Health service management(2)
13,817 views
95 slides
Dec 12, 2017
Slide 1 of 95
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
About This Presentation
Health Service Managements for students of Public health, Nurses, Medicine, Midwives
Slide Content
1
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
HEALTH SERVICE MANAGEMENT
By
Mohamed Hassan Mohamed
M.Sc. in Public and Environmental Health at University of
Gezira, Sudan
First addition
2017 - 2018
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
HEALTH SERVICE MANAGEMENT
By
Mohamed Hassan Mohamed
M.Sc. in Public and Environmental Health at University of
Gezira, Sudan
First addition
2017 - 2018
2
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CONTANTS
CHAPTER ONE: PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT OF HEALTH SERVICE
CHAPTER TWO: HOSPITAL MANAGEMENT
CHAPTER THREE: FUNCTIONS AND ROLES OF HOSPITAL
CHAPTER FOUR: MANAGEMENT OF BLOOD BANKS IN HOSPITALS
CHAPTER FIVE: HOSPITAL WASTE MANAGEMENT
CHAPTER SIX: HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM IN
HOSPITALS
CHAPTER SEVEN: LEADERSHIP
CHAPTER EIGHT: SUPERVISION
CHAPTER NINE: IMPLEMENTATION
CHAPTER TEN: EVALUATION
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CONTANTS
CHAPTER ONE: PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT OF HEALTH SERVICE
CHAPTER TWO: HOSPITAL MANAGEMENT
CHAPTER THREE: FUNCTIONS AND ROLES OF HOSPITAL
CHAPTER FOUR: MANAGEMENT OF BLOOD BANKS IN HOSPITALS
CHAPTER FIVE: HOSPITAL WASTE MANAGEMENT
CHAPTER SIX: HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM IN
HOSPITALS
CHAPTER SEVEN: LEADERSHIP
CHAPTER EIGHT: SUPERVISION
CHAPTER NINE: IMPLEMENTATION
CHAPTER TEN: EVALUATION
3
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Health service management
Introduction
Health has been declared a fundamental human right. This implies that the state
has a responsibility for the health of its people.
National governments all over the world are striving to expand and improve their
health care services.
The current criticism against health care services is that they are:
1. Predominantly urban-oriented
2. Mostly curative in nature, and
3. accessible mainly to a small part of the population
The present concern in both developed and developing countries is not only to
reach the whole population with adequate health care services, but also to secure
an acceptable level of health for all, through the application of primary health
care programmers.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Health service management
Introduction
Health has been declared a fundamental human right. This implies that the state
has a responsibility for the health of its people.
National governments all over the world are striving to expand and improve their
health care services.
The current criticism against health care services is that they are:
1. Predominantly urban-oriented
2. Mostly curative in nature, and
3. accessible mainly to a small part of the population
The present concern in both developed and developing countries is not only to
reach the whole population with adequate health care services, but also to secure
an acceptable level of health for all, through the application of primary health
care programmers.
4
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER ONE
PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT OF HEALTH SERVICE
Key Definitions:
What is Health Services Management?
Health service management is the field relating to leadership, management, and
administration of public health systems, systems, hospitals, and hospital
networks. In the United States, management of a single institution (e.g. a
hospital) is also referred to as "Medical and health services management
"Healthcare management" or Health Administration.
Health Services Management majors are interested in the application of business
management knowledge and techniques to the healthcare industry, Therefore,
students acquire knowledge and experience both in the general management
sector and specifically in the healthcare field.
Health services managers also called healthcare executives or healthcare
administrators, plan, direct, and coordinate medical and health services. They
might manage an entire facility or specialize in managing a specific clinical area or
department, or manage a medical practice for a group of physicians.
Health: - is the maximization of the biological & clinical indicators of organ
function & the maximization of physical, mental, & role functioning in everyday
life.
WHO defined health as “a state of complete physical, mental, and social well
being and not the mere absence of disease or infirmity?”
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER ONE
PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT OF HEALTH SERVICE
Key Definitions:
What is Health Services Management?
Health service management is the field relating to leadership, management, and
administration of public health systems, systems, hospitals, and hospital
networks. In the United States, management of a single institution (e.g. a
hospital) is also referred to as "Medical and health services management
"Healthcare management" or Health Administration.
Health Services Management majors are interested in the application of business
management knowledge and techniques to the healthcare industry, Therefore,
students acquire knowledge and experience both in the general management
sector and specifically in the healthcare field.
Health services managers also called healthcare executives or healthcare
administrators, plan, direct, and coordinate medical and health services. They
might manage an entire facility or specialize in managing a specific clinical area or
department, or manage a medical practice for a group of physicians.
Health: - is the maximization of the biological & clinical indicators of organ
function & the maximization of physical, mental, & role functioning in everyday
life.
WHO defined health as “a state of complete physical, mental, and social well
being and not the mere absence of disease or infirmity?”
5
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Health care: -Health care (or healthcare) is the diagnosis, treatment, and
prevention of disease, illness, injury, and other physical and mental
impairments in humans
Health services: - are specific activities within the larger domain of health care
undertaken to maintain or improve health or to prevent decrements of health.
Health service organizations: - are entities that provide the organizational
structure within which the delivery of health services is made directly to
consumers, whether the purpose of the services is preventive, acute chronic,
restorative or palliative.
Environmental health:has been defined by the World Health Organization (WHO)
comprises those aspects of human health, including quality of life, that are
determined by physical, biological, social and psychosocial factors in the
environment.
It also, refers to the theory and practice of assessing, correcting, controlling, and
preventing those factors in the environment that can potentially affect adversely
the health of present and future generations’ (WHO, 1993a)
Organizing: Organizing is the process of establishing orderly uses for all the
organization’s resources.
Health Service Delivery: The World Health Organization (WHO) defines service
delivery as the way inputs are combined to allow the delivery of a series of
interventions or health actions
Management is a process of reaching organizational goals by workingwith and
through people and other resources.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Health care: -Health care (or healthcare) is the diagnosis, treatment, and
prevention of disease, illness, injury, and other physical and mental
impairments in humans
Health services: - are specific activities within the larger domain of health care
undertaken to maintain or improve health or to prevent decrements of health.
Health service organizations: - are entities that provide the organizational
structure within which the delivery of health services is made directly to
consumers, whether the purpose of the services is preventive, acute chronic,
restorative or palliative.
Environmental health:has been defined by the World Health Organization (WHO)
comprises those aspects of human health, including quality of life, that are
determined by physical, biological, social and psychosocial factors in the
environment.
It also, refers to the theory and practice of assessing, correcting, controlling, and
preventing those factors in the environment that can potentially affect adversely
the health of present and future generations’ (WHO, 1993a)
Organizing: Organizing is the process of establishing orderly uses for all the
organization’s resources.
Health Service Delivery: The World Health Organization (WHO) defines service
delivery as the way inputs are combined to allow the delivery of a series of
interventions or health actions
Management is a process of reaching organizational goals by workingwith and
through people and other resources.
6
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Planning and Management of health service
Management is a process of reaching organizational goals by workingwith and
through people and other resources.
The definition of management is based on two principles
Commitment to achievements
The importance of people and other resources
This means that people are the most important resource for getting things done.
Importance of Management
Management is universal and necessary function.
It is essential for all kinds of organizations. This is because every organization
requires:-
The making of decisions
The coordinating of activities
The handling of people and
Evaluating the performance directed toward its objectives
Levels of managements:
➢ Top Level of Management
It consists of board of directors, chief executive or managing director. The top
management is the ultimate source of authority and it manages goals and policies
for an enterprise. It devotes more time on planning and coordinating functions.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Planning and Management of health service
Management is a process of reaching organizational goals by workingwith and
through people and other resources.
The definition of management is based on two principles
Commitment to achievements
The importance of people and other resources
This means that people are the most important resource for getting things done.
Importance of Management
Management is universal and necessary function.
It is essential for all kinds of organizations. This is because every organization
requires:-
The making of decisions
The coordinating of activities
The handling of people and
Evaluating the performance directed toward its objectives
Levels of managements:
➢ Top Level of Management
It consists of board of directors, chief executive or managing director. The top
management is the ultimate source of authority and it manages goals and policies
for an enterprise. It devotes more time on planning and coordinating functions.
7
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
The role of the top management can be summarized as follows –
Top management lays down the objectives and broad policies of the enterprise.
It issues necessary instructions for preparation of department budgets, procedures, schedules
etc.
It prepares strategic plans & policies for the enterprise.
It appoints the executive for middle level i.e. departmental managers.
It controls & coordinates the activities of all the departments.
It is also responsible for maintaining a contact with the outside world.
It provides guidance and direction.
The top management is also responsible towards the shareholders for the performance of the
enterprise
➢ Middle Level of Management
The branch managers and departmental managers constitute middle level. They
are responsible to the top management for the functioning of their department.
They devote more time to organizational and directional functions. In small
organization, there is only one layer of middle level of management but in big
enterprises, there may be senior and junior middle level management. Their role
can be emphasized as -
They implement the plans of the organization in accordance with the policies and directives of
the top management.
They make plans for the sub-units of the organization.
They participate in employment & training of lower level management.
They interpret and explain policies from top level management to lower level.
They are responsible for coordinating the activities within the division or department.
It also sends important reports and other important data to top level management.
They evaluate performance of junior managers.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
The role of the top management can be summarized as follows –
Top management lays down the objectives and broad policies of the enterprise.
It issues necessary instructions for preparation of department budgets, procedures, schedules
etc.
It prepares strategic plans & policies for the enterprise.
It appoints the executive for middle level i.e. departmental managers.
It controls & coordinates the activities of all the departments.
It is also responsible for maintaining a contact with the outside world.
It provides guidance and direction.
The top management is also responsible towards the shareholders for the performance of the
enterprise
➢ Middle Level of Management
The branch managers and departmental managers constitute middle level. They
are responsible to the top management for the functioning of their department.
They devote more time to organizational and directional functions. In small
organization, there is only one layer of middle level of management but in big
enterprises, there may be senior and junior middle level management. Their role
can be emphasized as -
They implement the plans of the organization in accordance with the policies and directives of
the top management.
They make plans for the sub-units of the organization.
They participate in employment & training of lower level management.
They interpret and explain policies from top level management to lower level.
They are responsible for coordinating the activities within the division or department.
It also sends important reports and other important data to top level management.
They evaluate performance of junior managers.
8
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
They are also responsible for inspiring lower level managers towards better performance.
➢ Lower Level of Management
Lower level is also known as supervisory / operative level of management. It
consists of supervisors, foreman, section officers, superintendent etc. According
to R.C. Davis, “Supervisory management refers to those executives whose work
has to be largely with personal oversight and direction of operative employees”.
In other words, they are concerned with direction and controlling function of
management. Their activities include -
Assigning of jobs and tasks to various workers
They guide and instruct workers for day to day activities.
They are responsible for the quality as well as quantity of production.
They are also entrusted with the responsibility of maintaining good relation in the organization.
They communicate workers problems, suggestions, and recommendatory appeals etc. to the
higher level and higher level goals and objectives to the workers.
They help to solve the grievances of the workers.
They supervise & guide the sub-ordinates.
They are responsible for providing training to the workers.
They arrange necessary materials, machines, tools etc. for getting the things done.
They prepare periodical reports about the performance of the workers.
They ensure discipline in the enterprise.
They motivate workers.
They are the image builders of the enterprise because they are in direct contact with the
workers.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
They are also responsible for inspiring lower level managers towards better performance.
➢ Lower Level of Management
Lower level is also known as supervisory / operative level of management. It
consists of supervisors, foreman, section officers, superintendent etc. According
to R.C. Davis, “Supervisory management refers to those executives whose work
has to be largely with personal oversight and direction of operative employees”.
In other words, they are concerned with direction and controlling function of
management. Their activities include -
Assigning of jobs and tasks to various workers
They guide and instruct workers for day to day activities.
They are responsible for the quality as well as quantity of production.
They are also entrusted with the responsibility of maintaining good relation in the organization.
They communicate workers problems, suggestions, and recommendatory appeals etc. to the
higher level and higher level goals and objectives to the workers.
They help to solve the grievances of the workers.
They supervise & guide the sub-ordinates.
They are responsible for providing training to the workers.
They arrange necessary materials, machines, tools etc. for getting the things done.
They prepare periodical reports about the performance of the workers.
They ensure discipline in the enterprise.
They motivate workers.
They are the image builders of the enterprise because they are in direct contact with the
workers.
9
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
The basic skills needed are:
• Calmness
• Maturity
• Friendliness
• Tolerance
• Appreciable
• Tolerable
• Adorable
• Frank
• Determined
The management functions
The four basics management functions and activities that make up the
management process are the following:-
a. planning
b. organizing
c. influencing or directing
d. Staffing
e. Budgeting
f. controlling
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
The basic skills needed are:
• Calmness
• Maturity
• Friendliness
• Tolerance
• Appreciable
• Tolerable
• Adorable
• Frank
• Determined
The management functions
The four basics management functions and activities that make up the
management process are the following:-
a. planning
b. organizing
c. influencing or directing
d. Staffing
e. Budgeting
f. controlling
10
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Planning
Planning involves choosing tasks that must be performed to attain organizational
goals, outlining how the task must be performed and indicating when they should
be performed.
Organizing
Organizing can be through assigning the tasks developed under the planning
function to individuals or groups within the organization. Organizing then creates a
mechanism to put plans into action.
Influencing
Influencing is another form of the basic functions within the management process.
This function also commonly referred to as motivating, leading or directing. It is
concerned primarily with people within the organizations. Influencing can be
defined as guiding the activities of organization member in appropriate directions.
Staffing:
It is the process of “personalizing” the organization, by hiring the right type and
adequate number of workers to each unit for the time required for the program,
through the following steps:
➢ Identifying the type and number of personnel
➢ Recruitment
➢ Selection and appointment
➢ Orientation
➢ Job analysis
➢ Job description
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Planning
Planning involves choosing tasks that must be performed to attain organizational
goals, outlining how the task must be performed and indicating when they should
be performed.
Organizing
Organizing can be through assigning the tasks developed under the planning
function to individuals or groups within the organization. Organizing then creates a
mechanism to put plans into action.
Influencing
Influencing is another form of the basic functions within the management process.
This function also commonly referred to as motivating, leading or directing. It is
concerned primarily with people within the organizations. Influencing can be
defined as guiding the activities of organization member in appropriate directions.
Staffing:
It is the process of “personalizing” the organization, by hiring the right type and
adequate number of workers to each unit for the time required for the program,
through the following steps:
➢ Identifying the type and number of personnel
➢ Recruitment
➢ Selection and appointment
➢ Orientation
➢ Job analysis
➢ Job description
11
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
BUDGETING
Financial administration consists of a series activities were funds are made
available for certain people in the organization under procedures that will ensure
their efficient use.
Budgeting: is the allocation of financial resources in support for programs or
projects for a special period of time. A budget is defined as “a balanced estimate
of expenditures and receipts for a given period of time”.
➢ The main activities are
➢ Budgeting
➢ Accounting
➢ Reviewing
➢ Purchasing
Controlling
Controlling is the management function for which managers can do the following:-
1. Gather information that measures recent performance within the organization.
2. Compare present performance to pre-established performance standards.
3. From this comparison, determine if the organization should be modified to meet
pre-established standards.
Controlling is an ongoing process. Managers continually gather information, make
their comparison, and then try to find new ways of improving production through
organizational modifications.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
BUDGETING
Financial administration consists of a series activities were funds are made
available for certain people in the organization under procedures that will ensure
their efficient use.
Budgeting: is the allocation of financial resources in support for programs or
projects for a special period of time. A budget is defined as “a balanced estimate
of expenditures and receipts for a given period of time”.
➢ The main activities are
➢ Budgeting
➢ Accounting
➢ Reviewing
➢ Purchasing
Controlling
Controlling is the management function for which managers can do the following:-
1. Gather information that measures recent performance within the organization.
2. Compare present performance to pre-established performance standards.
3. From this comparison, determine if the organization should be modified to meet
pre-established standards.
Controlling is an ongoing process. Managers continually gather information, make
their comparison, and then try to find new ways of improving production through
organizational modifications.
12
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
MANAGEMENT CYCLE
Managerial Skills
There are three types of skills are important for successful management
performance these are:-
1. Technical skills involve using specialized knowledge and expertise in executing
work related techniques and procedures.
2. Human skills are skills that build cooperation within the team being led.
3. Conceptual skills involve the ability to see the organization as a whole. A
manger with conceptual skills is able to understand how various functions of
the organization complement one another, and how changer in one part of the
organization affects the rest of the organization.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
MANAGEMENT CYCLE
Managerial Skills
There are three types of skills are important for successful management
performance these are:-
1. Technical skills involve using specialized knowledge and expertise in executing
work related techniques and procedures.
2. Human skills are skills that build cooperation within the team being led.
3. Conceptual skills involve the ability to see the organization as a whole. A
manger with conceptual skills is able to understand how various functions of
the organization complement one another, and how changer in one part of the
organization affects the rest of the organization.
