Difference between Quran and
Hadith
Dr. Amina Nakimuli
Quran
Speech of Allah sent down upon the prophet Muhammad pbuh through the angel Gabriel in its precise
meaning and wording transmitted to us by numerous persons both verbally and in writing
It is inimitable and unique
Protected by God-mentioned in the Quran
Hadith
Hadith
Linguistic meaning of Hadith are
news, reports
or narrations
In Islamic context a particular report
(verbal and written) about the sunnah
of the Prophet Muhammad
What is Sunnah?
Literal meaning is
the road or
practice
Religious context
what has been
described by
Prophet
Muhammad and
what he said and
did in continuous
manner so that
others follow.
Saying of Prophet Muhammad pbuh
Action of Prophet Muhammad pbuh
Approval (silent) of Prophet Muhammad pbuh in other
actions (companions)
Action on the Prophet Muhammad pbuh that are related to
Islam and the Prophet pbuh wanted us to act upon directly
or indirectly by mentioning the virtue of such act
Quran
Speech of Allah sent down
upon the prophet Muhammad
pbuh through the angel
Gabriel in its precise meaning
and wording transmitted to us
by numerous persons both
verbally and in writing
It is inimitable and unique
Protected by God-mentioned
in the Quran
Hadith
Qudsi
Meaning from Allah
while wording from the
Prophet Muhammad
pbuh
Communicated from
Allah through revelation
or in dreams then
communicated by
Prophet Muhammad
pbuh in his own words
Prophet relates to the
people what Allah has
said or did (does) but
not a part of Quran
•Abu Hurairah reported that
Allah’s messenger said
“Allah mighty and exalted is
He; said if my servant like
to meet me I like to meet
him, if he dislike me to
meet I dislike to meet him.
Hadith:
The Condition for the Acceptance of
Hadith
A Hadith must meet the
following five criteria in order
to be accepted in Islamic law
as a source of legal ordinance
Continuity of the change of
transmitters:
•chain of transmitters has to be
unbroken in order for the hadith to
be accepted.
•The transmitter must not be
missing from the chain of narrators
•Transmitter must have heard the
hadith directly from the
transmitter before him
•It is verified with biographical
science of hadith
The integrity of the transmitters:
Integrity of transmitters is established
in terms how they practice Islam.
They are not engaged in doing
forbidden things and must be
righteous and pious
Again should be verified through the
biographical science of Hadith
Soundness of Memory of transmitters
•must be verified through biographical science
of Hadith that transmitter has a sound memory or
his books were accurate and directly transmitted
from his book
Conformity of the
Hadith
•The conformity should be
both in the chain of
transmitters and in the text
Absence of Defects
•A defect in hadith is
defined as hidden defect in
the hadith which takes
away from its authenticity
•Hadith which appears to be
free from all defects in
beginning but after
thorough investigation
finds some defects
which can be in the chain
of transmitters or in the
text
Classification of Hadith
There are 2 types
of Hadiths:
The recurrent
Hadith (al-Hadith
al-mutawatir)
and the senses.
•This type of hadith is decisive, has no doubt that it actually came
from Prophet Muhammad pbuh
•Conditions of Mutawatir Hadith- Recurrent Hadith
•1. at Least four different people must have narrated the hadith
•2. Must be impossible for those four or more people to concur on a
lie.
•3. They must have narrated the hadith from the same people (first
2 conditions being applicable) from the beginning of the chain of
transmitters until the end of it
•4. The narration on the Hadith must rely on the mind
The non recurrent Hadith (al-hadith al-ahad)
Any Hadith which is not recurrent (mutawatir) is
called non-recurrent (ahad). This category is divided
into three sub categories according to number of
narrator of the Hadith.
The well known Hadith (al-Hadith al-mashhur). This
hadith which has been narrated by three or more
people in the chain of transmitters but did not arrive
at the rank of the recurrent hadith
The strong hadith (al-hadith al-aziz) this is a hadith in
which there are no less than 2 narrators in each part
of the chain on narrators
The rare Hadith (al-
hadith al-gharib) this is a
hadith which is narrated
by a single person at one
point in the chain of
transmitters
The non-recurrent is also sub divided in the three more
classifications regarding the beginning of the chain of transmitters
Elevated Hadith (al-hadith al-Marfu) This
is a hadith the chain or narrators fro
which begins prophet Muhammad pbuh
The Suspended Hadith (al-Hadith al-
mawquf) this hadith the chain of
narrators does not trace the Prophet
pbuh but instead a companion of the
Prophet
Elevated Hadith (al-hadith al-Marfu) This
is a hadith the chain or narrators fro
which begins prophet Muhammad pbuh
The Suspended Hadith (al-Hadith al-
mawquf) this hadith the chain of
narrators does not trace the Prophet
pbuh but instead a companion of the
Prophet
Authentic Hadith (al-hadith as-sahih). This is
a hadith which satisfies the 5 criteria of
acceptance of hadith.
The good Hadith (al-hadith al-hasan) this is
the hadith which like the authentic hadith
also satisfies the five criteria except the third
criteria of soundness of memory of the
transmitters is only slightly satisfied.
The weak hadith (al-hadith al-da’if) This
is hadith which does not satisfy all the
five criteria for acceptance of hadith
Weakness in the Hadith due to lacking
continuity
Continuity is missing at the end of the
chain, hanging (mu’allaq)
contues
Continuity is
missing in
the middle of
the chain of
transmitters,
interrupted
(munqati’)
•It 2 successive
transmitters or more are
missing in the middle of
the chain or transmitters
, problematic (mu’dil)
•If the first transmitter,
a companion of
Prophet Muhammad
pbuh is missing from
the chain of
transmitters, the
hadith is called
incompletely
transmitted (mursal)
Three sub
groupings
of hadith
are
classified
as:
•Forged transmitters-
hadith which transmitter
had transmitted from
other transmitter who he
has met but under whom
he did not study, implying
that he heard from him
•Forged regarding teachers
•Forged regarding naming
of transmitters
•If one of the transmitter of
the hadith is not named it
is called obscure
If something has been added to the
hadith then it is known as interpolated
Weakness due inaccuracy of memories
of transmitters
•Transmitted by a different weak channel -shaky
•Change in wording of the hadith- interpolated
•Inversion in the words of the chain of narrators or
text of the hadith –inverted