Why basal angiosperms are considered primitive?
1. Retention of Ancestral Traits
Basal angiosperms retain many characteristics that are considered primitive or ancestral
compared to the more derived traits seen in most modern flowering plants. These traits
include features of their flowers, vascular tissue, and reproductive strategies.
Basal angiosperms exhibit characteristics that are similar to those found in
gymnosperms (non-flowering seed plants) and other early-diverging seed plants. These
traits are thought to have been present in the earliest flowering plants.
Example: Amborella trichopoda (the only species in the Amborellales order) lacks vessels in
its xylem, a characteristic seen in more primitive plants like gymnosperms. Most other
angiosperms have more specialized water-conducting cells known as vessels.
2. Simple Floral Structures
In basal angiosperms, the flowers often have a less specialized structure. For instance, the
flowers tend to have numerous, spirally arranged petals, sepals, stamens, and carpels,
rather than the distinct and reduced number of floral organs typical of more advanced
angiosperms.
The flowers of basal angiosperms are often simple and unspecialized compared to those in
more derived groups. They tend to have fewer floral parts, and those parts are less
differentiated. In many cases, the floral organs are arranged in a spiral, a feature seen in
gymnosperms, rather than in distinct whorls.
Example: In Nymphaea (water lilies, part of Nymphaeales), the floral parts are often
numerous and spirally arranged, which is considered a primitive characteristic.
Example: Austrobaileya scandens (in the Austrobaileyales order) has large, simple, and
unspecialized flowers that exhibit spiral phyllotaxis, similar to early plant forms.
3. Undifferentiated Floral Organs
Basal angiosperms often have floral organs that are not distinctly separated into sepals,
petals, stamens, and carpels. In more derived angiosperms (monocots and eudicots), the floral
organs are usually clearly differentiated.
Example: In Amborella, the distinction between sepals and petals is not as clear, and the
flower parts are often intermediate in structure, a sign of primitive floral development.
4. Pollination Mechanisms
Pollen Structure: The pollen of basal angiosperms typically has a single pore or furrow
(monosulcate), which is considered a primitive characteristic, as opposed to the more
complex pollen structures seen in derived angiosperms.
The pollination mechanisms of basal angiosperms are generally less specialized. In contrast,
more derived angiosperms have evolved intricate relationships with specific pollinators,
such as bees, birds, or bats, leading to highly specialized flowers.