13
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Management and Organizational Resources
Management must always be aware of the status and use of organizational
resources. These resources composed of all assets available for activation during
the production process are of four basic types"-
1. human
2. monetary
3. raw materials
4. capital
Definition
Planning - is the combination of compiling and analyzing, information dreaming
up ideas, using logic and imagination and judgment in order to come to a decision
about what should be done.
Health Planning - Is the process of defining community health problems,
Identifying needs and resources, establishing priority goals, and setting out the
administrative action needed to reach those goals.
Scope of Planning:
What is the target client? Population, Institution, Programmer
What is the target geographical region or area? Village, District, Zone/Region
Features of Planning:
1. A good plan should give
Clear vision/mission, goal and objectives
A clear picture of the tasks to be accomplished
The resources needed to accomplish the task
Human resources, material, money, time, space and information.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Management and Organizational Resources
Management must always be aware of the status and use of organizational
resources. These resources composed of all assets available for activation during
the production process are of four basic types"-
1. human
2. monetary
3. raw materials
4. capital
Definition
Planning - is the combination of compiling and analyzing, information dreaming
up ideas, using logic and imagination and judgment in order to come to a decision
about what should be done.
Health Planning - Is the process of defining community health problems,
Identifying needs and resources, establishing priority goals, and setting out the
administrative action needed to reach those goals.
Scope of Planning:
What is the target client? Population, Institution, Programmer
What is the target geographical region or area? Village, District, Zone/Region
Features of Planning:
1. A good plan should give
Clear vision/mission, goal and objectives
A clear picture of the tasks to be accomplished
The resources needed to accomplish the task
Human resources, material, money, time, space and information.
14
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
2. Planning takes place at all levels
Planning takes place at any level in health system.
Planning takes place continually, it is cyclic/spiral process.
Planning methods can be applied to:-
. A large program at national level e.g. Malaria control programmed
. Small one - at village level e.g. Construction of community health post.
3. Planning must be collective undertaking
It requires the participation of:-
. Professionals – from health and other sectors
. Community/Non government organizations (NGO)
. Government/Party
Types of Planning
There are two types of planning
Strategic planning –often referred as a locative planning– normally five years or
more.
Tactical/operational planning –may be referred to as activity planning.
It covers a short period of time medium term –usually one year
Strategic Planning
What is strategic planning?
Strategic planning is the process of determining what an organization intends to
be in the future and how it will get there. It is finding the best future for your
organization and the best path to reach that destination.
Tactical/Operational Planning
Tactical/operational planning is short range planning that emphasizes the current
operations of various parts of the organization.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
2. Planning takes place at all levels
Planning takes place at any level in health system.
Planning takes place continually, it is cyclic/spiral process.
Planning methods can be applied to:-
. A large program at national level e.g. Malaria control programmed
. Small one - at village level e.g. Construction of community health post.
3. Planning must be collective undertaking
It requires the participation of:-
. Professionals – from health and other sectors
. Community/Non government organizations (NGO)
. Government/Party
Types of Planning
There are two types of planning
Strategic planning –often referred as a locative planning– normally five years or
more.
Tactical/operational planning –may be referred to as activity planning.
It covers a short period of time medium term –usually one year
Strategic Planning
What is strategic planning?
Strategic planning is the process of determining what an organization intends to
be in the future and how it will get there. It is finding the best future for your
organization and the best path to reach that destination.
Tactical/Operational Planning
Tactical/operational planning is short range planning that emphasizes the current
operations of various parts of the organization.
15
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Short range is defined as a period of time extending only about one year or less
into the future.
Steps in planning
There are six steps in planning
1. Situation analysis
2. Analyzing and selecting critical (priority) problems
3. Setting objectives and targets
4. Identifying potential obstacles
5. Designing the strategies
6. Writing up the plan
Step 1: Situational Analysis
Review and describe organizational characteristics, Consider, National health
polices & programmers, Analyze the organizational structure and functions of the
health services, Review past implementation experience, Analyze the health
condition (magnitude), Study the size, composition and distribution of the
population, Collect information about resources;
Step 2: Selecting Critical Problem (Priority)Analyzing problems and constraints,
Establish criteria for selection
Criteria - In identifying priority problem
Does the Problem:-
1. Affect large number of people, Cause high infant mortality, Affect maternal
health, Affect children and young persons, Cause chronic conditions & handicap,
Affect socio-economic development, Cause worry to the community
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Short range is defined as a period of time extending only about one year or less
into the future.
Steps in planning
There are six steps in planning
1. Situation analysis
2. Analyzing and selecting critical (priority) problems
3. Setting objectives and targets
4. Identifying potential obstacles
5. Designing the strategies
6. Writing up the plan
Step 1: Situational Analysis
Review and describe organizational characteristics, Consider, National health
polices & programmers, Analyze the organizational structure and functions of the
health services, Review past implementation experience, Analyze the health
condition (magnitude), Study the size, composition and distribution of the
population, Collect information about resources;
Step 2: Selecting Critical Problem (Priority)Analyzing problems and constraints,
Establish criteria for selection
Criteria - In identifying priority problem
Does the Problem:-
1. Affect large number of people, Cause high infant mortality, Affect maternal
health, Affect children and young persons, Cause chronic conditions & handicap,
Affect socio-economic development, Cause worry to the community
16
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Step 3: Setting Objective/ Target
Objectives are desired end states (outcomes) of a programmed, If the
programmed is made to have an objective and target then:-
It must be relevant - fits with health policy, It must be feasible - achievable, It
must be observable, It must be measurable
Step 4: Identifying Potential Obstacles
Why objectives could not be attained?
Which are the limitations & obstacles?
Resources:
. People: lack of interest, No skilled people etc
. Equipment: not available, Expensive
. Money: No budget
. Time: People may not have time
Step 5: Designing the Strategies
Outline potential strategies this include
. The technology to be applied, Procedure to be used, defining the role of the
communities and other relevant sectors, Design the details of selected strategy
Determine resources required in terms of proposed strategy
- Time
- Staff
- Facilities/materials
- Money
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Step 3: Setting Objective/ Target
Objectives are desired end states (outcomes) of a programmed, If the
programmed is made to have an objective and target then:-
It must be relevant - fits with health policy, It must be feasible - achievable, It
must be observable, It must be measurable
Step 4: Identifying Potential Obstacles
Why objectives could not be attained?
Which are the limitations & obstacles?
Resources:
. People: lack of interest, No skilled people etc
. Equipment: not available, Expensive
. Money: No budget
. Time: People may not have time
Step 5: Designing the Strategies
Outline potential strategies this include
. The technology to be applied, Procedure to be used, defining the role of the
communities and other relevant sectors, Design the details of selected strategy
Determine resources required in terms of proposed strategy
- Time
- Staff
- Facilities/materials
- Money
17
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Step 6: Writing up the Plan
The purpose of writing the plan
To request funds or resources
For monitoring and evaluating the implementation process by all concerned
Writing the Plan (summary) Executive summary
Introduction
Problem Statement
Objectives and Targets
Strategies and Activities
Budget
Work Plan
Monitoring and Eval
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Step 6: Writing up the Plan
The purpose of writing the plan
To request funds or resources
For monitoring and evaluating the implementation process by all concerned
Writing the Plan (summary) Executive summary
Introduction
Problem Statement
Objectives and Targets
Strategies and Activities
Budget
Work Plan
Monitoring and Eval
18
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER TWO
HOSPITAL MANAGEMENT
Hospital
A building in which the sick, injured, or infirm are received and treated; a public or
private institution founded for reception and cure, or for the refuge, of persons
diseased in body or mind, or disabled, infirm, or dependent, and in which they are
treated either at their own expense, or more often by charity in whole or in part;
a tent, building, or other place where the sick or wounded of an army cared for.
Hospital is a formal institutions developed by the society for patient care
Intended to meet the complex health needs of its members Individual-sick or
injured has access to centralized medical knowledge & technology Society-it
protects the family from many of the disruptive effects of caring for the ill in the
home and making the problems less disruptive for the society as a whole.
Hospital is a place for the diagnosis and treatment of human ills and restoration of
health and well-beings of those temporarily deprived of these. Professionally &
technically skilled people apply their knowledge and skill with the help of
complicated equipment and appliances - to provide quality care for the patient.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER TWO
HOSPITAL MANAGEMENT
Hospital
A building in which the sick, injured, or infirm are received and treated; a public or
private institution founded for reception and cure, or for the refuge, of persons
diseased in body or mind, or disabled, infirm, or dependent, and in which they are
treated either at their own expense, or more often by charity in whole or in part;
a tent, building, or other place where the sick or wounded of an army cared for.
Hospital is a formal institutions developed by the society for patient care
Intended to meet the complex health needs of its members Individual-sick or
injured has access to centralized medical knowledge & technology Society-it
protects the family from many of the disruptive effects of caring for the ill in the
home and making the problems less disruptive for the society as a whole.
Hospital is a place for the diagnosis and treatment of human ills and restoration of
health and well-beings of those temporarily deprived of these. Professionally &
technically skilled people apply their knowledge and skill with the help of
complicated equipment and appliances - to provide quality care for the patient.
19
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Evolution of hospitals
Evolution of hospitals has been divided into two parts which are history of
hospital and changing concept of hospital
History of hospitals
Early History: The word hospital originates from Latin word ‘hospice’. A place
where a guest is received is called hospitable, an institution for the care of sick
and injured. In the early period, during Greek and Roman Civilization the temples
were used as hospitals and these hospitals were integral part of the temples.
Some of the notable hospitals established in Europe date back to ancient times.
The earliest Hospital was founded at Hotel Dieu, Paris in 542 AD. St
Bartholomew`s hospital London dates back to 1123 AD. In 1524, Spanish built the
first hospital in Mexico.
The first general hospital opened in 1751 in North America as Pennsylvania
hospital. Thereafter, Bellevue Hospital in New York in 1736 and Massachusetts
Hospital in 1811 AD.
The advances in medical science in the field of microbiology, pharmacology,
radiation, blood transfusion, anesthesiology, surgical techniques and computers
all led to exponential growth in hospital services.
a) Ancient Asia: Sri Lankans are responsible for introducing the concept of
dedicated hospitals to the world. The first teaching hospital was the
Academy of Gundishapur in the Persian Empire.
b) Modern Era: By the mid 19th Century most of the Europe and United
States had established a number of public and privet hospital systems. In
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Evolution of hospitals
Evolution of hospitals has been divided into two parts which are history of
hospital and changing concept of hospital
History of hospitals
Early History: The word hospital originates from Latin word ‘hospice’. A place
where a guest is received is called hospitable, an institution for the care of sick
and injured. In the early period, during Greek and Roman Civilization the temples
were used as hospitals and these hospitals were integral part of the temples.
Some of the notable hospitals established in Europe date back to ancient times.
The earliest Hospital was founded at Hotel Dieu, Paris in 542 AD. St
Bartholomew`s hospital London dates back to 1123 AD. In 1524, Spanish built the
first hospital in Mexico.
The first general hospital opened in 1751 in North America as Pennsylvania
hospital. Thereafter, Bellevue Hospital in New York in 1736 and Massachusetts
Hospital in 1811 AD.
The advances in medical science in the field of microbiology, pharmacology,
radiation, blood transfusion, anesthesiology, surgical techniques and computers
all led to exponential growth in hospital services.
a) Ancient Asia: Sri Lankans are responsible for introducing the concept of
dedicated hospitals to the world. The first teaching hospital was the
Academy of Gundishapur in the Persian Empire.
b) Modern Era: By the mid 19th Century most of the Europe and United
States had established a number of public and privet hospital systems. In
20
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Continental Europe, the new hospitals were generally built and run by
public funds. In the late 20th Century, the concept of nonprofit hospital
was switched over to chains of for profit hospital.
c) Period of Growth: The first hospital in USA was founded in 1751, the
Pennsylvania Hospital. Rapid growth in the field of hospital occurred in
between 1860 to 1920.The main reason to the growth of the hospital can
be credited to the rapid advancement in the field of medicine
d) Consolidation ( 1920-1950 ) : The increasing average size of the hospitals
improved the comprehensiveness and quality of medical care. The
American College of Surgeons (ACS) was constituted in 1913.
The general and acute care hospitals established during the period were mainly
from private and voluntary action during Second World War. The number of
hospital increased significantly.
Changing concept of hospitals
The concept in the field of hospital is fast changing; the changing concept of
hospitals is broadly divided into four periods.
1. Trusteeship Period
Most of the hospitals were run and managed by the trustee’s .The advances in
technology were minimal during that period. This period lasted till 1920. The
doctors and nurses are not working for money, the approach was only
humanitarian. The objectives of the hospital remained to provide comfort to the
patient.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Continental Europe, the new hospitals were generally built and run by
public funds. In the late 20th Century, the concept of nonprofit hospital
was switched over to chains of for profit hospital.
c) Period of Growth: The first hospital in USA was founded in 1751, the
Pennsylvania Hospital. Rapid growth in the field of hospital occurred in
between 1860 to 1920.The main reason to the growth of the hospital can
be credited to the rapid advancement in the field of medicine
d) Consolidation ( 1920-1950 ) : The increasing average size of the hospitals
improved the comprehensiveness and quality of medical care. The
American College of Surgeons (ACS) was constituted in 1913.
The general and acute care hospitals established during the period were mainly
from private and voluntary action during Second World War. The number of
hospital increased significantly.
Changing concept of hospitals
The concept in the field of hospital is fast changing; the changing concept of
hospitals is broadly divided into four periods.
1. Trusteeship Period
Most of the hospitals were run and managed by the trustee’s .The advances in
technology were minimal during that period. This period lasted till 1920. The
doctors and nurses are not working for money, the approach was only
humanitarian. The objectives of the hospital remained to provide comfort to the
patient.
21
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
2. Physician Period
It was being utilized for medical. The hospitals were being utilized for medical
practice. The laboratory medicine developed during the period 1940 to 1950. The
political and economic environment started influencing the hospitals.
3. Administrative and Team Periods
The hospital practice became a team approach. The advances in technology
became more rapid. The use of computers and application of computers in
patient’s care and management of hospitals changed the scenario. People started
thinking about professionally managing the hospital.
4. Growth of Corporate Sector
With liberalization policy of the government all over the world lead to
globalization. The rapid advancement in the field of information technology, with
fast and safe air travel all over the world lead to the concepts of medical tourism,
the concept of corporatization of the hospital. The hospital concept has changed
from service approach to the profit making approach. The doctors have started
thinking on management principles and functions for productivity.
Types of hospitals:
There is wide range of hospitals Some hospitals are small, some are big, some
imparting teaching and training facilities, some are owned by private bodies,
some are special hospitals and so on.
These hospitals can be categorized or classified in several manners. Some of the
methods of classification of hospital are given below:-
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
2. Physician Period
It was being utilized for medical. The hospitals were being utilized for medical
practice. The laboratory medicine developed during the period 1940 to 1950. The
political and economic environment started influencing the hospitals.
3. Administrative and Team Periods
The hospital practice became a team approach. The advances in technology
became more rapid. The use of computers and application of computers in
patient’s care and management of hospitals changed the scenario. People started
thinking about professionally managing the hospital.
4. Growth of Corporate Sector
With liberalization policy of the government all over the world lead to
globalization. The rapid advancement in the field of information technology, with
fast and safe air travel all over the world lead to the concepts of medical tourism,
the concept of corporatization of the hospital. The hospital concept has changed
from service approach to the profit making approach. The doctors have started
thinking on management principles and functions for productivity.
Types of hospitals:
There is wide range of hospitals Some hospitals are small, some are big, some
imparting teaching and training facilities, some are owned by private bodies,
some are special hospitals and so on.
These hospitals can be categorized or classified in several manners. Some of the
methods of classification of hospital are given below:-
22
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
A) According to ownership and control
Classification of hospital based up on ownership and control is present as below:
1. Public hospitals: The hospitals run by central or state government, local
bodies and public sector undertaking. The hospitals are purely service
organizations and nonprofit making hospitals. Examples are civil hospitals.
2. Voluntary Hospitals: These hospitals are registered under the societies act
or public trust act. They are run by trusts and on non commercial basis
examples, charitable hospitals
3. Nursing Homes: Generally owned and, managed by individual doctors.
These hospitals generally do not admit cases of medico legal importance
and the patient care services are usually provided in some of the specialties
of medicine.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
A) According to ownership and control
Classification of hospital based up on ownership and control is present as below:
1. Public hospitals: The hospitals run by central or state government, local
bodies and public sector undertaking. The hospitals are purely service
organizations and nonprofit making hospitals. Examples are civil hospitals.
2. Voluntary Hospitals: These hospitals are registered under the societies act
or public trust act. They are run by trusts and on non commercial basis
examples, charitable hospitals
3. Nursing Homes: Generally owned and, managed by individual doctors.
These hospitals generally do not admit cases of medico legal importance
and the patient care services are usually provided in some of the specialties
of medicine.
23
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
4. Corporate Hospitals: These hospitals are run on the basis of profit earning
and are registered under companies act. Examples are Kamil Hospital,
Kalkaal Hospital, etc.
