Aircraft Accident
Investigation
By:
Chinmay Patel
Roll No: 98001019
Outline
History of Flight Data Recording
Recording and Storage of Data
Flight Data Recorder (FDR)
Cockpit Voice Recorder (CVR)
Crash Survivability Features
Post Crash Procedures
Information Retrieval
Aircraft Reconstruction as a Technique
History
Wright Brother’s
recording of propeller
rotations
First Generation FDRs
Stainless Steel Tape
200 to 400 hrs of
information
1958: 1
st
mandate in
USA
1960: 1
ST
mandate in
UK
First Generation FDR
History
1970s: Second
Generation FDRs
FDAUs introduced
Magnetic Tapes used
1991: Solid State
Memory FDRs
34 Parameters for 25
hrs
Second Generation FDR
Recording and Storage
Magnetic Tapes
Track about 100 Parameters
30 minutes of CVR audio
Solid State Memory Boards: Stacked array of
memory chips
No moving parts
More reliable
More Parameters (~ 700)
25 hrs of FDR data + 2 hrs of CVR audio
Data Acquisition
Location on the Aircraft
FDR
Sensors FDAU
FDR
Minimum of 11 to 29
Parameters to be
Recorded
Eg: Time, Pressure
Altitude, Airspeed,
Heading, Accelerations,
Control Surface Settings,
Fuel Flow, Engine RPM
& Temperature… etc
Solid State FDR
CVR
Records all kinds of Cockpit Conversation,
Warning alerts & Noises
Various Microphones in the Cockpit record
sounds Pre-amplified Digitized
Stored
Re-write older material
Provide an idea of the Crew’s Situation &
Decisions taken
Crash Survivability
Crash Survivable
Memory Unit (CSMU)
Damage resistant
features
Aluminum housing
Dry Silica Layer for
insulation
Steel/Titanium shell
Thoroughly tested
against impact, fire and
environmental damage
Post Crash Procedures
Locating the Black Box
Orange in color
Underwater Locator
Beacon
Pulses of 37.5 kHz
every second for 30
days
Can transmit sound
from 14000 ft under
water
Can be tracked by
Ultrasound Sensors
Black Boxes are transported
with utmost care
Kept in environment identical
to that in which it was found
ULB
Information Retrieval
Manufacturers supply NTSB with H/W & S/W
for Data Retrieval
Team of experts interprets the data from FDR
and the CDR audio
A typical team includes:
Airline representative
Airplane Manufacturer representative
NTSB Transportation-Safety Specialist
NTSB Air-Safety Investigator
Aircraft Reconstruction
2D as well as 3D reconstruction
Decide
Origin & Cause of Failure
Chain of Events
Important investigation technique
Better understanding of Failure Modes
Helps in ruling out false theories
Assurance that no possibility is left out
Comet G-ALYP Reconstruction
De Havilland Comet (1954)
Mid-air Explosion: 35 lives lost
Reconstruction provided clue to failure modes
Culprit: Fatigue failure of the stressed skin
TWA 800 Reconstruction
Boeing 747-131 (1996)
Mid-air Explosion
230 lives lost
Several Controversies
Reconstruction helped
to rule out false theories
Total of 876 pieces
arranged
Culprit: Explosion in
central fuel tank