Subscription copy of [
[email protected]]. Redistribution prohibited.32 Wealth Insight June 2021
(YYP]PUNH[[OL7YVÄ[
I
n order to pick the Profit 100
companies, we focused not just
on profitability but also on the
reliability and durability of those
profits. That required us to use a
number of filters. Here they are in
detail.
MARKET CAPITALISATION OF MORE
THAN `500 CRORE: Due to
fewer disclosures,
substandard corporate
governance standards and lack of
transparency of smaller companies,
we restricted our analysis to
companies that have a market cap
of at least `500 crore.
LONG-TERM HORIZON: To ensure
analytical strength, we
removed companies that
didn’t have a 10-year record.
However, we included those
companies which were listed within
the last 10 years but have a track
record.
PROFITABILITY: Profits – the
lifeline of our cover story –
were the most important
criterion for our analysis. We
took into consideration companies
that have earned profits in all of
the last 10 years. Further, we zeroed
in on only those companies that
have maintained constant growth
of at least at 8 per cent in their
profitability over the years. Using
this criterion, we removed those
companies which are unable to pass
on their costs. Also, a company
earning similar profits year after
year may not create wealth for its
shareholders in the long run. As
many companies are yet to declare
their FY21 results, we have taken
trailing 12-month (TTM) profit
growth till December 2020 for the
latest year.
RETURN ON EQUITY (ROE): An
investor should prefer
investing in a company
with a high ROE as it shows
the company’s ability to deploy its
funds efficiently. To remove low-
ROE companies, we applied a
minimum threshold of ROE equal
to or more than 15 per cent. The
ROE for the current year has been
calculated by taking TTM earnings
as of December 2020 over total
equity as per the latest balance
sheet available.
EXCEPTIONALS: Many
companies report
exceptional incomes or
losses arising from asset
write-offs, litigation expenses or
disposal of assets. Some companies
report these items on a regular
basis. Such occurrences obscure the
true picture of a company’s
profitability. To avoid such cases, we
have removed companies which tend
to report huge exceptional items on
a regular basis. The companies
which had median exceptional items
of more than 10 per cent of their
profits in the last 10 years were not
covered in this list.
CONSISTENT PERFORMANCE:
Many companies are able to
deliver exceptional
performance in the short
term but cannot replicate it in the
long term and turn out to be wealth
destroyers for investors. To remove
companies with such exceptional
performance, we applied another
criterion: a minimum return on
equity of equal to or more than 15
per cent in at least six out of the
last 10 years. A similar criterion
was applied in the case of
profitability. Companies with year-
on-year profit growth of less than 8
per cent in six out of the 10 years
have been removed. However, we
gave a relaxation for four years to
adjust for cyclicality.
CASH FLOWS: In investing,
there is a popular saying:
turnover is vanity, profit
is sanity and cash is
reality. Many businesses have a
robust track record of profitability
but suffer from subdued operating
cash flows. Profits have no meaning
until they are converted into cash.
It is also considered a potential red
flag if a company earns handsome
profits but its cash flows are not in
order. We removed companies
having no positive cash flows in at
least eight years out of the last 10
years. We kept this criterion more
stringent than our return on equity
and profitability criteria, given the
fact that historically, the absence of
cash flows has translated into
potential corporate-governance
issues and subdued stock returns.
We excluded banking and financial
companies from these criteria as
cash flows are not relevant to them.
DEBT TO EQUITY: We removed
companies with debt-to-
equity of more than two
times in three or more
years over the last 10 years. Hence,
we filtered out companies which
are excessively dependent on
leverage for their healthy ROE or
profitability. We provided a
relaxation of two years to
incorporate companies which once
The methodology and the rationale for the filters used to find out India’s 100
most profitable companies