B) According to Directory of Hospital
1. General hospitals:-They care for patients with various- disease conditions
for both sexes to all ages, medical, surgical, pediatrics, obstetrics, eye and
ear hospital etc. General hospitals may contain specialized units staffed by
specialized personnel, Renal Unit, Intensive Care Unit, Coronary Care Unit,
Plastic Surgery Unit and Burn Unit. There may be specialization at Unit
level, Neurological, Urological, Orthopedic Units, etc.
2. Rural Hospitals: The hospitals located in rural areas.
3. Specialty Hospitals: Hospital providing medical care usually in one or more
specialty like TB Hospital, Eye Hospital, Cancer Hospital, heart centers etc.
4. Teaching Hospital: Usually the hospitals attached to medical college
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
4. Corporate Hospitals: These hospitals are run on the basis of profit earning
and are registered under companies act. Examples are Kamil Hospital,
Kalkaal Hospital, etc.
B) According to Directory of Hospital
1. General hospitals:-They care for patients with various- disease conditions
for both sexes to all ages, medical, surgical, pediatrics, obstetrics, eye and
ear hospital etc. General hospitals may contain specialized units staffed by
specialized personnel, Renal Unit, Intensive Care Unit, Coronary Care Unit,
Plastic Surgery Unit and Burn Unit. There may be specialization at Unit
level, Neurological, Urological, Orthopedic Units, etc.
2. Rural Hospitals: The hospitals located in rural areas.
3. Specialty Hospitals: Hospital providing medical care usually in one or more
specialty like TB Hospital, Eye Hospital, Cancer Hospital, heart centers etc.
4. Teaching Hospital: Usually the hospitals attached to medical college
24
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
5. Isolation Hospital: Hospitals providing patient care to communicable
diseases.
C) According to size of hospital
The hospitals can be classified as small, medium or large size depending upon the
bed strength of the hospitals. Hospitals having more than 500 beds are usually
called large hospitals.
Hospitals having bed strength from 200 to 500 are called medium size hospitals
and hospitals having less than 200 beds are small hospitals.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
5. Isolation Hospital: Hospitals providing patient care to communicable
diseases.
C) According to size of hospital
The hospitals can be classified as small, medium or large size depending upon the
bed strength of the hospitals. Hospitals having more than 500 beds are usually
called large hospitals.
Hospitals having bed strength from 200 to 500 are called medium size hospitals
and hospitals having less than 200 beds are small hospitals.
25
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
D) According to clinical base
E) According to teaching facilities
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
D) According to clinical base
E) According to teaching facilities
26
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
F) According to gender
G) According to length of stay
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
F) According to gender
G) According to length of stay
27
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER THREE
FUNCTIONS AND ROLES OF HOSPITAL
Functions of Hospital administrator
The hospital is an integral part of a social and medical organization, the function
of which is to provide for the population complete health care, both curative and
preventive and whose outpatient services reach out to the family and its home
environment; the hospital is also a centre for the training of health worker and for
biosocial research (WHO).
1. Patient care: Primary function (curative function) refers to any type of care
given to patients by the health team members, e.g. Physicians; Nurses,
Physical Therapists, Dietitians, etc. It also. Includes health teaching to
patients.
2. Health Personnel Education: Secondary function (Educational function).
Refers to the education of professional and technical personnel who
provide health services, e.g. Physicians, Nurses, Dentists, Therapists,
Technicians, etc.
3. Health Promotion: Secondary function (Preventive functioning emerging
function for the hospital is that of a community health center taking an
active role to improve the health of the population it serves. Hospitals as
major community health centers can sponsor programs of environmental
and occupational health, home care services, etc.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER THREE
FUNCTIONS AND ROLES OF HOSPITAL
Functions of Hospital administrator
The hospital is an integral part of a social and medical organization, the function
of which is to provide for the population complete health care, both curative and
preventive and whose outpatient services reach out to the family and its home
environment; the hospital is also a centre for the training of health worker and for
biosocial research (WHO).
1. Patient care: Primary function (curative function) refers to any type of care
given to patients by the health team members, e.g. Physicians; Nurses,
Physical Therapists, Dietitians, etc. It also. Includes health teaching to
patients.
2. Health Personnel Education: Secondary function (Educational function).
Refers to the education of professional and technical personnel who
provide health services, e.g. Physicians, Nurses, Dentists, Therapists,
Technicians, etc.
3. Health Promotion: Secondary function (Preventive functioning emerging
function for the hospital is that of a community health center taking an
active role to improve the health of the population it serves. Hospitals as
major community health centers can sponsor programs of environmental
and occupational health, home care services, etc.
28
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
4. Health Related Research: Secondary function (Research - function)
Research that focuses on the improvement of health and/or - prevention of
disease.
Roles of hospital Administrator
By virtue of serving a health care organization, the hospital administrator
performs some specific roles which are described below. The hospital
administrator ensures that hospital runs effectively and efficiently.
The role of hospital administrator varies, depending up on the nature and
complexity of hospital, various roles can be grouped as role towards patients,
towards hospital organization, towards community.
➢ Role towards Patients
➢ Role towards Hospital Organization
➢ Role towards Community
Role towards Patients
The hospital administrator has a great responsibility to understand and appreciate
the emotional aspects of the patient care, his responsibility is to understand the
specific needs of certain groups of patients, i.e. patients on wheelchairs,
stretchers, geriatric group of patients, pediatric patients, neonates, serious cases,
foreign nationals etc.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
4. Health Related Research: Secondary function (Research - function)
Research that focuses on the improvement of health and/or - prevention of
disease.
Roles of hospital Administrator
By virtue of serving a health care organization, the hospital administrator
performs some specific roles which are described below. The hospital
administrator ensures that hospital runs effectively and efficiently.
The role of hospital administrator varies, depending up on the nature and
complexity of hospital, various roles can be grouped as role towards patients,
towards hospital organization, towards community.
➢ Role towards Patients
➢ Role towards Hospital Organization
➢ Role towards Community
Role towards Patients
The hospital administrator has a great responsibility to understand and appreciate
the emotional aspects of the patient care, his responsibility is to understand the
specific needs of certain groups of patients, i.e. patients on wheelchairs,
stretchers, geriatric group of patients, pediatric patients, neonates, serious cases,
foreign nationals etc.
29
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Some of the aspects of patients are given below:
✓ Creation of friendly environment
✓ Understanding patient’s physical needs
✓ Patient’s emotional needs
✓ Patient’s clinical needs
✓ Patient’s satisfaction
✓ Patient’s education
✓ Patient’s communication needs,
Role towards Hospital Organization
To handle the hospital resources for maximizing the output is one of the
fundamental roles of the administrator.
Hospital is a complex organization it is a labor intensive organization
working for day and night and without break; expectations of the workers
are very high and unity of direction and unity of command are often
violated.
The role of administrator is more of coordination in nature instead of
controlling he is coordinating officer.
Under the role a hospital administrator performs following function.
✓ Strategic planning
✓ Environmental influence on the hospital
✓ Operational management
✓ Management of hospital staff
✓ Materials management
✓ Financial management
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Some of the aspects of patients are given below:
✓ Creation of friendly environment
✓ Understanding patient’s physical needs
✓ Patient’s emotional needs
✓ Patient’s clinical needs
✓ Patient’s satisfaction
✓ Patient’s education
✓ Patient’s communication needs,
Role towards Hospital Organization
To handle the hospital resources for maximizing the output is one of the
fundamental roles of the administrator.
Hospital is a complex organization it is a labor intensive organization
working for day and night and without break; expectations of the workers
are very high and unity of direction and unity of command are often
violated.
The role of administrator is more of coordination in nature instead of
controlling he is coordinating officer.
Under the role a hospital administrator performs following function.
✓ Strategic planning
✓ Environmental influence on the hospital
✓ Operational management
✓ Management of hospital staff
✓ Materials management
✓ Financial management
30
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
✓ Hospital information
✓ Communication
✓ Public relation
✓ Risk management
✓ Law, Ethics and Code of Conduct
✓ Marketing of health services
✓ Quality management
Role towards Community
Hospital is a community organization; it receives inputs from the community in
the form of manpower, material, money, machines, land, building, environment,
information and gives output to the community.
Community participation is must for the success of any health program.
The utilization of health facility is also an important behavior of the community.
Hospital may provide State of the art Care, but if community does not utilize it; it
will go to waste.
Hospital must fulfill the felt needs of the community.
There should be social responsiveness and social responsibility of the hospital
administrator.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
✓ Hospital information
✓ Communication
✓ Public relation
✓ Risk management
✓ Law, Ethics and Code of Conduct
✓ Marketing of health services
✓ Quality management
Role towards Community
Hospital is a community organization; it receives inputs from the community in
the form of manpower, material, money, machines, land, building, environment,
information and gives output to the community.
Community participation is must for the success of any health program.
The utilization of health facility is also an important behavior of the community.
Hospital may provide State of the art Care, but if community does not utilize it; it
will go to waste.
Hospital must fulfill the felt needs of the community.
There should be social responsiveness and social responsibility of the hospital
administrator.
31
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
This can be achieved by:
✓ Integrating with primary health care
✓ Integrating hospital with other health care organizations
✓ Community participation in planning of services and also for utilization of
hospital services
✓ Outreach program: Outreach program like health camps, camp surgery,
immunization camps, etc.
The World Health Organization initiated the Network of Health Promoting
Hospitals with the aim to reorient health care institutions to integrate health
promotion and education, disease prevention and rehabilitation services in
curative care.
Many activities have been carried out and more than 700 hospitals in 25
European Countries and worldwide have joined the WHO network since the
establishment of the network.
Health Promoting Hospitals have committed themselves to integrate health
promotion in daily activities, i.e. to become a smoke-free setting, and to follow
the Vienna Recommendations, which advocate a number of strategic and ethical
directions such as encouraging patient participation, involving all professionals,
fostering patients` rights and promoting a healthy environment within the
hospital.
However, so far no tool or set of standards was available to systematically assess,
monitor and improve the quality of health promotion activities in hospitals.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
This can be achieved by:
✓ Integrating with primary health care
✓ Integrating hospital with other health care organizations
✓ Community participation in planning of services and also for utilization of
hospital services
✓ Outreach program: Outreach program like health camps, camp surgery,
immunization camps, etc.
The World Health Organization initiated the Network of Health Promoting
Hospitals with the aim to reorient health care institutions to integrate health
promotion and education, disease prevention and rehabilitation services in
curative care.
Many activities have been carried out and more than 700 hospitals in 25
European Countries and worldwide have joined the WHO network since the
establishment of the network.
Health Promoting Hospitals have committed themselves to integrate health
promotion in daily activities, i.e. to become a smoke-free setting, and to follow
the Vienna Recommendations, which advocate a number of strategic and ethical
directions such as encouraging patient participation, involving all professionals,
fostering patients` rights and promoting a healthy environment within the
hospital.
However, so far no tool or set of standards was available to systematically assess,
monitor and improve the quality of health promotion activities in hospitals.
32
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Definition of health promotion
Health promotion is defined as “the process of enabling people to increase control
over, and to improve, their health” (Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion), and is
here understood to embrace health education, disease prevention and
rehabilitation services.
It is also understood to include health enhancement by empowering patients,
relatives and employees in the improvement of their health-related physical,
mental and social well-being.
Hospitals play an important role in promoting health, preventing disease and
providing rehabilitation services.
Some of these activities have been an essential part of hospital work, however,
the increasing prevalence of lifestyle-related and chronic diseases require a more
expanded scope and systematic provision of activities such as therapeutic
education, effective communication strategies to enable patients to take an active
role in chronic disease-management or motivational counselling.
The need of standards for health promotion in hospitals
1. The predominant approach to quality management in hospitals is through
setting standards for the services.
2. Health promotion is a core quality issue for improving health and sustaining
quality of life, however, a review of existing standards for quality in health
care for references to health promotion activities yielded little results.
3. Standards for health promotion in hospitals are necessary to ensure the
quality of services provided in this area.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Definition of health promotion
Health promotion is defined as “the process of enabling people to increase control
over, and to improve, their health” (Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion), and is
here understood to embrace health education, disease prevention and
rehabilitation services.
It is also understood to include health enhancement by empowering patients,
relatives and employees in the improvement of their health-related physical,
mental and social well-being.
Hospitals play an important role in promoting health, preventing disease and
providing rehabilitation services.
Some of these activities have been an essential part of hospital work, however,
the increasing prevalence of lifestyle-related and chronic diseases require a more
expanded scope and systematic provision of activities such as therapeutic
education, effective communication strategies to enable patients to take an active
role in chronic disease-management or motivational counselling.
The need of standards for health promotion in hospitals
1. The predominant approach to quality management in hospitals is through
setting standards for the services.
2. Health promotion is a core quality issue for improving health and sustaining
quality of life, however, a review of existing standards for quality in health
care for references to health promotion activities yielded little results.
3. Standards for health promotion in hospitals are necessary to ensure the
quality of services provided in this area.
33
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
4. Standards will facilitate both the implementation of health promotion and
the assessment and continuous monitoring for quality improvement.
5. Recognizing the need for standards for health promotion in hospitals, WHO
established a working group at the 9th International Conference on Health
Promoting Hospitals, Copenhagen, and May 2001?
6. Since then several working groups and country networks have been
working on the development of standards.
7. As a result, five core standards applicable to all hospitals have been
developed in accordance with international requirements established by
the ALPHA program developed by the International Society for Quality in
Health.
8. It involved a wide range of scientists, health promotion experts and
managers of health care organizations from the WHO European Region, as
well as members of the international Health Promoting Hospitals Network.
Format and application of standards
The standards presented in this document are the result of series of workshops
and consultations.
They have been piloted in 36 hospitals in nine European countries and were
assessed to be relevant and applicable.
Based on the feedback from the pilot test, substandards and measurable
elements have been amended and specified and steps for the further
development and facilitation of standards have been planned.
Each standard consists of standard formulation, description of objective and
definition of sub standards.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
4. Standards will facilitate both the implementation of health promotion and
the assessment and continuous monitoring for quality improvement.
5. Recognizing the need for standards for health promotion in hospitals, WHO
established a working group at the 9th International Conference on Health
Promoting Hospitals, Copenhagen, and May 2001?
6. Since then several working groups and country networks have been
working on the development of standards.
7. As a result, five core standards applicable to all hospitals have been
developed in accordance with international requirements established by
the ALPHA program developed by the International Society for Quality in
Health.
8. It involved a wide range of scientists, health promotion experts and
managers of health care organizations from the WHO European Region, as
well as members of the international Health Promoting Hospitals Network.
Format and application of standards
The standards presented in this document are the result of series of workshops
and consultations.
They have been piloted in 36 hospitals in nine European countries and were
assessed to be relevant and applicable.
Based on the feedback from the pilot test, substandards and measurable
elements have been amended and specified and steps for the further
development and facilitation of standards have been planned.
Each standard consists of standard formulation, description of objective and
definition of sub standards.
34
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
The standards are related to the patient's pathway and define the responsibilities
and activities concerning health promotion as an integral part of all services
offered to patients in a hospital.
The way forward
In order to facilitate the practical use of the standards in planning,
implementation and assessment of health promotion in hospitals measurable
elements and indicators are being defined and a tool for self assessment is being
developed.
It is not the aim of WHO to externally assess the activities in hospitals in the
European Network of Health Promoting Hospitals, but hospitals within and other
hospitals are encourage using the self assessment tool for improving their health
promotion services.
The standards are considered public domain and quality agencies and
accreditation bodies are encouraged to include the standards for health
promotion in hospitals in their existing standards sets.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
The standards are related to the patient's pathway and define the responsibilities
and activities concerning health promotion as an integral part of all services
offered to patients in a hospital.
The way forward
In order to facilitate the practical use of the standards in planning,
implementation and assessment of health promotion in hospitals measurable
elements and indicators are being defined and a tool for self assessment is being
developed.
It is not the aim of WHO to externally assess the activities in hospitals in the
European Network of Health Promoting Hospitals, but hospitals within and other
hospitals are encourage using the self assessment tool for improving their health
promotion services.
The standards are considered public domain and quality agencies and
accreditation bodies are encouraged to include the standards for health
promotion in hospitals in their existing standards sets.
35
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Standards for health promotion in hospitals
Standards for health promotion in hospitals are listed below:-
Standard 1: Management Policy
The organization has a written policy for health promotion. The policy is
implemented as part of the overall organization quality improvement system,
aiming at improving health outcomes. This policy is aimed at patients, relatives
and staff.
Objective:
To describe the framework for the organization's activities concerning health
promotion as an integral part of the organization's quality management system.
Substandard:
1.1 The organization identifies responsibilities for the process of implementation,
evaluation and regular review of the policy.
1.2 The organization allocates resources to the processes of implementation,
evaluation and regular review of the policy.
1.3 Staff is aware of the health promotion policy and it is included in induction
programmers for new staff.
1.4 The organization ensures the availability of procedures for collection and
evaluation of data in order to monitor the quality of health promotion activities.
1.5 The organization ensures that staffs have relevant competences to perform
health promotion activities and supports the acquisition of further competences
as required.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Standards for health promotion in hospitals
Standards for health promotion in hospitals are listed below:-
Standard 1: Management Policy
The organization has a written policy for health promotion. The policy is
implemented as part of the overall organization quality improvement system,
aiming at improving health outcomes. This policy is aimed at patients, relatives
and staff.
