alternative:Socialist
internationalism
•Karl Marx
•“Workers of the world unite”
•“The proletariat has no
nation”
•Marxist anti-nationalism:
affinity to the nation retards
the worker’s struggle
The birth of LiberalInternationalism
Immanuel Kant (1795):
◼“Forstatesintheirrelationto
eachother,therecannotbe
anyreasonablewayoutof
thelawlessconditionwhich
entailsonlywarexceptthat
they,likeindividualmen,
shouldgiveuptheirsavage
[lawless]freedom, adjust
themselvestotheconstraints
ofpubliclaw,andthus
establisha continuously
growingstateconsistingof
variousnationswhichwill
ultimatelyincludeallthe
nationsoftheworld.”
What this means:
•Agreements among states
merely avert war
•Nationsneededtogiveup
theirfreedomandsubject
themselves toalarger
systemoflaw(analogue
withcitizensinacountry)
•A form of global
government needed to
createandenforcethese
laws
AnAlternative:Socialistinternationalism
Karl Marx and Friedrich Angels
“Workers of the world unite! You have nothing to
lose but your chains.”
Major challenge to internationalism
Hitler saw both variants
internationalism as an attack
on the nation
Fascists believed in the
primacy of ethnic majorities