Does the Environment Play a
Role in the Spread of Infection -
and if so
- doing what counts!
Mary Brachman RN MS CIC
Presentation Overview
Infection Control ConceptsInfection Control Concepts
Level of DisinfectionLevel of Disinfection
Susceptibility of MicroorganismsSusceptibility of Microorganisms
Factors Affecting DisinfectionFactors Affecting Disinfection
Appropriate DisinfectantsAppropriate Disinfectants
Presentation Overview
Controversial IssuesControversial Issues
Antibiotic Resistant OrganismsAntibiotic Resistant Organisms
Blood and Body Fluid SpillsBlood and Body Fluid Spills
Isolation RoomsIsolation Rooms
Adding Value to the Organization Adding Value to the Organization
How are organisms
spread and who is
at risk?
Infectious Agents
Reservoirs
Portals of Exit
Transmission
Portals of Entry
Susceptible Host
Bacteria
Excretions
Contact
Mucous
membrane
People
Viruses
Secretions
Droplet
Broken Skin
Equipment
Fungus
Skin
Vehicle
GI Tract
Water
Parasites
Droplets
Airborne
GU Tract
Genetic
makeup
Underlying
disease
Environ-
ment
Skin
integrity
Vector
Respiratory
tract
The Chain of Infection
Breaking the
Chain of
Infection
Infectious
Agents
Reser-
voirs
Portals
of
Exit
Transmission
Modes
Portals
of
Entry
Suscep-
tible
Host
Breaking the
Chain of
Infection
Infectious
Agents
Reser-
voirs
Portals
of
Exit
Transmission
Modes
Portals
of
Entry
Suscep-
tible
Host
What’s the
“RIGHT”
Level of Disinfection?
Categories of Items Needing
Disinfection or Sterilization
CriticalCritical
SemicriticalSemicritical
Non-CriticalNon-Critical
Categories of Items Needing
Disinfection/or Sterilization
CriticalCritical
Enters sterile tissue or Enters sterile tissue or
vascular systemvascular system
CRITICAL
Categories of Items Needing
Disinfection or Sterilization
SemicriticalSemicritical
Touches mucous Touches mucous
membranes or membranes or
non-intact skinnon-intact skin
Categories of Items Needing
Disinfection/or Sterilization
Environmental SurfacesEnvironmental Surfaces
Housekeeping surfacesHousekeeping surfaces
Medical equipment surfacesMedical equipment surfaces
Non-Critical
Non-critical - housekeeping
surfaces
Non-critical - equipment
How RESISTANT Are
Microorganisms to
Disinfectants?
Descending Order of Resistance
to Chemical Disinfectants
Bacterial SporesBacterial Spores
Bacillus subtilisBacillus subtilis
MycobacteriaMycobacteria
Mycobacterium tuberculosisMycobacterium tuberculosis
Nonlipid or small virusesNonlipid or small viruses
Polio VirusPolio Virus
FungiFungi
Trichophyton spp.Trichophyton spp.
Vegetative BacteriaVegetative Bacteria
Pseudomonas Pseudomonas
StaphylococcusStaphylococcus
Lipid or medium-sized virusesLipid or medium-sized viruses
Hepatitis B Virus (HBV)Hepatitis B Virus (HBV)
Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)
Favero, MS in Block SS.
Disinfection, Sterilization & Preservation, 1991
Hard to kill
Easy to kill
Descending Order of Resistance
to Chemical Disinfectants
Bacterial Spores STBacterial Spores ST
Bacillus subtilisBacillus subtilis
HLDHLD
Mycobacteria ILDMycobacteria ILD
Mycobacterium tuberculosis Mycobacterium tuberculosis
Nonlipid or small viruses LLDNonlipid or small viruses LLD
Polio VirusPolio Virus
FungiFungi
Trichophyton spp.Trichophyton spp.
Vegetative BacteriaVegetative Bacteria
PseudomonasPseudomonas
StaphylococcusStaphylococcus
Lipid or medium-sized virusesLipid or medium-sized viruses
Hepatitis B Virus (HBV)Hepatitis B Virus (HBV)
Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)
Favero, MS in Block SS.
Disinfection, Sterilization & Preservation, 1991
What factors
influence the
EFFECTIVENESS
of the
disinfection process?