Objective:
To describe the framework for the organization's activities concerning health
promotion as an integral part of the organization's quality management system.
Substandard:
1.1 The organization identifies responsibilities for the process of implementation,
evaluation and regular review of the policy.
1.2 The organization allocates resources to the processes of implementation,
evaluation and regular review of the policy.
1.3 Staff is aware of the health promotion policy and it is included in induction
programmers for new staff.
1.4 The organization ensures the availability of procedures for collection and
evaluation of data in order to monitor the quality of health promotion activities.
1.5 The organization ensures that staffs have relevant competences to perform
health promotion activities and supports the acquisition of further competences
as required.
36
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
1.6 The organization ensures the availability of the necessary infrastructure,
including resources, space, equipment, etc. in order to implement health
promotion activities.
Standard 2: Patient Assessment
The organization ensures that health professionals, in partnership with patients,
systematically assess needs for health promotion activities.
Objective: To support patient treatment, improve prognosis and to promote the
health and well-being of patients.
Substandard:
2.1 The organization ensures the availability of procedures for all patients to
assess their need for health promotion.
2.2 The organization ensures procedures to assess specific needs for health
promotion for diagnosis related patient-groups.
2.3 The assessment of a patient's need for health promotion is done at first
contact with the hospital.
This is kept under review and adjusted as necessary according to changes in the
patient's clinical condition or on request.
2.4 The patients' needs assessment ensures awareness of and sensitivity to social
and cultural background.
2.5 Information provided by other health service partners is used in the
identification of patient needs.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
1.6 The organization ensures the availability of the necessary infrastructure,
including resources, space, equipment, etc. in order to implement health
promotion activities.
Standard 2: Patient Assessment
The organization ensures that health professionals, in partnership with patients,
systematically assess needs for health promotion activities.
Objective: To support patient treatment, improve prognosis and to promote the
health and well-being of patients.
Substandard:
2.1 The organization ensures the availability of procedures for all patients to
assess their need for health promotion.
2.2 The organization ensures procedures to assess specific needs for health
promotion for diagnosis related patient-groups.
2.3 The assessment of a patient's need for health promotion is done at first
contact with the hospital.
This is kept under review and adjusted as necessary according to changes in the
patient's clinical condition or on request.
2.4 The patients' needs assessment ensures awareness of and sensitivity to social
and cultural background.
2.5 Information provided by other health service partners is used in the
identification of patient needs.
37
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Standard 3: Patient Information and Intervention
The organization provides patients with information on significant factors
concerning their disease or health condition and health promotion interventions
are established in all patient pathways.
Objective:
To ensure that the patient is informed about planned activities, to empower the
patient in an active partnership in planned activities and to facilitate integration
of health promotion activities in all patient pathways.
Substandard:
3.1 Based on the health promotion needs assessment, the patient is informed of
factors impacting on their health and, in partnership with the patient, a plan for
relevant activities for health promotion is agreed.
3.2 Patients are given clear, understandable and appropriate information about
their actual condition, treatment, care and factors influencing their health.
3.3 The organization ensures that health promotion is systematically offered to all
patients based on assessed needs.
3.4 The organization ensures that information given to the patient, and health
promoting activities are documented and evaluated, including whether expected
and planned results have been achieved.
3.5 The organization ensures that all patients, staff and visitors have access to
general information on factors influencing health.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Standard 3: Patient Information and Intervention
The organization provides patients with information on significant factors
concerning their disease or health condition and health promotion interventions
are established in all patient pathways.
Objective:
To ensure that the patient is informed about planned activities, to empower the
patient in an active partnership in planned activities and to facilitate integration
of health promotion activities in all patient pathways.
Substandard:
3.1 Based on the health promotion needs assessment, the patient is informed of
factors impacting on their health and, in partnership with the patient, a plan for
relevant activities for health promotion is agreed.
3.2 Patients are given clear, understandable and appropriate information about
their actual condition, treatment, care and factors influencing their health.
3.3 The organization ensures that health promotion is systematically offered to all
patients based on assessed needs.
3.4 The organization ensures that information given to the patient, and health
promoting activities are documented and evaluated, including whether expected
and planned results have been achieved.
3.5 The organization ensures that all patients, staff and visitors have access to
general information on factors influencing health.
38
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Standard 4: Promoting a Healthy Workplace
The management establishes conditions for the development of the hospital as a
healthy workplace.
Objective: To support the establishment of a healthy and safe workplace, and to
support health promotion activities for staff.
Substandard:
4.1 The organization ensures the establishment and implementation of a
comprehensive Human Resource Strategy that includes the development and
training of staff in health promotion skills.
4.2 The organization ensures the establishment and implementation of a policy
for a healthy and safe workplace providing occupational health for staff.
4.3 The organization ensures the involvement of staff in decisions impacting on
the staff's working environment.
4.4 The organization ensures availability of procedures to develop and
maintain staff awareness on health issues.
Standard 5: Continuity and Cooperation
The organization has a planned approach to collaboration with other health
service levels and other institutions and sectors on an ongoing basis.
Objective: To ensure collaboration with relevant providers and to initiate
partnerships to optimize the integration of health promotion activities in patient
pathways.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Standard 4: Promoting a Healthy Workplace
The management establishes conditions for the development of the hospital as a
healthy workplace.
Objective: To support the establishment of a healthy and safe workplace, and to
support health promotion activities for staff.
Substandard:
4.1 The organization ensures the establishment and implementation of a
comprehensive Human Resource Strategy that includes the development and
training of staff in health promotion skills.
4.2 The organization ensures the establishment and implementation of a policy
for a healthy and safe workplace providing occupational health for staff.
4.3 The organization ensures the involvement of staff in decisions impacting on
the staff's working environment.
4.4 The organization ensures availability of procedures to develop and
maintain staff awareness on health issues.
Standard 5: Continuity and Cooperation
The organization has a planned approach to collaboration with other health
service levels and other institutions and sectors on an ongoing basis.
Objective: To ensure collaboration with relevant providers and to initiate
partnerships to optimize the integration of health promotion activities in patient
pathways.
39
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Substandard:
5.1 The organization ensures that health promotion services are coherent with
current provisions and health plans.
5.2 The organization identifies and cooperates with existing health and social care
providers and related organizations and groups in the community.
5.3 The organization ensures the availability and implementation of activities and
procedures after patient discharge during the post-hospitalization period.
5.4 The organization ensures that documentation and patient information is
communicated to the relevant recipient/follow-up partners in patient care and
rehabilitation.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Substandard:
5.1 The organization ensures that health promotion services are coherent with
current provisions and health plans.
5.2 The organization identifies and cooperates with existing health and social care
providers and related organizations and groups in the community.
5.3 The organization ensures the availability and implementation of activities and
procedures after patient discharge during the post-hospitalization period.
5.4 The organization ensures that documentation and patient information is
communicated to the relevant recipient/follow-up partners in patient care and
rehabilitation.
40
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER FOUR
MANAGEMENT OF BLOOD BANKS IN HOSPITALS
Overview and background
• A well-organized blood transfusion service (BTS), with quality systems in all
areas, is a prerequisite for safe and effective use of blood and blood
products.
• The HIV/AIDS pandemic has focused particular attention on the importance
of preventing transfusion-transmitted infections (TTIs).
• Up to 3% of HIV infections worldwide are transmitted through the
transfusion of contaminated blood and blood products.
• Many more recipients of blood products are infected by hepatitis B and C
viruses, syphilis and other infectious agents, such as Changes disease.
• The global burden of disease due to unsafe blood transfusion can be
eliminated or substantially reduced through an integrated strategy for
blood safety which includes:-
✓ Establishment of a nationally-coordinated blood transfusion service.
✓ Collection of blood only from voluntary non-remunerated blood donors
from low-risk populations.
✓ Testing of all donated blood, including screening for transfusion-
transmissible infections, blood grouping and compatibility testing.
✓ Reduction in unnecessary transfusions through the effective clinical use
of blood, including the use of simple alternatives to transfusion
(crystalloids and colloids), wherever possible.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER FOUR
MANAGEMENT OF BLOOD BANKS IN HOSPITALS
Overview and background
• A well-organized blood transfusion service (BTS), with quality systems in all
areas, is a prerequisite for safe and effective use of blood and blood
products.
• The HIV/AIDS pandemic has focused particular attention on the importance
of preventing transfusion-transmitted infections (TTIs).
• Up to 3% of HIV infections worldwide are transmitted through the
transfusion of contaminated blood and blood products.
• Many more recipients of blood products are infected by hepatitis B and C
viruses, syphilis and other infectious agents, such as Changes disease.
• The global burden of disease due to unsafe blood transfusion can be
eliminated or substantially reduced through an integrated strategy for
blood safety which includes:-
✓ Establishment of a nationally-coordinated blood transfusion service.
✓ Collection of blood only from voluntary non-remunerated blood donors
from low-risk populations.
✓ Testing of all donated blood, including screening for transfusion-
transmissible infections, blood grouping and compatibility testing.
✓ Reduction in unnecessary transfusions through the effective clinical use
of blood, including the use of simple alternatives to transfusion
(crystalloids and colloids), wherever possible.
41
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Management of Blood Banks
• Blood is the part of life that is given to those who need it by those who
have the resource to satisfy the need. Emergencies occur every minute.
• For each patient requiring blood, it is an emergency and the patients could
have set back if blood is not available.
• The surgeries need blood, and also the blood is required in blood disease,
such as leukemia’s, thalassemia, and a blood cancer.
The main tasks of blood banks are as follows:-
1. Collection of Blood
2. Testing of the blood.
3. Storage of Blood.
4. Supply of Blood to the hospitals and other health facilities.
How we can collect a Blood?
1- Voluntary/intentional donors: - This kind of blood collection is done by the
voluntary organization, they are establishing blood camps in different
organization and institutions and they persuade the people to donate with the
poor and venerable patient and save their life.
2- Professional Donors: they are the private blood banks, even they collect the
blood voluntarily or they buy the blood and then they sale the blood.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Management of Blood Banks
• Blood is the part of life that is given to those who need it by those who
have the resource to satisfy the need. Emergencies occur every minute.
• For each patient requiring blood, it is an emergency and the patients could
have set back if blood is not available.
• The surgeries need blood, and also the blood is required in blood disease,
such as leukemia’s, thalassemia, and a blood cancer.
The main tasks of blood banks are as follows:-
1. Collection of Blood
2. Testing of the blood.
3. Storage of Blood.
4. Supply of Blood to the hospitals and other health facilities.
How we can collect a Blood?
1- Voluntary/intentional donors: - This kind of blood collection is done by the
voluntary organization, they are establishing blood camps in different
organization and institutions and they persuade the people to donate with the
poor and venerable patient and save their life.
2- Professional Donors: they are the private blood banks, even they collect the
blood voluntarily or they buy the blood and then they sale the blood.
42
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Some Critical issues in blood banks
1. Insufficient provision of Blood:-
• The blood bank is facing many problems, one of the most important one is
the lack of donor and volunteers, so this deficit is due to some
misconceptions and lack of education among the local people.
• To educate the people and to wash the brain of the people so the public
information campaign is so vital because the media is the blood of the war,
the volunteers and especially the youth should encourage to donate blood.
• As it is obvious that the volunteer organization can play a big role in the
collection of blood, through blood donation camps in different places, they
are supplying the blood just for a little payment because they are just
cutting their test expenses.
• If the blood is broken in to small components so we can protect this blood
from wastage by this way.
2. Blood Testing: -
• Among the blood banks some of them are just working to recover their cost
but some of them are subsided. With the emerge of AIDS these laboratory
costs are increased because the costs are increasing by this Test.
• It is so important for the blood banks to test the blood so carefully, because
it is the matter of life and death to the recipient of blood e.g. jaundice
typhoid, malaria and even the AIDS.
• It is not bad for the patient to pay more for a good quality of blood,
because it is secure from different infectious diseases.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Some Critical issues in blood banks
1. Insufficient provision of Blood:-
• The blood bank is facing many problems, one of the most important one is
the lack of donor and volunteers, so this deficit is due to some
misconceptions and lack of education among the local people.
• To educate the people and to wash the brain of the people so the public
information campaign is so vital because the media is the blood of the war,
the volunteers and especially the youth should encourage to donate blood.
• As it is obvious that the volunteer organization can play a big role in the
collection of blood, through blood donation camps in different places, they
are supplying the blood just for a little payment because they are just
cutting their test expenses.
• If the blood is broken in to small components so we can protect this blood
from wastage by this way.
2. Blood Testing: -
• Among the blood banks some of them are just working to recover their cost
but some of them are subsided. With the emerge of AIDS these laboratory
costs are increased because the costs are increasing by this Test.
• It is so important for the blood banks to test the blood so carefully, because
it is the matter of life and death to the recipient of blood e.g. jaundice
typhoid, malaria and even the AIDS.
• It is not bad for the patient to pay more for a good quality of blood,
because it is secure from different infectious diseases.
43
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
3. Staffing and workload:-
• When there is the collection time for blood so there is overcrowding of the
staff is exist, when this process end up so the overcrowding is became
decrease.
• The blood banks which are attached to the hospitals they are usually using
the trained staff of other hospitals, when the load is less so they are going
back to their own duties.
Internal blood banks vs. external blood banks
The advantage of the external blood banks are:--
❖ No capital investment-
❖ No staffing and management problems.
The Disadvantage:-
❖ Blood is not quickly available when it is needed.
❖ Patients can replace the blood immediately when he wants.
In-house blood banks depend on:--
❖ Having financial resources.-
❖ Location of hospitals near to private blood banks.-
❖ Basic equipments for example laboratory.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
3. Staffing and workload:-
• When there is the collection time for blood so there is overcrowding of the
staff is exist, when this process end up so the overcrowding is became
decrease.
• The blood banks which are attached to the hospitals they are usually using
the trained staff of other hospitals, when the load is less so they are going
back to their own duties.
Internal blood banks vs. external blood banks
The advantage of the external blood banks are:--
❖ No capital investment-
❖ No staffing and management problems.
The Disadvantage:-
❖ Blood is not quickly available when it is needed.
❖ Patients can replace the blood immediately when he wants.
In-house blood banks depend on:--
❖ Having financial resources.-
❖ Location of hospitals near to private blood banks.-
❖ Basic equipments for example laboratory.
44
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Establish a blood transfusion service
• It is the responsibility of governments to ensure a safe and adequate supply
of blood.
• This responsibility may be delegated to a non-profit nongovernmental
organization, but the BTS should be developed within the framework of the
country’s health care infrastructure.
• The BTS requires government commitment and support and recognition as
a separate unit with an adequate budget, management team and trained
staff.
Important activities in establishing a blood transfusion service include:
1. Formalization of government commitment and support
2. Development of a national blood policy and plan
3. Development of necessary legislation/ regulation for the BTS
4. Formation of an organization with responsibility and authority for the BTS
5. Formation of a BTS management committee
6. Appointment of a medical director
7. Appointment of a quality manager
8. Appointment, when necessary, of specialist BTS advisory groups
9. Appointment and training of staff experienced in each key aspect of the BTS
10. Development and implementation of a budgeting and finance system to
ensure a sustainable blood programmed through cost recovery and/or
annual budget allocation
11. Establishment of national quality system, including guidelines, standard
operating procedures, accurate records, monitoring and evaluation.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Establish a blood transfusion service
• It is the responsibility of governments to ensure a safe and adequate supply
of blood.
• This responsibility may be delegated to a non-profit nongovernmental
organization, but the BTS should be developed within the framework of the
country’s health care infrastructure.
• The BTS requires government commitment and support and recognition as
a separate unit with an adequate budget, management team and trained
staff.
Important activities in establishing a blood transfusion service include:
1. Formalization of government commitment and support
2. Development of a national blood policy and plan
3. Development of necessary legislation/ regulation for the BTS
4. Formation of an organization with responsibility and authority for the BTS
5. Formation of a BTS management committee
6. Appointment of a medical director
7. Appointment of a quality manager
8. Appointment, when necessary, of specialist BTS advisory groups
9. Appointment and training of staff experienced in each key aspect of the BTS
10. Development and implementation of a budgeting and finance system to
ensure a sustainable blood programmed through cost recovery and/or
annual budget allocation
11. Establishment of national quality system, including guidelines, standard
operating procedures, accurate records, monitoring and evaluation.
45
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Testing of donated blood
➢ Technical officer
➢ Screening strategies and protocols
➢ Training of laboratory technical staff
➢ Screening of all donated blood for TTIs
➢ Blood grouping and compatibility testing
➢ Good laboratory practice, including standard operating procedures (SOPs)
➢ Continuity in testing
➢ Effective blood cold chain
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Testing of donated blood
➢ Technical officer
➢ Screening strategies and protocols
➢ Training of laboratory technical staff
➢ Screening of all donated blood for TTIs
➢ Blood grouping and compatibility testing
➢ Good laboratory practice, including standard operating procedures (SOPs)
➢ Continuity in testing
➢ Effective blood cold chain
46
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER FIVE
HOSPITAL WASTE MANAGEMENT
INTRODUCTION
Biomedical waste management has recently emerged as an issue of major
concern not only to hospitals, nursing home authorities but also to the
environment. the bio-medical wastes generated from health care units depend
upon a number of factors such as waste management methods, type of health
care units, occupancy of healthcare units, specialization of healthcare units, ratio
of reusable items in use, availability of infrastructure and resources etc.
