This presentation would briefly touch upon the updated terminologies, causes, mechanism of drowning and management.
Size: 11.44 MB
Language: en
Added: Sep 18, 2022
Slides: 60 pages
Slide Content
Drowning and Near Drowning – Pathophysiology & Management Dr. Ipsita Mahapatra, PGT, Dept. of Pediatrics Gauhati Medical College and Hospital
1. Definition “ A process resulting in primary respiratory impairment from submersion/immersion in a liquid medium .” - World Congress on Drowning (Amsterdam, 2002) Presence of a liquid/air interface at the entrance of the patient’s airway The term ‘drowning’ does not imply the final outcome – death or survival. The outcome should be denoted as fatal or non-fatal drowning.
Submersion E ntire body to be covered in a liquid medium A irway, in its entirety, is under the liquid medium Immersion A body part is covered in a liquid medium; it does not require the entire body to be underwater. O ral and nasal airways must be under water or other liquid medium, limiting the victim’s ability to breathe.
The International Liaison Committee on Resuscitation (ILCOR), WHO and the World Congress on Drowning recommends that ambiguous terms such as ‘dry and wet drowning, active and passive drowning, near drowning, and secondary drowning’ should no longer be used. C onfusing and not clinically relevant. S impler, more uniform “ Utstein ” style of terminology should be used . The Utstein approach to the evaluation of drowning victims standardizes reporting and data collection and also provides guidance for the history, physical examination, and appropriate management.
Revised utstein drowning data collection form
Types of drowning These terminologies are no longer used. Near drowning : Survival of atleast 24 hours after an episode of suffocation caused by submersion in a liquid medium. Wet vs dry drowning : Dry-drowning is due to larynogospasm following a sudden immersion into water which leads to asphyxia and subsequently, hypoxia. There is no collection of water within the alveoli. Wet - drowning is due to aspiration of more amount of liquid resulting in collection of water within the alveoli.
Fresh water vs salt water drowning : There is no significant clinical difference between the two. Historically, it was felt to affect electrolytes, cause fluid shifting and cause hemolysis. I ntravascular blood volume changes - atleast 11ml/kg of fluid E lectrolyte changes - atleast 22ml/kg of fluid Most patients aspirate <4ml/kg of water T he distinction between salt water and fresh water drowning are no longer considered significant. Secondary drowning : Any secondary condition (Heart disease, epilepsy, alcohol use etc ) leading to loss of consciousness in water, thereby, drowning.
2. Statistics and global impact of drowning P oorly studied and vastly underestimated . Deaths due to accidents are not counted in drowning. R anks as the third leading cause of unintentional injury deaths worldwide and in South-east Asia, after road traffic injuries and falls. Majority of fatalities occur in low- and middle- income countries. >50% of drowning cases occur in WHO Western Pacific and South-East Asia regions.
In India, majority of drowning cases are reported from the states of Madhya Pradesh and Maharashtra. According to a December 2019 Lancet report on estimates of ‘healthy life’ lost in India, the rate of years of life lost (YLL) by drowning were highest in the central states of Madhya Pradesh (MP), Maharashtra, Chhattisgarh and NE state Assam.
3. epidemiology Drowning has one of the highest case fatality rates and is in the top-10 causes of death related to unintentional injuries for all pediatric age groups. Highest rates of drowning deaths in 2 age groups : 1-4 years and 15-19 years Males > Females
Children < 1year B athtub/household bucket L eft alone or with an elder sibling without adult supervision. Children 1-4 years Curious but unaware nature coupled with rapid progression of their physical capabilities. Lack of adult supervision In affluent countries, drownings are reported in residential swimming pools. In rural areas, drownings reported in irrigation ditches, nearby ponds, rivers.
School age children Natural water bodies such as lakes, ponds, rivers and canals. Drowning cases are mostly due to swimming or boating activities in this age group. Adolescents 90% of drowning cases occur in natural bodies of water Adolescent males >> females D ue to greater risk-taking behaviour , alcohol use, less perception of risks associated with drowning and greater confidence in their swimming ability.
4. Risk factors Males > Females Age < 14 years Low SE status and poor education Living in rural areas Epilepsy (15-19 times risk) Cardiac etiologies – arrythmias, myocarditis, prolonged QT syndromes (Cold water may prolong the QT interval) Substance abuse/intoxication Attempted self harm Trauma Abuse (bath-tub related drownings)
5. pathophysiology The primary physiologic effects of drowning are due to hypoxic-ischemic and reperfusion injuries. The “ drowning process ” is the stepwise progression of events leading to respiratory failure, hypoxia, and death .