Factors Influencing
Disinfectant Activity
Number & location of organismsNumber & location of organisms
Resistance of organismsResistance of organisms
ConcentrationConcentration
Factors Influencing
Disinfectant Activity (con’t)
Water hardness and temperatureWater hardness and temperature
Organic matterOrganic matter
Contact timeContact time
Characteristics Of An Ideal
Disinfectant
Broad spectrumBroad spectrum
Fast actingFast acting
Good cleanerGood cleaner
Surface compatibilitySurface compatibility
Not affected by environmental factorsNot affected by environmental factors
* Rutala, Wm., in Hospital Epidemiology and Infection Control; Chapter * Rutala, Wm., in Hospital Epidemiology and Infection Control; Chapter
69; 199669; 1996
Characteristics Of An Ideal
Disinfectant (con’t)
Residual effectResidual effect
Water solubleWater soluble
Stable in concentrate and use-dilutionStable in concentrate and use-dilution
Easy to useEasy to use
EconomicalEconomical
* Rutala, Wm., in Hospital Epidemiology and Infection Control; Chapter * Rutala, Wm., in Hospital Epidemiology and Infection Control; Chapter
69;199669;1996
CONTROVERSIAL ISSUES
Antibiotic Resistant OrganismsAntibiotic Resistant Organisms
Clean Up of Blood & Body Fluids Clean Up of Blood & Body Fluids
Standard Precautions and Standard Precautions and
Isolation RoomsIsolation Rooms
Antibiotic Resistant
Organism
A microorganism that has A microorganism that has
developed resistance to developed resistance to
antibioticsantibiotics
Resistant Organisms:Resistant Organisms:
Why the Concern?Why the Concern?
Ineffective or no antibiotics
Poor patient outcomes
Delayed discharge
Increased costs
Patients Most at Risk for Patients Most at Risk for
Acquiring Resistant StrainsAcquiring Resistant Strains
Multiple medical problems
Long hospitalizations
Admitted to intensive care
Receiving antibiotics
Methicillin ResistantMethicillin Resistant
Staph aureusStaph aureus
Reservoir: Reservoir: SkinSkin
Contaminated Contaminated
equipment equipment or surfacesor surfaces
Transmission:Transmission:Direct skin to skin Direct skin to skin
contactcontact
Indirect contact via Indirect contact via
contaminated contaminated
equipment equipment or surfacesor surfaces
Resistance to Disinfectants: LowResistance to Disinfectants: Low
Descending Order of Resistance
to Chemical Disinfectants
Bacterial SporesBacterial Spores
Bacillus subtilisBacillus subtilis
MycobacteriaMycobacteria
Mycobacterium tuberculosisMycobacterium tuberculosis
Nonlipid or small virusesNonlipid or small viruses
Polio VirusPolio Virus
FungiFungi
Trichophyton spp.Trichophyton spp.
Vegetative BacteriaVegetative Bacteria
StaphylococcusStaphylococcus
Methicillin Resistant StaphMethicillin Resistant Staph
Lipid or medium-sized virusesLipid or medium-sized viruses
Hepatitis B Virus (HBV)Hepatitis B Virus (HBV)
Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)Adapted from: Favero, MS in Block SS.
Disinfection, Sterilization & Preservation, 1991
Hard to kill
Easy to kill
Vancomycin ResistantVancomycin Resistant
EnterococcusEnterococcus (VRE) (VRE)
Reservoir: Reservoir: BowelBowel
Contaminated Contaminated
equipment equipment or surfacesor surfaces
Transmission:Transmission:Direct contact with Direct contact with
fecesfeces
Indirect contact via Indirect contact via
contaminated contaminated
equipment equipment or surfacesor surfaces
Resistance to Disinfectants: LowResistance to Disinfectants: Low
Descending Order of Resistance
to Chemical Disinfectants
Bacterial SporesBacterial Spores
Bacillus subtilisBacillus subtilis
MycobacteriaMycobacteria
Mycobacterium tuberculosisMycobacterium tuberculosis
Nonlipid or small virusesNonlipid or small viruses
Polio VirusPolio Virus
FungiFungi
Trichophyton spp.Trichophyton spp.
Vegetative BacteriaVegetative Bacteria
EnterococcusEnterococcus
Vancomycin Resistant EnterococcusVancomycin Resistant Enterococcus
Lipid or medium-sized virusesLipid or medium-sized viruses
Hepatitis B Virus (HBV)Hepatitis B Virus (HBV)
Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)Favero, MS in Block SS.