The proper management of biomedical waste has become a worldwide
humanitarian topic today. Although hazards of poor management of biomedical
waste have aroused the concern world over, especially in the light of its far-
reaching effects on human, health and the environment.
Now it is a well established fact that there are many adverse and harmful effects
to the environment including human beings which are caused by the “Hospital
waste” generated during the patient care. Hospital waste is a potential health
hazard to the health care workers, public and flora and fauna of the area. The
problems of the waste disposal in the hospitals and other health-care institutions
have become issues of increasing concern.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER FIVE
HOSPITAL WASTE MANAGEMENT
INTRODUCTION
Biomedical waste management has recently emerged as an issue of major
concern not only to hospitals, nursing home authorities but also to the
environment. the bio-medical wastes generated from health care units depend
upon a number of factors such as waste management methods, type of health
care units, occupancy of healthcare units, specialization of healthcare units, ratio
of reusable items in use, availability of infrastructure and resources etc.
The proper management of biomedical waste has become a worldwide
humanitarian topic today. Although hazards of poor management of biomedical
waste have aroused the concern world over, especially in the light of its far-
reaching effects on human, health and the environment.
Now it is a well established fact that there are many adverse and harmful effects
to the environment including human beings which are caused by the “Hospital
waste” generated during the patient care. Hospital waste is a potential health
hazard to the health care workers, public and flora and fauna of the area. The
problems of the waste disposal in the hospitals and other health-care institutions
have become issues of increasing concern.
47
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Definition
According to Biomedical Waste (Management and Handling) Rules, 1998 of India
“Any waste which is generated during the diagnosis, treatment or immunization
of human beings or animals or in research activities pertaining thereto or in the
production or testing of biological.
The Government of India (notification, 1998) specifies that Hospital Waste
Management is a part of hospital hygiene and maintenance activities. This
involves management of range of activities, which are mainly engineering
functions, such as collection, transportation, operation or treatment of processing
systems, and disposal of wastes.
One of the major achievements has been to change the attitudes of the operators
of health care facilities to incorporate good HCW management practices in their
daily operations and to purchase on-site waste management services from the
private sector.
Sources of Biomedical Waste
Hospitals produce waste, which is increasing over the years in its amount and
type. The hospital waste, in addition to the risk for patients and personnel who
handle them also poses a threat to public health and environment.
Major Sources
▪ Govt. hospitals/private hospitals/nursing homes/ dispensaries.
▪ Primary health centers.
▪ Medical colleges and research centers/ paramedic services.
▪ Veterinary colleges and animal research centers.
▪ Blood banks/mortuaries/autopsy centers.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Definition
According to Biomedical Waste (Management and Handling) Rules, 1998 of India
“Any waste which is generated during the diagnosis, treatment or immunization
of human beings or animals or in research activities pertaining thereto or in the
production or testing of biological.
The Government of India (notification, 1998) specifies that Hospital Waste
Management is a part of hospital hygiene and maintenance activities. This
involves management of range of activities, which are mainly engineering
functions, such as collection, transportation, operation or treatment of processing
systems, and disposal of wastes.
One of the major achievements has been to change the attitudes of the operators
of health care facilities to incorporate good HCW management practices in their
daily operations and to purchase on-site waste management services from the
private sector.
Sources of Biomedical Waste
Hospitals produce waste, which is increasing over the years in its amount and
type. The hospital waste, in addition to the risk for patients and personnel who
handle them also poses a threat to public health and environment.
Major Sources
▪ Govt. hospitals/private hospitals/nursing homes/ dispensaries.
▪ Primary health centers.
▪ Medical colleges and research centers/ paramedic services.
▪ Veterinary colleges and animal research centers.
▪ Blood banks/mortuaries/autopsy centers.
48
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
▪ Biotechnology institutions.
▪ Production units.
Minor Sources
▪ Physicians/ dentists’ clinics
▪ Animal houses/slaughter houses.
▪ Blood donation camps.
▪ Vaccination centers.
▪ Funeral services.
▪ Institutions for disabled persons
Classification of Bio-Medical Waste
The World Health Organization (WHO) has classified medical waste into eight
categories:
1. General Waste
2. Pathological
3. Radioactive
4. Chemical
5. Infectious to potentially infectious waste
6. Sharps
7. Pharmaceuticals
8. Pressurized containers
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
▪ Biotechnology institutions.
▪ Production units.
Minor Sources
▪ Physicians/ dentists’ clinics
▪ Animal houses/slaughter houses.
▪ Blood donation camps.
▪ Vaccination centers.
▪ Funeral services.
▪ Institutions for disabled persons
Classification of Bio-Medical Waste
The World Health Organization (WHO) has classified medical waste into eight
categories:
1. General Waste
2. Pathological
3. Radioactive
4. Chemical
5. Infectious to potentially infectious waste
6. Sharps
7. Pharmaceuticals
8. Pressurized containers
49
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Problems relating to biomedical waste
A major issue related to current Bio-Medical waste management in many
hospitals is that the implementation of Bio-Waste regulation is unsatisfactory as
some hospitals are disposing of waste in a haphazard, improper and
indiscriminate manner. Lack of segregation practices, results in mixing of hospital
wastes with general waste making the whole waste stream hazardous.
Inappropriate segregation ultimately results in an incorrect method of waste
disposal.
Inadequate Bio-Medical waste management thus will cause environmental
pollution, unpleasant smell, growth and multiplication of vectors like insects,
rodents and worms and may lead to the transmission of diseases like typhoid,
cholera, hepatitis and AIDS through injuries from syringes and needles
contaminated with human.
Various communicable diseases, which spread through water, sweat, blood, body
fluids and contaminated organs, are important to be prevented.
Need of biomedical waste management in hospitals
The reasons due to which there is great need of management of hospitals waste
such as:
1. Injuries from sharps leading to infection to all categories of hospital personnel
and waste handler.
2. nosocomial infections in patients from poor infection control practices and
poor waste management.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Problems relating to biomedical waste
A major issue related to current Bio-Medical waste management in many
hospitals is that the implementation of Bio-Waste regulation is unsatisfactory as
some hospitals are disposing of waste in a haphazard, improper and
indiscriminate manner. Lack of segregation practices, results in mixing of hospital
wastes with general waste making the whole waste stream hazardous.
Inappropriate segregation ultimately results in an incorrect method of waste
disposal.
Inadequate Bio-Medical waste management thus will cause environmental
pollution, unpleasant smell, growth and multiplication of vectors like insects,
rodents and worms and may lead to the transmission of diseases like typhoid,
cholera, hepatitis and AIDS through injuries from syringes and needles
contaminated with human.
Various communicable diseases, which spread through water, sweat, blood, body
fluids and contaminated organs, are important to be prevented.
Need of biomedical waste management in hospitals
The reasons due to which there is great need of management of hospitals waste
such as:
1. Injuries from sharps leading to infection to all categories of hospital personnel
and waste handler.
2. nosocomial infections in patients from poor infection control practices and
poor waste management.
50
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
3. Risk of infection outside hospital for waste handlers and scavengers and at
time general public living in the vicinity of hospitals.
4. Risk associated with hazardous chemicals, drugs to persons handling wastes
at all levels.
5. “Disposable” being repacked and sold by unscrupulous elements without
even being washed.
6. Drugs which have been disposed of, being repacked and sold off to
unsuspecting buyers.
7. Risk of air, water and soil pollution directly due to waste, or due to defective
incineration emissions and ash.
Biomedical Waste Management Process
There is a big network of Health Care Institutions in India. The hospital waste like
body parts, organs, tissues, blood and body fluids along with soiled linen, cotton,
bandage and plaster casts from infected and contaminated areas are very
essential to be properly collected, segregated, stored, transported, treated and
disposed of in safe manner to prevent nosocomial or hospital acquired infection.
1. Waste collection
2. Segregation
3. Transportation and storage
4. Treatment & Disposal
5. Transport to final disposal site
6. Final disposal
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
3. Risk of infection outside hospital for waste handlers and scavengers and at
time general public living in the vicinity of hospitals.
4. Risk associated with hazardous chemicals, drugs to persons handling wastes
at all levels.
5. “Disposable” being repacked and sold by unscrupulous elements without
even being washed.
6. Drugs which have been disposed of, being repacked and sold off to
unsuspecting buyers.
7. Risk of air, water and soil pollution directly due to waste, or due to defective
incineration emissions and ash.
Biomedical Waste Management Process
There is a big network of Health Care Institutions in India. The hospital waste like
body parts, organs, tissues, blood and body fluids along with soiled linen, cotton,
bandage and plaster casts from infected and contaminated areas are very
essential to be properly collected, segregated, stored, transported, treated and
disposed of in safe manner to prevent nosocomial or hospital acquired infection.
1. Waste collection
2. Segregation
3. Transportation and storage
4. Treatment & Disposal
5. Transport to final disposal site
6. Final disposal
51
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Biomedical Waste Treatment and Disposal
Health care waste is a heterogeneous mixture, which is very difficult to manage as
such. But the problem can be simplified and its dimension reduced considerably if
a proper management system is planned.
Incineration Technology
This is a high temperature thermal process employing combustion of the waste
under controlled condition for converting them into inert material and gases.
Incinerators can be oil fired or electrically powered or a combination thereof.
Broadly, three types of incinerators are used for hospital waste: multiple hearth
type, rotary kiln and controlled air types. All the types can have primary and
secondary combustion chambers to ensure optimal combustion. These are
refractory lined.
Environmental Impact
Treatment and disposal of healthcare waste may pose health risks indirectly
through the release of pathogens and toxic pollutants into the environment.
• Landfills can contaminate drinking-water if they are not properly constructed.
Occupational risks exist at disposal facilities that are not well designed, run, or
maintained.
Incineration of waste has been widely practiced, but inadequate incineration or
the incineration of unsuitable materials results in the release of pollutants into
the air and of ash residue. Incinerated materials containing chlorine can generate
dioxins and furans, which are human carcinogens and have been associated with
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Biomedical Waste Treatment and Disposal
Health care waste is a heterogeneous mixture, which is very difficult to manage as
such. But the problem can be simplified and its dimension reduced considerably if
a proper management system is planned.
Incineration Technology
This is a high temperature thermal process employing combustion of the waste
under controlled condition for converting them into inert material and gases.
Incinerators can be oil fired or electrically powered or a combination thereof.
Broadly, three types of incinerators are used for hospital waste: multiple hearth
type, rotary kiln and controlled air types. All the types can have primary and
secondary combustion chambers to ensure optimal combustion. These are
refractory lined.
Environmental Impact
Treatment and disposal of healthcare waste may pose health risks indirectly
through the release of pathogens and toxic pollutants into the environment.
• Landfills can contaminate drinking-water if they are not properly constructed.
Occupational risks exist at disposal facilities that are not well designed, run, or
maintained.
Incineration of waste has been widely practiced, but inadequate incineration or
the incineration of unsuitable materials results in the release of pollutants into
the air and of ash residue. Incinerated materials containing chlorine can generate
dioxins and furans, which are human carcinogens and have been associated with
52
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER SIX
HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM IN HOSPITALS
Definion
HRM is the business of people and also HRM refers to activities by which an
organization recruits, selects, trains, develops, motivates, evaluates,
compensates, and rewards people fairly.
The Human Resources Management (HRM) function includes a variety of
activities, and key among them is deciding what staffing needs you have and
whether to use independent contractors or hire employees to fill these needs,
recruiting and training the best employees, ensuring they are high performers,
dealing with performance issues, and ensuring your personnel and management
practices conform to various regulations.
The goal of the management of human resources function is to identify and
provide the right number of competent staff to meet the needs of patients served
by the hospital
A Growing Profession
As it is obvious to us that the current century as an era of development and
knowledge, the knowledge is expanding through the world by the emerging of
new decade, new technologies and new inventions and new observations and
even new experiments keep emerging, at the mean time many new proficient
fields and specialization have also emerged.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER SIX
HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM IN HOSPITALS
Definion
HRM is the business of people and also HRM refers to activities by which an
organization recruits, selects, trains, develops, motivates, evaluates,
compensates, and rewards people fairly.
The Human Resources Management (HRM) function includes a variety of
activities, and key among them is deciding what staffing needs you have and
whether to use independent contractors or hire employees to fill these needs,
recruiting and training the best employees, ensuring they are high performers,
dealing with performance issues, and ensuring your personnel and management
practices conform to various regulations.
The goal of the management of human resources function is to identify and
provide the right number of competent staff to meet the needs of patients served
by the hospital
A Growing Profession
As it is obvious to us that the current century as an era of development and
knowledge, the knowledge is expanding through the world by the emerging of
new decade, new technologies and new inventions and new observations and
even new experiments keep emerging, at the mean time many new proficient
fields and specialization have also emerged.
53
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
As compare to social sciences the rapid growth is more in physical such as medical
sciences is increased, because the financial and technological resources are more
assigned in this field.
Labour Management/Unionization
• Labour Management is one of the most important and even a crucial part
of Personnel Management. Since the emergence of unionization the
management has faced with many challenges and obstacles.
• Sometimes these unions are creating many problems and headache in the
hospitals, and we hope that they have contributed in a positive side such as
trade unions and so far.
• The constructive and destructive role of unions depends on some factors,
such as past management practices and leadership style, many union are
emerging like a virulent and infectious disease who are not following the
healthy personnel policies.
• But most unions and central Labour bodies are also active in their
communities, helping to make conditions better for working people and
their families, both union and non-union.
• Unions individually and collectively pressure the government on issues that
impact working people such as minimum wage, hours of work, health and
safety regulations and other employment standards.
• Unions have been at the forefront of struggles to preserve and protect
health care, education and other important public services. Unions fight
budget cuts and laws that help big business while eroding the quality of life
in our communities.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
As compare to social sciences the rapid growth is more in physical such as medical
sciences is increased, because the financial and technological resources are more
assigned in this field.
Labour Management/Unionization
• Labour Management is one of the most important and even a crucial part
of Personnel Management. Since the emergence of unionization the
management has faced with many challenges and obstacles.
• Sometimes these unions are creating many problems and headache in the
hospitals, and we hope that they have contributed in a positive side such as
trade unions and so far.
• The constructive and destructive role of unions depends on some factors,
such as past management practices and leadership style, many union are
emerging like a virulent and infectious disease who are not following the
healthy personnel policies.
• But most unions and central Labour bodies are also active in their
communities, helping to make conditions better for working people and
their families, both union and non-union.
• Unions individually and collectively pressure the government on issues that
impact working people such as minimum wage, hours of work, health and
safety regulations and other employment standards.
• Unions have been at the forefront of struggles to preserve and protect
health care, education and other important public services. Unions fight
budget cuts and laws that help big business while eroding the quality of life
in our communities.
54
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Functions of Human Resource Management:-
➢ Human resource planning
➢ Training and Development
➢ Employee Communication
➢ Staffing (recruitment and selection)
➢ Compensation and benefits
➢ Job design and Organization design
➢ Employee/Labour industrial relations.
➢ Performance Appraisal
Employees training and development:-
• Training and Development provides employees with background
information about an employer. It can also teach you a new skill and can
provide you with overall knowledge that can help you better perform your
job.
• If you are trying to teach a skill, a video or some type of visual aid can be
very beneficial. Seminars comprise another form of training
• These can be used to teach any size group and are very helpful in providing
a vast amount of information in a short period of time. Other types of
training can involve on-the-job observation in which you watch what others
are doing and learn while they work.
• all these different types of training, people can choose the best training for
their organization. Since it is important to provide clear, accurate and up to
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Functions of Human Resource Management:-
➢ Human resource planning
➢ Training and Development
➢ Employee Communication
➢ Staffing (recruitment and selection)
➢ Compensation and benefits
➢ Job design and Organization design
➢ Employee/Labour industrial relations.
➢ Performance Appraisal
Employees training and development:-
• Training and Development provides employees with background
information about an employer. It can also teach you a new skill and can
provide you with overall knowledge that can help you better perform your
job.
• If you are trying to teach a skill, a video or some type of visual aid can be
very beneficial. Seminars comprise another form of training
• These can be used to teach any size group and are very helpful in providing
a vast amount of information in a short period of time. Other types of
training can involve on-the-job observation in which you watch what others
are doing and learn while they work.
• all these different types of training, people can choose the best training for
their organization. Since it is important to provide clear, accurate and up to
55
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
date training, it is also important to revamp your training styles every
couple of years.
Benefits of Training and development:-
1. Increased job satisfaction and morale among employees
2. Increased employee motivation
3. Increased efficiencies in processes, resulting in financial gain
4. Increased capacity to adopt new technologies and methods
5. Increased innovation in strategies and products
Updating Medical Knowledge:-
• It is so necessary to keep the medical staff updated and trained in order to
fit them for the emergence of new technology in the medical field,
Participation in medical seminars, workshops, and joining medical
communities and reading the medical books, journals and literature is
essential but it is not enough.