Initial struggle for 20-30 seconds (unable to call for help as breathing takes priority) Submersion (airway below the surface of water) Panic, voluntary breath holding (60 seconds maximum). Small amount of water aspirated triggering cough reflex and laryngospasm Respiratory impairment leads to hypoxia, hypercarbia and acidosis Arterial oxygen tension decreases, laryngospasm abates and more water is aspirated
Cardiopulmonary arrest By 3-4 minutes, myocardial hypoxia leads to abrupt circulatory failure. Ineffective cardiac contractions with ineffective perfusion (Pulseless electrical activity) Progressively decreasing cardiac output and oxygen delivery to other organs Terminal apnea due to profound hypoxia and medullary depression Progressive decrease in SaO 2 , loss of consciousness from hypoxia
End organ effects Pulmonary Aspiration of 1-3 ml of liquid causes surfactant washout, increased capillary endothelial permeability Profound hypoxia, tachypnea, acid/base disturbances Poor lung compliance, intrapulmonary shunting, V/Q mismatch and atelectasis Acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS)
Cardiovascular systemic venous return from compressive forces on the upper and lower extremities, peripheral vasoconstriction Increased myocardial stretch, increased pulmonary artery pressure, and an increase in stroke volume, leading to increased cardiac output Lethal in pre-existing illness, such as congestive heart failure or pulmonary hypertension Central hypervolemia Swimming (including diving) can precipitate fatal ventricular arrythmias in patients with congenital long QT syndrome
Neurologic T he primary mechanisms of injury to the central nervous system are tissue hypoxia and ischemia which cause neuronal damage . Several hours after cardiopulmonary arrest, cerebral edema may develop (mechanism not clearly understood) The biggest determinants of outcome and long-term neurologic sequelae are the duration of submersion and the interval time between drowning and ventilation efforts. Approximately, 20% of nonfatal drowning victims sustain neurologic damage, limiting functional recovery despite successful cardiopulmonary resuscitation.
Renal Free water deficit and dehydration over time Increased glomerular blood flow, decreased free water reabsorption, and decreased vasopressin release from the hypothalamus Stretching of myocardium, release od Atrial Natriuretic peptide (ANP) Central hypervolemia ARF may occur (though rarely) due to lactic acidosis, prolonged hypoperfusion and rhabdomyolysis.
Acid-base and electrolytes: A metabolic and/or respiratory acidosis is often observed Coagulation : Hemolysis and coagulopathy are rare potential complications of non fatal drowning.
6. presentation Asymptomatic Patients Symptomatic Patients N o cough or dyspnea Normal vital signs No signs of hypoxia or tachypnea, Chest exam is normal (without crackles or wheezes) Altered sensorium Hypotension or shock Hypoventilation or absent pulse Cough or pulmonary rales in auscultation Asystole, arrythmias
7. Management Drowning chain of Survival The steps of the chain are: (1) prevent drowning; (2) recognize distress; (3) provide flotation; (4) remove from water; and (5) provide care
A drowning victim is usually silent and may not make violent movements in water. Management of drowning victims can be divided into 3 phases : Pre-hospital care Emergency department (ED) care Inpatient care Pre-hospital care (At the scene) Emergency department (ED) care Inpatient care
Pre-hospital care S cene safety, rapid extraction, and prompt basic life support are key to improve survival. Rescue and extrication : Swift water rescue training programs teach the adage “ Reach, Throw, Row, Go .” These are the four steps in water rescue with “progressively more risk to the rescuer.” Reach : Rescuers should start by reaching for the victim with an object, such as a paddle or branch Throw : If this fails, rescuers should throw a floatation device such as a throwbag or personal flotation device (PFD) to the victim. Row : If necessary, rescuers should proceed to take a boat to the victim. Go : As a last resort, rescuers should enter the water to rescue the victim. Rescue and immediate resuscitation efforts by bystanders improves the outcome of drowning patients.
Activate EMS if unconscious drowning victim CPR for drowning victims: traditional A-B-C approach with emphasis on ventilating the patient G ive two rescue breaths before proceeding to check the pulse and to give chest compressions if the patient is pulseless. Clear the airway of secretions, look out for vomiting, place the patient in rescue position. Cervical spine should be protected in anyone with potential traumatic neck injury. Remove wet clothing, passive external rewarming. Heimlich’s manoeuvre has no proven role. Patient should be immediately shifted to a nearby hospital.
During ambulance transportation/Emergency department care EMS personnel should do a primary survey on all drowning victims, including aggressive airway management and restoration of adequate oxygenation and ventilation. For a patient in cardiopulmonary arrest, an automatic external defibrillator (AED) should be applied as soon as possible and BLS/ACLS algorithms should be followed. Primary survey A: Airway : definite airway in the form of endotracheal intubation or with a suproglottic device if the patient has respiratory distress, is not able to protect the airway or has traumatic injuries .
B : Breathing : Consider giving PPV. The goal is to make the oxygen saturation above 92% C: Circulation: Vascular access must be established as quickly as possible for the administration on IV fluids and vasopressors. Epinephrine is drug of choice in victims with bradyasystolic cardiopulmonary arrest. IV dose of 0.01mg/kg using 1:10,000 (0.1mg/ml) solution should be given every 3-5 min, as needed. Epinephrine can be given intratracheally at a dose of 0.1 – 0.2 mg/kg of 1:1000 (1mg/ml) solution if no IV access is available. IV bolus of lactated Ringers solution or 0.9% NaCl (10-20 ml/kg) is to augment preload, repeated doses maybe necessary.
D: Disability : Neurological assessment using Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) has prognostic significance. E: Exposure : Hypothermic patients may require external rewarming.