Disinfection, Sterilization & Preservation, 1991
Hard to kill
Easy to kill
Surfaces hands . . .
Hands patient . . .
What are the
recommendations for
environmental
cleaning?
Environmental CleaningEnvironmental Cleaning
Standard Precautions
“Adequate procedures for
routine care, cleaning and
disinfecting of
environmental surfaces,…
CDC Guideline for Isolation Precautions in Hospitals;
AJIC Vol. 24, pp. 24-52; 1996
Environmental CleaningEnvironmental Cleaning
Standard Precautions
…beds, bedrails, bedside
equipment and other frequently
touched surfaces and that
procedures are being followed.”
CDC Guideline for Isolation Precautions in Hospitals;
AJIC Vol. 24, pp. 24-52; 1996
Appropriate Disinfectants For
Housekeeping Surfaces - CDC
““visible cleanliness using detergent and visible cleanliness using detergent and
warm water, warm water, oror
EPA hospital grade detergent- disinfectant”EPA hospital grade detergent- disinfectant”
Favero, M. in Chemical Germicides in Health Care; Ch. 4;1995Favero, M. in Chemical Germicides in Health Care; Ch. 4;1995
Appropriate Disinfectants For
Non-Critical Equipment - CDC
““detergent and warm water, detergent and warm water, OROR
cleaning plus application of intermediate to low-level disinfectant”cleaning plus application of intermediate to low-level disinfectant”
Favero, M. inFavero, M. in
Chemical Germicides in Health Care; Ch. 4;1995Chemical Germicides in Health Care; Ch. 4;1995
Environmental CleaningEnvironmental Cleaning
Airborne Precautions - same as
Standard Precautions
Droplet Precautions -
same as Standard Precautions
CDC Guideline for Isolation Precautions in Hospitals;
AJIC Vol. 24, pp. 24-52; 1996
Environmental Cleaning
Contact Precautions -Contact Precautions -
““adequate procedures for routine adequate procedures for routine
care, cleaning and disinfecting…”care, cleaning and disinfecting…”
dedicate non-critical equipment; dedicate non-critical equipment;
clean and disinfect between clean and disinfect between
patientspatients
CDC Guideline for Isolation Precautions in Hospitals; CDC Guideline for Isolation Precautions in Hospitals;
AJIC Vol. 24, pp. 24-52; 1996AJIC Vol. 24, pp. 24-52; 1996
Environmental Cleaning
Antibiotic Resistant Organisms
Acute Care Non-Acute Care
Non-Hand
Contact
When visibly soiled &
to maintain aesthetics
Detergent OK
When visibly soiled &
to maintain aesthetics
Detergent
Hand-
Contact
Daily cleaning
Detergent-
disinfectant
Regular cleaning & to
maintain aesthetics
No recommendations
on detergent vs.
disinfectant
ddfdf df
Global Consensus Conference on Antimicrobial
Resistance. March, 1999; Tornoto Canada
Environmental Cleaning
Antibiotic Resistant Organisms
Dedicate non-critical equipmentDedicate non-critical equipment
Clean & disinfect between patientsClean & disinfect between patients
Outbreak situations - additional cleaning Outbreak situations - additional cleaning
may be indicatedmay be indicated
Terminal cleaning - opportunity to clean Terminal cleaning - opportunity to clean
areas not routinely accessible areas not routinely accessible
Global Consensus Conference on Antimicrobial Resistance. March, Global Consensus Conference on Antimicrobial Resistance. March,
1999; Toronto Canada1999; Toronto Canada
Environmental Cleaning
Antibiotic Resistant Organisms
Identify surfaces frequently touched Identify surfaces frequently touched
Include these surfaces in daily and Include these surfaces in daily and
terminal cleanterminal clean
Review the cleaning processReview the cleaning process
Ensure compliance with proceduresEnsure compliance with procedures
OSHA Bloodborne OSHA Bloodborne
Pathogen StandardPathogen Standard
Clean Up ofClean Up of
Blood and Body FluidsBlood and Body Fluids
OSHA Bloodborne
Pathogen Standard
““work site maintained in a clean and work site maintained in a clean and
sanitary condition . . . contaminated sanitary condition . . . contaminated
work surfaces shall be decontaminated work surfaces shall be decontaminated
with an with an appropriate disinfectantappropriate disinfectant after after
completion of procedures; immediately completion of procedures; immediately
or as soon as feasible when or as soon as feasible when
contaminated or after any spill of blood contaminated or after any spill of blood
or other potentially infectious or other potentially infectious
materials . . .”materials . . .”