• There is also advance in training technology such as the software and hard-
wares (videos, projectors, and other instruments).
Manpower Planning:-
• Personnel management is productive exploitation of manpower resources.
This is also termed as ‘Manpower Management’. Manpower Management
is choosing the proper type of people as and when required.
• It also takes into account the upgrading in existing people. Manpower
Management starts with manpower planning. Every manager in an
organization is a personnel man, dealing with people.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
date training, it is also important to revamp your training styles every
couple of years.
Benefits of Training and development:-
1. Increased job satisfaction and morale among employees
2. Increased employee motivation
3. Increased efficiencies in processes, resulting in financial gain
4. Increased capacity to adopt new technologies and methods
5. Increased innovation in strategies and products
Updating Medical Knowledge:-
• It is so necessary to keep the medical staff updated and trained in order to
fit them for the emergence of new technology in the medical field,
Participation in medical seminars, workshops, and joining medical
communities and reading the medical books, journals and literature is
essential but it is not enough.
• There is also advance in training technology such as the software and hard-
wares (videos, projectors, and other instruments).
Manpower Planning:-
• Personnel management is productive exploitation of manpower resources.
This is also termed as ‘Manpower Management’. Manpower Management
is choosing the proper type of people as and when required.
• It also takes into account the upgrading in existing people. Manpower
Management starts with manpower planning. Every manager in an
organization is a personnel man, dealing with people.
56
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Advantages of manpower planning:
Manpower planning ensures optimum use of available human resources.
1. 1It is useful both for medical organization and for others.
2. It generates facilities to educate people in the organization.
3. It brings about fast economic developments.
4. It boosts the geographical mobility of labor.
5. It provides smooth working even after expansion of the organization.
6. It opens possibility for workers for future promotions, thus providing
incentive.
7. It creates healthy atmosphere of encouragement and motivation in the
organization.
8. Training becomes effective.
9. It provides help for career development of the employees
Recruitment and selection
• Recruitment and selection is the important stage in HRM, actually the
selection processes, if use it inappropriately, may have the potential to
discriminate against certain groups. Equally subjective judgments based on
stereotypes, appearance, can disadvantage the applicant.
• The entire selection process must therefore be based on criteria related to
the requirements of the job, the necessary competencies to perform the
job and the potential for development such as intelligence, qualification,
aptitude.
• Interviewers need training, because every administrator or a medical
doctor cannot be a good interviewer.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Advantages of manpower planning:
Manpower planning ensures optimum use of available human resources.
1. 1It is useful both for medical organization and for others.
2. It generates facilities to educate people in the organization.
3. It brings about fast economic developments.
4. It boosts the geographical mobility of labor.
5. It provides smooth working even after expansion of the organization.
6. It opens possibility for workers for future promotions, thus providing
incentive.
7. It creates healthy atmosphere of encouragement and motivation in the
organization.
8. Training becomes effective.
9. It provides help for career development of the employees
Recruitment and selection
• Recruitment and selection is the important stage in HRM, actually the
selection processes, if use it inappropriately, may have the potential to
discriminate against certain groups. Equally subjective judgments based on
stereotypes, appearance, can disadvantage the applicant.
• The entire selection process must therefore be based on criteria related to
the requirements of the job, the necessary competencies to perform the
job and the potential for development such as intelligence, qualification,
aptitude.
• Interviewers need training, because every administrator or a medical
doctor cannot be a good interviewer.
57
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
• As we know in many private institutions the recruitment is done by referral
basis, while in governmental institutions the routine advertisements of the
posts, screening of documents, and then interviewing.
• So these all need an overhaul, and to introduce scientific methods for the
selection and recruitment in order to avoid nepotism and referral system.
Job and Organization design:-
• As it is clear from the definition of Job design, that job design is the
specification of the contents, method and relationships of the jobs to
satisfy technological and organizational requirements as well as the
personal needs of the job holder.
• So Like other organizations and institutions, hospital and health facilities
also have the same structure and roles; sometimes they are not able to
achieve their targeted goals and objectives. So hospitals need clear job
description and image, proper declaration of personnel policies and
procedures, organizational charts and so on as much the other
organizations have.
Employee Communication:-
• Effective communication have much more effect on the human and
organizational health, because if we have a proper channel and code of
communication, so it is not easy that we have face any problems, the
problems and obstacle is preventing by the virtue of effective
communication, effective communication is the blood of any organization.
• When there is a strike or the spread of infectious disease so in that time the
effective communication can play a significant role to control all the
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
• As we know in many private institutions the recruitment is done by referral
basis, while in governmental institutions the routine advertisements of the
posts, screening of documents, and then interviewing.
• So these all need an overhaul, and to introduce scientific methods for the
selection and recruitment in order to avoid nepotism and referral system.
Job and Organization design:-
• As it is clear from the definition of Job design, that job design is the
specification of the contents, method and relationships of the jobs to
satisfy technological and organizational requirements as well as the
personal needs of the job holder.
• So Like other organizations and institutions, hospital and health facilities
also have the same structure and roles; sometimes they are not able to
achieve their targeted goals and objectives. So hospitals need clear job
description and image, proper declaration of personnel policies and
procedures, organizational charts and so on as much the other
organizations have.
Employee Communication:-
• Effective communication have much more effect on the human and
organizational health, because if we have a proper channel and code of
communication, so it is not easy that we have face any problems, the
problems and obstacle is preventing by the virtue of effective
communication, effective communication is the blood of any organization.
• When there is a strike or the spread of infectious disease so in that time the
effective communication can play a significant role to control all the
58
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
matters. So newsletters, pamphlets, leaflets, slide presentations, and
cassettes are so essential for employee communication.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
matters. So newsletters, pamphlets, leaflets, slide presentations, and
cassettes are so essential for employee communication.
59
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER SEVEN
LEADERSHIP
Objective
At the end of this unit the trainee will be able to:
• Define Leadership
• Explain major notes of a leader
• Describe the general strategies in leadership
• Examine different aspects of a leader as a change agent
Definition
Definition Leadership and management are not defined the same way. For
example, the concept of leaders and managers is understood differently.
However, people often use these concepts interchangeably.
There are several ways of defining leadership, and yet, the essential features of
leadership are more or less reflected in most of the definitions. For example, the
following is one of the shortest definitions of leadership.
Leadership is a process of directing and influencing task-related activities of group
members.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER SEVEN
LEADERSHIP
Objective
At the end of this unit the trainee will be able to:
• Define Leadership
• Explain major notes of a leader
• Describe the general strategies in leadership
• Examine different aspects of a leader as a change agent
Definition
Definition Leadership and management are not defined the same way. For
example, the concept of leaders and managers is understood differently.
However, people often use these concepts interchangeably.
There are several ways of defining leadership, and yet, the essential features of
leadership are more or less reflected in most of the definitions. For example, the
following is one of the shortest definitions of leadership.
Leadership is a process of directing and influencing task-related activities of group
members.
60
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Main aspects of leadership
Although leadership is defined differently the main aspects of leadership include:
1. Involvement of other people in the leadership process. It is very difficult to
think of leadership without people.
2. Presence of unequal distribution of power among leaders and members.
Where leaders have very high power in the relationship.
3. There is influence of behavior of other people working with the leader and
employees. Some the influence is accepted by the subordinates and
employees. The acceptance is most often voluntarily.
4. Most of the relationships are attached with values and conviction.
There are many who say that leaders are borne and not made. These people try to
justify their theory by focusing on certain personal characteristics of leaders. For
example, some people identify effective leaders by their height. They say leaders
are generally tall. They give examples like Abraham Lincoln (President of the
USA) or Nelson Madella (former President of South Africa). However, others
argue that this is not true. For example, Napoleon who was a world class
Famous leader was not tall; he was rather short.
Other theories concentrate on the behavioral characteristics of leaders either
related to the tasks they are handling or the way they maintain the dynamics and
interactions among their followers and employees. Others would like to relate
leaders with the management techniques they are using in the leadership
process.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Main aspects of leadership
Although leadership is defined differently the main aspects of leadership include:
1. Involvement of other people in the leadership process. It is very difficult to
think of leadership without people.
2. Presence of unequal distribution of power among leaders and members.
Where leaders have very high power in the relationship.
3. There is influence of behavior of other people working with the leader and
employees. Some the influence is accepted by the subordinates and
employees. The acceptance is most often voluntarily.
4. Most of the relationships are attached with values and conviction.
There are many who say that leaders are borne and not made. These people try to
justify their theory by focusing on certain personal characteristics of leaders. For
example, some people identify effective leaders by their height. They say leaders
are generally tall. They give examples like Abraham Lincoln (President of the
USA) or Nelson Madella (former President of South Africa). However, others
argue that this is not true. For example, Napoleon who was a world class
Famous leader was not tall; he was rather short.
Other theories concentrate on the behavioral characteristics of leaders either
related to the tasks they are handling or the way they maintain the dynamics and
interactions among their followers and employees. Others would like to relate
leaders with the management techniques they are using in the leadership
process.
61
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
How do leaders influence other people?
1. The influence of leaders on other people is expressed through power
relationship. Power of a leader is defined as the ability of a leader to influence or
change the behavior of other people. The power of leaders comes from a number
of sources: it could be because of:
2. Their expertise or education/experience,
3. Their position in a government structure,
4. Acceptance in the community,
5. Degree of authority in rewarding and punishing others, etc.
However, it is good to note that educational level is not the critical aspect of
becoming a leader. Leaders are everywhere. We can find leaders in the
community, in government structures, in schools, in a village, etc.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
How do leaders influence other people?
1. The influence of leaders on other people is expressed through power
relationship. Power of a leader is defined as the ability of a leader to influence or
change the behavior of other people. The power of leaders comes from a number
of sources: it could be because of:
2. Their expertise or education/experience,
3. Their position in a government structure,
4. Acceptance in the community,
5. Degree of authority in rewarding and punishing others, etc.
However, it is good to note that educational level is not the critical aspect of
becoming a leader. Leaders are everywhere. We can find leaders in the
community, in government structures, in schools, in a village, etc.
62
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
What is vision or vision statement?
Definitions # 1
A vision is a mental developed image of possible and desirable suture states of
the organization as well as personal destiny. It is the ability to see the invisible.
Definition # 2
Vision separates the leader from manager managers see what is and leaders what
should be. Vision see beyond the horizon. 10% of the people are forward looking,
10% of the people are backward looking and 80% are watching to see who is
going to win. Example:- Albert Einstein once said, "Imagination is more important
than knowledge. Imagination or the smart use of knowledge is what separates
winners from losers.
Have Personality Trail of Visionary Leader
✓ See the invisible
✓ Welcome change
✓ Appreciate vulnerability (when people are honest to you
✓ Share knowledge
✓ energize others
✓ Benchmarking (applying) experience from people who have gone the same
need)
✓ Follow through
✓ Set ethical standards
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
What is vision or vision statement?
Definitions # 1
A vision is a mental developed image of possible and desirable suture states of
the organization as well as personal destiny. It is the ability to see the invisible.
Definition # 2
Vision separates the leader from manager managers see what is and leaders what
should be. Vision see beyond the horizon. 10% of the people are forward looking,
10% of the people are backward looking and 80% are watching to see who is
going to win. Example:- Albert Einstein once said, "Imagination is more important
than knowledge. Imagination or the smart use of knowledge is what separates
winners from losers.
Have Personality Trail of Visionary Leader
✓ See the invisible
✓ Welcome change
✓ Appreciate vulnerability (when people are honest to you
✓ Share knowledge
✓ energize others
✓ Benchmarking (applying) experience from people who have gone the same
need)
✓ Follow through
✓ Set ethical standards
63
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
A Good Visionary Leader:
✓ Takes a stand
✓ Builds and develops strong followers
✓ communicates often
✓ Plays up his/her strength (strength based leadership)
✓ Recognize that leadership is every where (not just at the top)
✓ is himself and believe in himself (what you see is what you get)
✓ Understands the game
✓ Has Devine interest, concern, and passion for followers and colleagues
✓ Learn from mistakes
✓ Makes sure that everyone is getting the massage
Understand who a leader is:
?????? the root of the word lead is a word meaning to go. It denotes travel from one
place to another. Leaders can be said to be those who go first. They are those
who step out to show others the directions in which to head. They are pioneers.
They are people who venture into annex plowed territory and uncharted seas.
They guide us to new destinations. They are ones who take us on places we have
never been before.
?????? Leadership is the capacity and willing to valley men and women to a common
purpose, and the character which inspire confidence.
?????? Leadership is influence, the ability of one person to influence others. One man
can lead others only to the extent that he can influence them.
?????? Leader is a man who knows the road, who can keep ahead, and who can pull
others after him/her.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
A Good Visionary Leader:
✓ Takes a stand
✓ Builds and develops strong followers
✓ communicates often
✓ Plays up his/her strength (strength based leadership)
✓ Recognize that leadership is every where (not just at the top)
✓ is himself and believe in himself (what you see is what you get)
✓ Understands the game
✓ Has Devine interest, concern, and passion for followers and colleagues
✓ Learn from mistakes
✓ Makes sure that everyone is getting the massage
Understand who a leader is:
?????? the root of the word lead is a word meaning to go. It denotes travel from one
place to another. Leaders can be said to be those who go first. They are those
who step out to show others the directions in which to head. They are pioneers.
They are people who venture into annex plowed territory and uncharted seas.
They guide us to new destinations. They are ones who take us on places we have
never been before.
?????? Leadership is the capacity and willing to valley men and women to a common
purpose, and the character which inspire confidence.
?????? Leadership is influence, the ability of one person to influence others. One man
can lead others only to the extent that he can influence them.
?????? Leader is a man who knows the road, who can keep ahead, and who can pull
others after him/her.
64
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
?????? A leader is a person who has the ability to get others to do what they don't
want to do, and like it.
?????? Leadership is the capacity to move, inspire and mobilize masses of people.
?????? A leader is a person who is passionate to achieve a goal and convinces others
by example to join him/her the same direction
Evaluate Your Effort
?????? Evaluate the outcome
?????? Be willing to evaluate oneself and everyone involued (one of the greatest
challenge that a leader may face is to go back to critic his/her performance)
?????? Don't see every thing as easy and as simple as you go along this road:
- don't be discouraged
- stay focused
- be willing to modify and change
- stay consistent
- lead beyond the cultural road blocks
- be willing to be criticized
- Try for the second time, third time, and so on (please be courageous not to give
up)
Lead today by having the tomorrow in
- The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams
- To keep leading, try to keep learning
- Value your listening and reading time at roughly times of your talking time. (This
will insure since one is on a course of continuous learning) and self-improvement.
- To learn from those who have doing better than the leader.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
?????? A leader is a person who has the ability to get others to do what they don't
want to do, and like it.
?????? Leadership is the capacity to move, inspire and mobilize masses of people.
?????? A leader is a person who is passionate to achieve a goal and convinces others
by example to join him/her the same direction
Evaluate Your Effort
?????? Evaluate the outcome
?????? Be willing to evaluate oneself and everyone involued (one of the greatest
challenge that a leader may face is to go back to critic his/her performance)
?????? Don't see every thing as easy and as simple as you go along this road:
- don't be discouraged
- stay focused
- be willing to modify and change
- stay consistent
- lead beyond the cultural road blocks
- be willing to be criticized
- Try for the second time, third time, and so on (please be courageous not to give
up)
Lead today by having the tomorrow in
- The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams
- To keep leading, try to keep learning
- Value your listening and reading time at roughly times of your talking time. (This
will insure since one is on a course of continuous learning) and self-improvement.
- To learn from those who have doing better than the leader.
65
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Core leadership competencies for a leader
- Setting clear direction
- Setting a good example
- Effective communication
- creating emotional alignment
- Bringing the best out of people
- acting as a change agent
- Decisions and action in times
- Crisis and uncertainty
A Leader as a change Agent
In order to change the culture of any organization:
1. Create and foster a vision of new future
2. face up to behavior, values and norms in the current culture that must
change
3. Nitrate and lead the change
4. create a willingness to separate from the past
5. Build shared ownership through organization wide participation
6. communicate the changes and new cultural messages
7. create a sense of urgency and excitement
8. model the behavior that supports the new vision
9. sustain momentum
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Core leadership competencies for a leader
- Setting clear direction
- Setting a good example
- Effective communication
- creating emotional alignment
- Bringing the best out of people
- acting as a change agent
- Decisions and action in times
- Crisis and uncertainty
A Leader as a change Agent
In order to change the culture of any organization:
1. Create and foster a vision of new future
2. face up to behavior, values and norms in the current culture that must
change
3. Nitrate and lead the change
4. create a willingness to separate from the past
5. Build shared ownership through organization wide participation
6. communicate the changes and new cultural messages
7. create a sense of urgency and excitement
8. model the behavior that supports the new vision
9. sustain momentum
66
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Summary
- Leaders will have an overview of global leadership - Leaders will be empowered
to take the next step in their journey of leadership - Leaders will have the courage
to become changes' agent. - Leaders will be motivated to be visionaries in leading
their organizations - Leaders will be exposed on how to lead their organizations in
the change process - Leaders will have a confidence to engage in change. Leaders
of to day are constantly confronted with a reality of a need for change. Leaders
face overwhelming decisions to make and changes to introduce. The strategies
established to introduce change, skills exercised to bring change, systems
structured for management and mechanisms developed for evaluation
determines the leader's effectiveness in his/her effort to bring change in the life
of their organization. Hence Health Extension Worker will be highly motivated to
grasp basic concepts of leadership and change management while reading this
concept paper
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Summary
- Leaders will have an overview of global leadership - Leaders will be empowered
to take the next step in their journey of leadership - Leaders will have the courage
to become changes' agent. - Leaders will be motivated to be visionaries in leading
their organizations - Leaders will be exposed on how to lead their organizations in
the change process - Leaders will have a confidence to engage in change. Leaders
of to day are constantly confronted with a reality of a need for change. Leaders
face overwhelming decisions to make and changes to introduce. The strategies
established to introduce change, skills exercised to bring change, systems
structured for management and mechanisms developed for evaluation
determines the leader's effectiveness in his/her effort to bring change in the life
of their organization. Hence Health Extension Worker will be highly motivated to
grasp basic concepts of leadership and change management while reading this
concept paper
67
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER EIGHT
SUPERVISION
Learning Objectives
• Define supervision,
• Appreciate the importance of supervision,
• Describe the purposes of making supervision,
• Understand and exercise the principles, processes and activities of supervision,
• List down the responsibilities and the roles to be played by supervisor, and
• Appreciate the importance of giving feedback after making supervision.