Secondary Survey Detailed history with details of the drowning event to guide treatment and determine prognosis P hysical examination Relevant blood investigations must be ordered – CBC, electrolytes, RFT, glucose, screening for toxicology if indicated. ECG : Osborn waves ABG : Acidosis CXR : to look for evidence of aspiration, pneumonitis, atelectasis, pulmonary edema, and inhaled foreign bodies
Inpatient care Treatment is guided by Szpilman classification system of drowning grades for risk stratification and management. Inpatient management is aimed at supportive care and treatment of organ-specific complications. Goal is to prevent further secondary neurologic injury and minimize end-organ damage.
Check response to verbal and tactile stimuli Conscious Unconscious 5 breaths Lungs clear Rales Cough No cough Some All Grade 2 Grade 1 Grade 0 Normal BP Shock Grade 3 Grade 4 Pulse No pulse Check submersion time Grade 5 >1 hour, signs of death < 1 hour Grade 6 DEATH Consider autopsy
Medications Prophylactic broad spectrum antibiotics (change as per C/S) Consider antifungal and anaerobes if drowning in dirty water Treat bronchospasm : Salbutamol MDI/ Nebulisation In case of seizures, consider phenytoin or fosphenytoin (loading dose of 10-20mg/kg/day followed by maintenance of 5-8mg/kg/day). They are less sedative, may have some neuroprotective effects and may mitigate neurogenic pulmonary edema. Head end elevation to 30 degrees after ruling out cervical spine injury IV fluids (Hypotonic solutions should be avoided) Electrolyte management
Other strategies ECMO Prevention of raised ICP and management Mannitol Hypothermia management: Attention to core body temperature starts in the field and continues during transport and in the hospital. Goal is to prevent or treat moderate o r severe hypothermia. Damp clothes to be removed from all drowning victims. Passive, active external, active internal rewarming.
8. complications Death may occur due to – ARDS MODS Sepsis Post hypoxic encephalopathy Pulmonary edema Hypoxia Cerebral edema and raised ICP Hypothermia DIC Shock Myoglobinuria and Hemoglobinuria
9. Prognosis Markers of poor prognosis : Duration of submersion > 5 min Time to effective basic life support >10 minutes Resuscitation duration > 25 min Water temperature > 10 ◦ C Persistent apnea and requirement of cardiopulmonary resuscitation GCS < 6 at presentation Arterial pH < 7.1 upon presentation Markers of good prognosis : CPR in the field Resuscitation duration < 25 min Detectable pulse on arrival Core temperature < 35 ◦ C GCS ≥ 6 at presentation
35 – 60% of individuals needing continued CPR on arrival to the ED die. 10 – 20% of patients presenting with coma recover completely, despite fixed and dilated pupils with varying degrees of residual neurological deficit. Approximately 6% suffer a residual neurologic deficit. 75 % of drowning victims survive.
10. When to discharge ? Asymptomatic patients with normal CXR and blood investigations should be monitored for 6-8 hours prior to successful discharge. Symptomatic patients , once stabilized and recovered can be discharged as per the treating physician’s clinical assessment.
11. Preventive measures The WHO Global Report on Drowning (2016) outlines four strategies and six interventions for drowning prevention. 4 strategies Assam’s State Disaster Management Authority has produced a flood safety document, while the Government of Maharashtra’s Tourism Department has issued a notification for drowning prevention on beaches during bad weather. To ensure a comprehensive response to drowning, to identify and align efforts to prevent drowning deaths, and assign clear roles and responsibilities.
T o understand risk factors for drowning and assess the effectiveness of interventions Implementing mass media communication campaigns directly relevant to drowning prevention, dangers of consuming alcohol before or during swimming or boating activities, implementing initiatives to enhance awareness and highlight the vulnerability of children to drowning
6 interventions
12. Forensic autopsy internal findings of drowning Emphysema aquosum - Aspirated drowning medium in lungs and ballooning of lungs. Paltauf's spots – Subpleural hemorrhages due to rupture of alveolar capillaries Silt, weed or sand in airways, frothy fluid in conducting airway White or blood tinged froth at mouth, nostrils. P ink or red-tinged froth exuding from the lumen of the sectioned larynx, trachea, and bronchial tubes as well as the cut surfaces of the lung parenchyma.
13. Take home message Immediate resuscitative efforts is key! Consider associated co-morbidities (trauma/alcohol or drug intoxication/medical conditions) Development of pulmonary edema may take time, the clinical findings will always precede the radiological findings and the initial CXR maybe normal. N o clinical difference between salt water and fresh water drowning as in majority of cases the amount of aspirated liquid around 3-4 ml only. Majority of treatment is supportive . Asymptomatic patients should be monitored for 6-8 hours prior to successful discharge.
14. BiBliography 1. WHO Regional Status Report on Drowning in South-East Asia (2019) 2. New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) 3. The Lancet 4. Nelson Textbook of Pediatrics 5. Idris AH, et al. Recommended guidelines for uniform reporting of data from drowning: the “ Utstein style.” 6. Global burden of drowning, Paper Presented at World Congress on Drowning; 2002 7. Drowning (BLS): Systematic review, ILCOR