ROAD DESIGN MANUAL
PART 1: GEOMETRIC DESIGN OF RURAL ROADS
(CHAPTER 3 + DESIGN CONTROLS AND CRITERIA Page 3.10
2.9
ECONOMIC CONSIDERATIONS
‘me relationship between costs and benefits 18 a measure of Justif-
Seation, and often a deciding factor in determining the geometric
features of design. The costs include right-of-way (road reserve),
construction, maintenance and vehicle operation. The general value
resulting from an improved road Link includes services and benefits
to the country, community and road users. A high geometric design
Standard is varranced vhere there are sufficient benefits to road
users to justify the additional coste above that of a low design
standard. Particularly in the stages of planning the preliminary
design when decisions regarding location and general design parameters
are sade, the relationship between costs and benefite for different
alternatives is of great importance.
Preliminary or approxisate cost estisates should be made for each
Alternative plan. All major items should be included; road reserve
acquisition, site clearance, earthworks, drainage, fe, abructures
and, Where significant, relocation of utility services and the cost of
maintaining traffic during construction. Estimated annual costs of
maintaíning and operating the roadways, roadsides (@itches)and struc~
fares should also be included if there appear to be significant
differences between alternatives.
To complete a monetary analysis of alternative plans, the total road
user coste should be determined for each alternative, Road user coste
are the drivers’ vehicular operating costs and, where relevant, the
value of (gained) time. The total of the road user costs for each
alternative plan can be a good factor for comparison as they reflect
speed, distance (directness) and operating conditions.
À computer model called the “Road Transport Investment Model” (or
the “Highway Cost Model"), which estimates the costs of different
investment strategies for rural roads in developing countries, is
Operational in Kenya. It is based on research carried out mainly in
Kenya by the British Transport and Road Research Laboratory, and it can
provide useful assistance to the design engineer, as long as up-to-date
and relíable input data, especially on maintenance (procedures and
Productivity) and vehicle operation, are readily available.
+ Bau THRE Reporte 672, 673 and O74, Overseas Unit,
Transport and Road Research Laboratory Crowthorne,
Berkshire, England.