Definition
Supervision or control is a teaching-learning process of ensuring that workers
execute the work and spend money as per the plan. It is an investigative-
corrective process: investigative because if the work is no proceeding as pre
schedule or money is being over spend and corrective because suitable counter-
measures are taken to see that the deficiencies are made good.
For effective supervision, the manager should possess technical proficiency, tact
and leadership qualities. It is the art of guiding, instructing, and encouraging staff
initiative. It must be seen to be of value and the worker supervised must regard it
as a support and a way of improving competence.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER EIGHT
SUPERVISION
Learning Objectives
• Define supervision,
• Appreciate the importance of supervision,
• Describe the purposes of making supervision,
• Understand and exercise the principles, processes and activities of supervision,
• List down the responsibilities and the roles to be played by supervisor, and
• Appreciate the importance of giving feedback after making supervision.
Definition
Supervision or control is a teaching-learning process of ensuring that workers
execute the work and spend money as per the plan. It is an investigative-
corrective process: investigative because if the work is no proceeding as pre
schedule or money is being over spend and corrective because suitable counter-
measures are taken to see that the deficiencies are made good.
For effective supervision, the manager should possess technical proficiency, tact
and leadership qualities. It is the art of guiding, instructing, and encouraging staff
initiative. It must be seen to be of value and the worker supervised must regard it
as a support and a way of improving competence.
68
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Health service supervision is defined as "A process of guiding, helping, training
and encouraging staff to improve their performance in order to provide high
quality health services. "It is not fault finding. It is concerned with operational
running of the unit and should deal with the following key questions:
1. Do staffs understand the responsibilities and objectives that come with
their job?
2. How do staffs organize their works and what tasks have to be assigned to
them?
3. How do staffs deal with the problems and difficulties in their job?
4. Do staffs achieve high technical, ethical and legal standards in their job?
5. What personal and technical supports are required for the employer to
work effectively?
6. What measure can be taken to improve the performance of the staffs?
The supervisor should be able to make orders and issues instructions and in
addition to checking and reviewing performance. Through supervision, the
manager is monitoring, controlling and supporting.
An effective system of staff supervision is essential part of any such strategies and
must be given a priority status.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Health service supervision is defined as "A process of guiding, helping, training
and encouraging staff to improve their performance in order to provide high
quality health services. "It is not fault finding. It is concerned with operational
running of the unit and should deal with the following key questions:
1. Do staffs understand the responsibilities and objectives that come with
their job?
2. How do staffs organize their works and what tasks have to be assigned to
them?
3. How do staffs deal with the problems and difficulties in their job?
4. Do staffs achieve high technical, ethical and legal standards in their job?
5. What personal and technical supports are required for the employer to
work effectively?
6. What measure can be taken to improve the performance of the staffs?
The supervisor should be able to make orders and issues instructions and in
addition to checking and reviewing performance. Through supervision, the
manager is monitoring, controlling and supporting.
An effective system of staff supervision is essential part of any such strategies and
must be given a priority status.
69
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Kinds of Supervision
There are many ways of conducting supervision, but one example is sited below.
1. Task-Oriented
In this case, both quantity and quality of the task are taken into consideration.
One of the tasks that are examined is how a manager supervises his/her
subordinate.
2. Person-Oriented
Person-oriented supervision is the control of the workers based on the
understanding of their needs, past training and styles of working. Therefore, there
are no rigid rules of supervision. Supervision is tailored to the concerned workers
personality.
Responsibilities of Supervisors
1. Identify standards of good performance and communicate to staff
members.
2. Work with staff to periodically assess their performance compared to these
standards.
3. Provide feedback to staff about their performance.
4. Work with the staff and the community to identify appropriate
interventions that will lead to improve worker performance and delivery of
high quality service.
5. Mobilize resources from many different sources to implement
interventions.
6. Ensure that interventions have had the intended effect.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Kinds of Supervision
There are many ways of conducting supervision, but one example is sited below.
1. Task-Oriented
In this case, both quantity and quality of the task are taken into consideration.
One of the tasks that are examined is how a manager supervises his/her
subordinate.
2. Person-Oriented
Person-oriented supervision is the control of the workers based on the
understanding of their needs, past training and styles of working. Therefore, there
are no rigid rules of supervision. Supervision is tailored to the concerned workers
personality.
Responsibilities of Supervisors
1. Identify standards of good performance and communicate to staff
members.
2. Work with staff to periodically assess their performance compared to these
standards.
3. Provide feedback to staff about their performance.
4. Work with the staff and the community to identify appropriate
interventions that will lead to improve worker performance and delivery of
high quality service.
5. Mobilize resources from many different sources to implement
interventions.
6. Ensure that interventions have had the intended effect.
70
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Needs of a Supervisor
• Knowledge of the work
• Knowledge of responsibilities
• Skill in instructing
• Skill in improving methods
• Skill in leadership.
A supervisor gets results through people. People must be treated asindividuals.
This has to be understood by any supervisor.
Main Features of a Supervisor
1. Guidance and training
o Maintain regular contact with staff
o Manage performance problems
o Designing a supervisory system (plan, schedule and performance evaluation).
2. Assistance with resources and logistics
3. Support, encouragement and advocacy
4. Monitoring and evaluation.
Effective Supervision
To make an effective supervision and to facilitate the work, it is advisable to
remember and apply the following issues.
• Create good communication and understanding, and participatory discussions
with the staff. Encourage suggestions and participation. Even you need to talk
informally with your staff.
• Share the overall goals and objectives of the program with the staff.
• Respect your staff and the give praise to the contributions made.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Needs of a Supervisor
• Knowledge of the work
• Knowledge of responsibilities
• Skill in instructing
• Skill in improving methods
• Skill in leadership.
A supervisor gets results through people. People must be treated asindividuals.
This has to be understood by any supervisor.
Main Features of a Supervisor
1. Guidance and training
o Maintain regular contact with staff
o Manage performance problems
o Designing a supervisory system (plan, schedule and performance evaluation).
2. Assistance with resources and logistics
3. Support, encouragement and advocacy
4. Monitoring and evaluation.
Effective Supervision
To make an effective supervision and to facilitate the work, it is advisable to
remember and apply the following issues.
• Create good communication and understanding, and participatory discussions
with the staff. Encourage suggestions and participation. Even you need to talk
informally with your staff.
• Share the overall goals and objectives of the program with the staff.
• Respect your staff and the give praise to the contributions made.
71
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
• Identify the types of decisions or issues the staff feel are important.
• Develop and create team working and team spirit among the staff involved in
supervision.
• Equip yourself with a checklist.
• Select properly qualified staff with technical and managerial skill.
• Reward (in kind or cash) those with better performances.
Roles of a supervisor
Coach - A good supervisor places a high priority on coaching employees. Good
coaching involves working with employee’s to establish suitable goals, action
plan, and time liens.
Mentor - Te employee can look to the supervisor as a model for direction and
development.
Advocate for organization - Often the supervisor is the first person to tell
employees about new policies and programs from management. The supervisor
must be authentic, yet tactful.
Advocate for employee - The supervisor is often responsible to represent the
employee's request and to management, along with also representing the
employee's cases for deserving a reward.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
• Identify the types of decisions or issues the staff feel are important.
• Develop and create team working and team spirit among the staff involved in
supervision.
• Equip yourself with a checklist.
• Select properly qualified staff with technical and managerial skill.
• Reward (in kind or cash) those with better performances.
Roles of a supervisor
Coach - A good supervisor places a high priority on coaching employees. Good
coaching involves working with employee’s to establish suitable goals, action
plan, and time liens.
Mentor - Te employee can look to the supervisor as a model for direction and
development.
Advocate for organization - Often the supervisor is the first person to tell
employees about new policies and programs from management. The supervisor
must be authentic, yet tactful.
Advocate for employee - The supervisor is often responsible to represent the
employee's request and to management, along with also representing the
employee's cases for deserving a reward.
72
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Factors that influences supervisions
There are a number of factors that influences supervision and determine
supervision style. Some of them are:
1. The Task
In this case in which a high degree of consistency and uniformity of output are
required and work is determined by strict government policies and/or legislation,
then a more directive form of supervision may well be required.
Closed and defined tasks require an emphasis on a tighter and more directive
style of supervision. In this case where a high degree of activity and initiative are
required and are based on a relatively open learning approach, then a more
participative style is preferable.
2. The Supervisee
Maturity, as the capacity to set high but attainable goals (achievement-motivation),
willingness and ability to take responsibility, the education and experience of an
individual or a group are some of the factors to be considered from the supervisee.
Supervisory style, therefore, should change according to the situation. For
example, employees with low maturity require a high task orientation in their
supervision.
3. Time
The time factor is important in the sense that tasks governed by strict time limits
and emergency situations require a more directive style of leadership, which do
not allow for the discussion of the supervisors instructions and requirements.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Factors that influences supervisions
There are a number of factors that influences supervision and determine
supervision style. Some of them are:
1. The Task
In this case in which a high degree of consistency and uniformity of output are
required and work is determined by strict government policies and/or legislation,
then a more directive form of supervision may well be required.
Closed and defined tasks require an emphasis on a tighter and more directive
style of supervision. In this case where a high degree of activity and initiative are
required and are based on a relatively open learning approach, then a more
participative style is preferable.
2. The Supervisee
Maturity, as the capacity to set high but attainable goals (achievement-motivation),
willingness and ability to take responsibility, the education and experience of an
individual or a group are some of the factors to be considered from the supervisee.
Supervisory style, therefore, should change according to the situation. For
example, employees with low maturity require a high task orientation in their
supervision.
3. Time
The time factor is important in the sense that tasks governed by strict time limits
and emergency situations require a more directive style of leadership, which do
not allow for the discussion of the supervisors instructions and requirements.
73
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
5. The supervisor's own style and situations.
Individual style of supervision and the existing situation/condition may have
positive or negative impact on supervision. It is clear that individuals have
different behavior and character. Depending on the type of behavior an
individual possesses, the style of supervision also may be favored or affected. On
the other hand, situations may have also an impact on the style of the supervisor,
even if he/she has good knowledge on supervision. Internal and external forces
or conditions may dictate on the individual style. For example, in the case of and
an epidemic, where many people are suffering and dying of the disease, a
supervisor should take an immediate action on those who are not working
properly. "Do not be afraid to vary your type of supervision to suit the
circumstances."
Should supervision be based on task or relationship behavior?
Task behavior refers to the extent of which the supervisor defines roles and
specific activities and the means by which the supervisee fits into the operation of
the organization. Relationship behavior refers to the extent of which the
supervisor emphasizes personal contact and provides the social and personal
support for the supervisee.
In may respects, the task behavior is near to an autocratic approach while the
relationship behavior tends to be more democratic, open and consultative.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
5. The supervisor's own style and situations.
Individual style of supervision and the existing situation/condition may have
positive or negative impact on supervision. It is clear that individuals have
different behavior and character. Depending on the type of behavior an
individual possesses, the style of supervision also may be favored or affected. On
the other hand, situations may have also an impact on the style of the supervisor,
even if he/she has good knowledge on supervision. Internal and external forces
or conditions may dictate on the individual style. For example, in the case of and
an epidemic, where many people are suffering and dying of the disease, a
supervisor should take an immediate action on those who are not working
properly. "Do not be afraid to vary your type of supervision to suit the
circumstances."
Should supervision be based on task or relationship behavior?
Task behavior refers to the extent of which the supervisor defines roles and
specific activities and the means by which the supervisee fits into the operation of
the organization. Relationship behavior refers to the extent of which the
supervisor emphasizes personal contact and provides the social and personal
support for the supervisee.
In may respects, the task behavior is near to an autocratic approach while the
relationship behavior tends to be more democratic, open and consultative.
74
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Should supervision style adapt to the circumstances?
Contemporary approaches to management have criticized the view that there is a
"one best way" of managing that may be used universally, irrespective of time,
place or task. The burden is on adapting management to the particular
circumstances and the recognition that what is appropriate in one case is not
necessarily appropriate in another. This is certainly the case with supervision
styles which should not be seen a mutually exclusive and universally applicable.
The style of supervision adopted by individual supervisors will very much depend
upon the overall policy approach adopted by the organization and the values
expressed in organizational relations.
What skills are required for effective supervision?
Three types of skills that may facilitate 'effective supervision' are:
1. Technical Skills
It is highly essential and important in the specific area of work for supervision. The
supervisor should possess good experience and training in the area of concerned
in addition to knowledge of relevant legislation and organizational policies for
that area.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Should supervision style adapt to the circumstances?
Contemporary approaches to management have criticized the view that there is a
"one best way" of managing that may be used universally, irrespective of time,
place or task. The burden is on adapting management to the particular
circumstances and the recognition that what is appropriate in one case is not
necessarily appropriate in another. This is certainly the case with supervision
styles which should not be seen a mutually exclusive and universally applicable.
The style of supervision adopted by individual supervisors will very much depend
upon the overall policy approach adopted by the organization and the values
expressed in organizational relations.
What skills are required for effective supervision?
Three types of skills that may facilitate 'effective supervision' are:
1. Technical Skills
It is highly essential and important in the specific area of work for supervision. The
supervisor should possess good experience and training in the area of concerned
in addition to knowledge of relevant legislation and organizational policies for
that area.
75
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
2. Conceptual Skills
It refers to the ability of the supervisor to see specific problems in their wider
dimension in addition to applying a logical approach to the issues raised in
supervision. Improving skills here are problem identification and solving,
organizing, and planning in addition to a proactive management style.
4. Human Relation Skills
It is essential for ensuring the necessary comprehension, communication,
motivation, and employee development together with discipline in the
supervisory relation.
Process and Activities of Supervision
1. Preparation for supervision
In the preparatory stage the supervisor has to:
• Study the available documents (such as reports, charts, job descriptions, etc.)
• Identify the priorities for supervision
• Prepare a supervision schedule.
• Preparation of manpower, finance, and other relevant logistics to conduct the
supervision
• Discuss with partners about the supervision
The most important discrepancies and problems have to be identified and
prioritized thereby setting out a checklists of activities and tasks to which priority
attention should be given in respect to each program, district, institution or unit,
and type of health worker.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
2. Conceptual Skills
It refers to the ability of the supervisor to see specific problems in their wider
dimension in addition to applying a logical approach to the issues raised in
supervision. Improving skills here are problem identification and solving,
organizing, and planning in addition to a proactive management style.
4. Human Relation Skills
It is essential for ensuring the necessary comprehension, communication,
motivation, and employee development together with discipline in the
supervisory relation.
Process and Activities of Supervision
1. Preparation for supervision
In the preparatory stage the supervisor has to:
• Study the available documents (such as reports, charts, job descriptions, etc.)
• Identify the priorities for supervision
• Prepare a supervision schedule.
• Preparation of manpower, finance, and other relevant logistics to conduct the
supervision
• Discuss with partners about the supervision
The most important discrepancies and problems have to be identified and
prioritized thereby setting out a checklists of activities and tasks to which priority
attention should be given in respect to each program, district, institution or unit,
and type of health worker.
76
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
2. Conducting the Supervision
In this stage, the supervisor
• will establish contacts with appropriate persons and groups,
• Discuss the issues on the checklists,
• Review objectives and targets,
• Enter into more detailed discussion with the supervisees,
• Observe the supervisee in his/her work,
• Identify areas for follow up and gaps,
• Consult with community representatives, and
• Report to the health team.
3. Follow up of supervision
These stages should systematically set the particular solution to the individual‘s
problems. It is identified through the supervisors' report and the health teams'
program of work. It is important to clarify the objectives and targets, and then set
out the actions required in terms of training, timetable of activities, and changes
in logistic support. In order to secure a record for future supervision and clarify
action required, the supervisor should make a report. The experience of
supervision in the health sector
Studies and consultations show a number of key problems in many system of
supervision.
