HARD And SOFT Approach t o HRM Bibek Regmi MBS T.U
HARD Approach Employees are simply resources of the business Instrumental approach toward managing employees . HARD HRM = stresses `the quantitative, calculative and business- strategic,task aspects
FOCUS HIRING MOVING FIRING
Features Taller Organizational Structures Hierarchical Command and Control No delegation of authority
Leadership Autocratic Leadership Style Employees are only instructed on how to do their job, rather than taking part in decision making
Training And Development Designed on current job requirement Based on responding to current needs Initiated by HR/Top management Emphasizes productivity needs
Appraisals Judgmental appraisal Evaluation process is informal Evaluation process is on-going Evaluated as individuals Evaluation used for reward and remedial
Pay – enough to recruit and retain enough staff Std and Fixed package Employees feel job is secure Wage adjustment based on seniority Salary determined by market rates
Communication Minimal Communication Top-Down
Soft HRM Approach Employees are the most important resource Source of competitive advantage SOFT HRM = People-Focused / High-Commitment
“Train your Employee Enough Train them so much So that anybody can pay them Double Salary Of what you are giving them “ 2 Richard Branson Theory “ Treat them well Enough So they don’t want to Leave “
Focus EMPLOYEE EMPOWERMENT
Features Few layers Shared Culture Two-Way Communication
Team Cohesiveness Employees trust each other Employees work as a team Encourage to learn each others tasks Organization is relationship oriented Supervisors help to build cohesive team Employees assist each other
Work Environment Working environment is of trust and warm Employees have influence at workplace Environment is amiable Comfortable rest and recreation areas Supervisor is approachable
Communication Flow Employees appreciate management giving accurate information Explanation on importance of tasks Employees briefed on development plans Open communication with supervisors Regular feedback on performance
Democratic Leadership Opinions are asked, consulted
Appraisal System focuses on identifying Training and Development needs. Pay and Performance related Rewards
Employees promoted from within whenever possible Promoted from within, internal vacancy Succession Planning
Work Force Planning
Based on Attitude and Integration with T eam
Which is best? Soft or Hard HRM? “ It Depends.”
HARD HRM 23 Useful when Management have Expertise 2. Quicker Decision Making 3. Cost Effective Leads to Poor Employee Relation 2 . Job Hopper/Staff Turnover 3.Less Successful Recruitment
Soft HRM Useful when employees are experienced Employee Loyalty Use of Skill Decision making needs more time Costly Approach Leads to RS.
Practitioners In this context 25
We practice Soft HRM Of the people By the people For the people
Nepal Perspective HARD HRM Banking Industry Private Company SOFT HRM Public Service Commission NGO/INGO
Conclusion So We Can Say, Situation of an Organization & Behaviour of the Employees Convey Steward Which is the Best Fitted to Follow !!!