OSHA Bloodborne
Pathogen Standard
Appropriate DisinfectantAppropriate Disinfectant
Tuberculocidal (Phenolic)Tuberculocidal (Phenolic)
Sodium Hypochlorite (Bleach)Sodium Hypochlorite (Bleach)
Quat with HIV/HBV claimQuat with HIV/HBV claim
OSHA Bloodborne
Pathogen Standard
Must follow label instructionsMust follow label instructions::
Personal protective equipmentPersonal protective equipment
Clean surface before disinfectingClean surface before disinfecting
Leave surface wet:Leave surface wet:
30 seconds HIV30 seconds HIV
10 minutes HBV10 minutes HBV
Descending Order of Resistance
to Chemical Disinfectants
Bacterial SporesBacterial Spores
Bacillus subtilisBacillus subtilis
MycobacteriaMycobacteria
Mycobacterium tuberculosisMycobacterium tuberculosis
Nonlipid or small virusesNonlipid or small viruses
Polio VirusPolio Virus
FungiFungi
Trichophyton spp.Trichophyton spp.
Vegetative BacteriaVegetative Bacteria
Pseudomonas Pseudomonas
StaphylococcusStaphylococcus
Lipid or medium-sized virusesLipid or medium-sized viruses
Hepatitis B Virus (HBV)Hepatitis B Virus (HBV)
Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)
Favero, MS in Block SS.
Disinfection, Sterilization & Preservation,
1991
Hard to kill
Easy to kill
OSHA Directive Can Be OSHA Directive Can Be
ChallengedChallenged
Non-tuberculocidal disinfectants Non-tuberculocidal disinfectants
(e.g. quats) inactivate HBV(e.g. quats) inactivate HBV
Non-critical surfaces rarely Non-critical surfaces rarely
involved in disease transmissioninvolved in disease transmission
Exposure time manufacturers Exposure time manufacturers
use to achieve label claims are use to achieve label claims are
not used for non-critical surfacesnot used for non-critical surfaces
OSHA Directive:
Implications for Practice
Use scientific literature to determine Use scientific literature to determine
practice; use quatpractice; use quat
Risk OSHA citation and fineRisk OSHA citation and fine
At Hospitals Discretion
How Do You
Add Value
to the Organization?
Cost Analysis - Quat vs Phenolic
Direct costsDirect costs
Labor: salaries and benefitsLabor: salaries and benefits
MaterialsMaterials
fixed costs fixed costs
variable costsvariable costs
Indirect costsIndirect costs
Labor: salaries and trainingLabor: salaries and training
Opportunity costOpportunity cost
Problems associated with procedureProblems associated with procedure
Slay the Sacred Cows
Disinfectants for cleaning:Disinfectants for cleaning:
hallways, conference rooms, nurses station, utility roomshallways, conference rooms, nurses station, utility rooms
non-hand-contact surfaces in patient rooms non-hand-contact surfaces in patient rooms (unless more (unless more
practical)practical)
Phenolics for environmental cleaningPhenolics for environmental cleaning
Excessive cleaning of OR walls, floorsExcessive cleaning of OR walls, floors
10 minute contact time for non-critical surfaces10 minute contact time for non-critical surfaces
Slay the Sacred Cows
““Special cleaning” for Isolation Rooms Special cleaning” for Isolation Rooms (in (in
absence of visible soil)absence of visible soil)
changing cubical curtainschanging cubical curtains
preparing fresh solution before cleaningpreparing fresh solution before cleaning
discarding solution after cleaning discarding solution after cleaning
changing mop heads changing mop heads
washing walls and stripping floorswashing walls and stripping floors
Wearing scrub apparel for infection controlWearing scrub apparel for infection control
Red bags for “non-infectious” wasteRed bags for “non-infectious” waste
Breaking the
Chain of
Infection
Infectious
Agents
Reser-
voirs
Portals
of
Exit
Transmission
Modes
Portals
of
Entry
Suscep-
tible
Host