• Lack of skilled/experienced staff
• Lack of motivated staff
• Lack of resources to carry out supervision sustainable
• High turn of skilled manpower
• It is sometimes carried out without planning and scheduling
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
2. Conducting the Supervision
In this stage, the supervisor
• will establish contacts with appropriate persons and groups,
• Discuss the issues on the checklists,
• Review objectives and targets,
• Enter into more detailed discussion with the supervisees,
• Observe the supervisee in his/her work,
• Identify areas for follow up and gaps,
• Consult with community representatives, and
• Report to the health team.
3. Follow up of supervision
These stages should systematically set the particular solution to the individual‘s
problems. It is identified through the supervisors' report and the health teams'
program of work. It is important to clarify the objectives and targets, and then set
out the actions required in terms of training, timetable of activities, and changes
in logistic support. In order to secure a record for future supervision and clarify
action required, the supervisor should make a report. The experience of
supervision in the health sector
Studies and consultations show a number of key problems in many system of
supervision.
• Lack of skilled/experienced staff
• Lack of motivated staff
• Lack of resources to carry out supervision sustainable
• High turn of skilled manpower
• It is sometimes carried out without planning and scheduling
77
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
• Feedback is not given on time
• Most of the time those areas which are far away are notcovered by supervision.
• Lack of transportation to reach inaccessible areas
The experience of supervision in the health sector
Studies and consultations show a number of key problems in many system of
supervision.
• Lack of skilled/experienced staff
•lack of motivated staff
• Lack of resources to carry out supervision sustainable
• High turn of skilled manpower
• It is sometimes carried out without planning and scheduling
• Feedback is not given on time
• Most of the time those areas which are far away are not covered by supervision.
• Lack of transportation to reach inaccessible areas
• Supervisors and Supervisees have in sufficient time for supervision
• Supervision visits and sessions suffer from poor scheduling
• Supervisors do not have the necessary seniority and respect among the
employees
• Feedback does not occur in the supervisory process
• Supervisors fail to adopt the right supervisory style
• Supervision takes place sporadically and/or infrequently
• Nobody is responsible for ensuring that effective supervision occur
• Lack of preparation of supervision particularly in not prioritizing the issues for
supervision
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
• Feedback is not given on time
• Most of the time those areas which are far away are notcovered by supervision.
• Lack of transportation to reach inaccessible areas
The experience of supervision in the health sector
Studies and consultations show a number of key problems in many system of
supervision.
• Lack of skilled/experienced staff
•lack of motivated staff
• Lack of resources to carry out supervision sustainable
• High turn of skilled manpower
• It is sometimes carried out without planning and scheduling
• Feedback is not given on time
• Most of the time those areas which are far away are not covered by supervision.
• Lack of transportation to reach inaccessible areas
• Supervisors and Supervisees have in sufficient time for supervision
• Supervision visits and sessions suffer from poor scheduling
• Supervisors do not have the necessary seniority and respect among the
employees
• Feedback does not occur in the supervisory process
• Supervisors fail to adopt the right supervisory style
• Supervision takes place sporadically and/or infrequently
• Nobody is responsible for ensuring that effective supervision occur
• Lack of preparation of supervision particularly in not prioritizing the issues for
supervision
78
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
• Insufficient development supervisory skills
• Inadequate job descriptions confuse the supervisory process.
Classification of Supervision
1. Individual and Group Supervision
• Individual Supervision
Individual supervision takes place one-to-one bases between the supervisor and
supervisee. Some of the advantages are:
It allows dealing with the personal issues and to the particular problems of the
supervisee.
Can contribute to the motivation of the supervisee,
The supervision can adjust his/her style of supervision.
• Group Supervision
It may well be more appropriate to conduct group supervisory sessions. This
means that the supervisor would supervise community workers from a defined
geographic area at one time and one site, combining field contacts between a
supervisor and multiple community workers into one supervisory session.
Supervision can occur on a fixed schedule and the site can be rotated among the
community workers' villages in the area. This method introduces the possibility of
peer group support as problems an solutions are shared among co-workers and
colleagues in a learning process. Problems faced by the health workers might
even be common or interrelated and therefore require a more team.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
• Insufficient development supervisory skills
• Inadequate job descriptions confuse the supervisory process.
Classification of Supervision
1. Individual and Group Supervision
• Individual Supervision
Individual supervision takes place one-to-one bases between the supervisor and
supervisee. Some of the advantages are:
It allows dealing with the personal issues and to the particular problems of the
supervisee.
Can contribute to the motivation of the supervisee,
The supervision can adjust his/her style of supervision.
• Group Supervision
It may well be more appropriate to conduct group supervisory sessions. This
means that the supervisor would supervise community workers from a defined
geographic area at one time and one site, combining field contacts between a
supervisor and multiple community workers into one supervisory session.
Supervision can occur on a fixed schedule and the site can be rotated among the
community workers' villages in the area. This method introduces the possibility of
peer group support as problems an solutions are shared among co-workers and
colleagues in a learning process. Problems faced by the health workers might
even be common or interrelated and therefore require a more team.
79
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
2. Informal and Formal Supervision
Supervision is normally considered to be a relatively formal process with a
structure involving preparation, organized supervision sessions, regular frequency
and time limits, recognized stages and means for the gathering of information,
agenda setting, the keeping of records, and formal definition of actions to be
taken. Those recognized procedures lend seriousness to the supervisory process.
The pressure of time, the immediacy of a crises situation or the development of
highly interesting and important problems also requires supervision to be
conducted on a more formal basis. It is important, however, that this informality
should not become the predominant form of supervision. There is clearly a need
to ensure supervision takes on the form of a repeating system with a clear and
regular structure.
3. Direct and Indirect Supervision
Direct supervision involves the supervisor observing the supervisee in work
situations with the advantage that a clear understanding of problems and
valuable solutions can be developed.
Much supervision, however, takes place in an indirect manner relying on
interviews and records. The indirect method: is based more on the analysis of
documentation and the administration type action. It includes periodical review
of the diary, worksheets, records, etc. maintained by the worker
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
2. Informal and Formal Supervision
Supervision is normally considered to be a relatively formal process with a
structure involving preparation, organized supervision sessions, regular frequency
and time limits, recognized stages and means for the gathering of information,
agenda setting, the keeping of records, and formal definition of actions to be
taken. Those recognized procedures lend seriousness to the supervisory process.
The pressure of time, the immediacy of a crises situation or the development of
highly interesting and important problems also requires supervision to be
conducted on a more formal basis. It is important, however, that this informality
should not become the predominant form of supervision. There is clearly a need
to ensure supervision takes on the form of a repeating system with a clear and
regular structure.
3. Direct and Indirect Supervision
Direct supervision involves the supervisor observing the supervisee in work
situations with the advantage that a clear understanding of problems and
valuable solutions can be developed.
Much supervision, however, takes place in an indirect manner relying on
interviews and records. The indirect method: is based more on the analysis of
documentation and the administration type action. It includes periodical review
of the diary, worksheets, records, etc. maintained by the worker
80
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER NINE
IMPLEMENTATION
Learning Objectives
At the end of this Unit, the trainee will be able to:
Define implementation,
Ensure the availability and on timely deployment of all resources that are needed
for implementation,
Use time-table for proper follow up of implementation,
Decide on important issues to facilitate implementation,
Know that motivation of staff, coordination, monitoring and supervision of works
are vital for implementation, and
Understand factors that affect implementation and find means of alleviating
them.
Definition
It is putting a program into action or doing the work.
What is to be implemented depends on the plan. Once a program has been
planned and marketed, it must be implemented.
Implementation “consists of initiating the activity, providing assistance to it and
to its participant, problem-solving issues that may arise, and reporting on
progress.” To accomplish all of this, one has to select the most appropriate
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER NINE
IMPLEMENTATION
Learning Objectives
At the end of this Unit, the trainee will be able to:
Define implementation,
Ensure the availability and on timely deployment of all resources that are needed
for implementation,
Use time-table for proper follow up of implementation,
Decide on important issues to facilitate implementation,
Know that motivation of staff, coordination, monitoring and supervision of works
are vital for implementation, and
Understand factors that affect implementation and find means of alleviating
them.
Definition
It is putting a program into action or doing the work.
What is to be implemented depends on the plan. Once a program has been
planned and marketed, it must be implemented.
Implementation “consists of initiating the activity, providing assistance to it and
to its participant, problem-solving issues that may arise, and reporting on
progress.” To accomplish all of this, one has to select the most appropriate
81
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
implementation strategy and see that any special concerns associated with
implementation are handled properly.
Factors that facilitate Implementation
1.The implementer need to ƒ Know and review the plans drafted, ƒ Understand
the goals/objectives, ƒ Write detail activities based on the goals/objectives, ƒ
Arrange time-table, ƒ Assign responsible bodies, and ƒ Discuss with the
stakeholders.
2. Allocating the necessary Resources/Inputs
✓ Manpower Secure and deploy on time the necessary manpower in kind and
number.
✓ Money - Clear budget for capital and recurrent uses have to be available
and utilized effectively and efficiently. - Know the amount of budget
allocated for implementing the project/program/activity. - Close control of
the utilization is very essential. ƒ
✓ Materials - Obtain the necessary equipment and supplies on time. - Need
strict controlling on the utilization to prevent corruption.
✓ Information - Document all the necessary information about the progress
of the implementation. - Inform the stakeholders about the development
and if there is any constraint, etc. ƒ
✓ Time - Use time effectively. - Develop time-table to follow the
implementation
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
implementation strategy and see that any special concerns associated with
implementation are handled properly.
Factors that facilitate Implementation
1.The implementer need to ƒ Know and review the plans drafted, ƒ Understand
the goals/objectives, ƒ Write detail activities based on the goals/objectives, ƒ
Arrange time-table, ƒ Assign responsible bodies, and ƒ Discuss with the
stakeholders.
2. Allocating the necessary Resources/Inputs
✓ Manpower Secure and deploy on time the necessary manpower in kind and
number.
✓ Money - Clear budget for capital and recurrent uses have to be available
and utilized effectively and efficiently. - Know the amount of budget
allocated for implementing the project/program/activity. - Close control of
the utilization is very essential. ƒ
✓ Materials - Obtain the necessary equipment and supplies on time. - Need
strict controlling on the utilization to prevent corruption.
✓ Information - Document all the necessary information about the progress
of the implementation. - Inform the stakeholders about the development
and if there is any constraint, etc. ƒ
✓ Time - Use time effectively. - Develop time-table to follow the
implementation
82
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Implementation Timetable To provide some guidance in implementing a program,
it is helpful to compile a tentative timetable for implementation. It might even be
useful to include the entire planning process.
3. Create good relation with the stakeholders at all levels. More emphasis has to
be given to the immediate manager.
4. Coordination of the work Coordination of the work will facilitate
implementation and will help to complete the program on time. Some of the
areas to be considered in coordination are: ƒ
Give defined responsibilities to the staff. ƒ
Give authority that can balance the authority offered. ƒ
Person in charge have to be assigned and be known by all. ƒ
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Implementation Timetable To provide some guidance in implementing a program,
it is helpful to compile a tentative timetable for implementation. It might even be
useful to include the entire planning process.
3. Create good relation with the stakeholders at all levels. More emphasis has to
be given to the immediate manager.
4. Coordination of the work Coordination of the work will facilitate
implementation and will help to complete the program on time. Some of the
areas to be considered in coordination are: ƒ
Give defined responsibilities to the staff. ƒ
Give authority that can balance the authority offered. ƒ
Person in charge have to be assigned and be known by all. ƒ
83
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Develop check lists that will guide coordination such as:
✓ What is to be done?
✓ Where does the action will take place?
✓ When will be the action will take place?
✓ Which materials and equipment are needed?
✓ Who will be responsible at each level?
General and specific responsibilities have to be clearly stated and known by all
concerned. Etc
5. Communication Directives and coordination will go smoothly if there is proper
communication on the ground ƒ Create link with the necessary stakeholders
including the community.
Develop organizational structure, which will help you to know the authority,
responsibility and who makes decision, etc. ƒ
Communicating with staff, government agencies, community, and other relevant
stakeholders will enhance and facilitate the implementation process. Create
networking with all stakeholders. ƒ
Intersectrol communication and collaboration will enhance the implementation
process
6. Monitoring and Supervision Monitoring is a continuous, systematic and critical
review of a project/program/activity with the aim of checking progress. Corrective
action has to be taken if any gap is detected during monitoring.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Develop check lists that will guide coordination such as:
✓ What is to be done?
✓ Where does the action will take place?
✓ When will be the action will take place?
✓ Which materials and equipment are needed?
✓ Who will be responsible at each level?
General and specific responsibilities have to be clearly stated and known by all
concerned. Etc
5. Communication Directives and coordination will go smoothly if there is proper
communication on the ground ƒ Create link with the necessary stakeholders
including the community.
Develop organizational structure, which will help you to know the authority,
responsibility and who makes decision, etc. ƒ
Communicating with staff, government agencies, community, and other relevant
stakeholders will enhance and facilitate the implementation process. Create
networking with all stakeholders. ƒ
Intersectrol communication and collaboration will enhance the implementation
process
6. Monitoring and Supervision Monitoring is a continuous, systematic and critical
review of a project/program/activity with the aim of checking progress. Corrective
action has to be taken if any gap is detected during monitoring.
84
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
During monitoring check ƒ
✓ If activities are implemented as planned or not, ƒ
✓ If the time is properly utilized, ƒ If the necessary manpower is
deployed, ƒ
✓ If the necessary resources utilized properly, ƒ
✓ If there is a need of modifying/changing, etc.
Use of Log Frames, Activity Plans, and Schedules will help to monitor progress.
Periodic supervision has to be made to know the progress of the implementation.
It needs to be planned. It is to maintain and improve the quality of
implementation of program/activity. Supervision can be conducted either directly
by observing the implementation at the site or indirectly by checking reports.
Decisions on Implementation
First: Ensure that program activities are executed as planned and services
delivered as intended. Coordination of activities on time and place are the first to
be considered.
Second: The deployment of personnel in the right number, time and place.
Organizing, directing and supervising.
Third: Mobilization and allocation of the necessary resources. Monitoring and
controlling, logistics deploying, accounting and organizing have to be undertaken
for proper implementation of programs/activities.
Fourth: The information needed in relation to implementation. Decision on
What? And Why? – Adequate quantity and quality. From where? - Which
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
During monitoring check ƒ
✓ If activities are implemented as planned or not, ƒ
✓ If the time is properly utilized, ƒ If the necessary manpower is
deployed, ƒ
✓ If the necessary resources utilized properly, ƒ
✓ If there is a need of modifying/changing, etc.
Use of Log Frames, Activity Plans, and Schedules will help to monitor progress.
Periodic supervision has to be made to know the progress of the implementation.
It needs to be planned. It is to maintain and improve the quality of
implementation of program/activity. Supervision can be conducted either directly
by observing the implementation at the site or indirectly by checking reports.
Decisions on Implementation
First: Ensure that program activities are executed as planned and services
delivered as intended. Coordination of activities on time and place are the first to
be considered.
Second: The deployment of personnel in the right number, time and place.
Organizing, directing and supervising.
Third: Mobilization and allocation of the necessary resources. Monitoring and
controlling, logistics deploying, accounting and organizing have to be undertaken
for proper implementation of programs/activities.
Fourth: The information needed in relation to implementation. Decision on
What? And Why? – Adequate quantity and quality. From where? - Which
85
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
sources? How? – Processing and putting together, analyzed, reported, etc.
To whom to be communicated?
Factors affecting Implementation/ Causes of Poor Implementation
Poor implementation means delayed or non-implemented or different from that
planned. The factors for such causes could be unavoidable or failure at earlier
parts of the planning cycle or failure at the programming and implementation
stages. The factors could be internal, such as turnover of trained staff or external
such as natural calamities, shortage of fund, etc.
Factors ƒ
❖ A change in priorities/ polices. So we need to be flexible in our planning.
❖ Resistance to the changes. It can be internal and external and it is
anticipated. So you should overcome and absorb it.
❖ Lack on the necessary resources. This can be due to external, unforeseeable
circumstances or poor design. ƒ
❖ Imprecisely specified project/program. This can be due to a failure to
quantify, identify, when the resources are required. ƒ
❖ Lack of appropriate organizational structures. ƒ
❖ Lack of appropriate managerial skills. ƒ
❖ Unforeseen circumstances, e.g. famine, war, etc.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
sources? How? – Processing and putting together, analyzed, reported, etc.
To whom to be communicated?
Factors affecting Implementation/ Causes of Poor Implementation
Poor implementation means delayed or non-implemented or different from that
planned. The factors for such causes could be unavoidable or failure at earlier
parts of the planning cycle or failure at the programming and implementation
stages. The factors could be internal, such as turnover of trained staff or external
such as natural calamities, shortage of fund, etc.
Factors ƒ
❖ A change in priorities/ polices. So we need to be flexible in our planning.
❖ Resistance to the changes. It can be internal and external and it is
anticipated. So you should overcome and absorb it.
❖ Lack on the necessary resources. This can be due to external, unforeseeable
circumstances or poor design. ƒ
❖ Imprecisely specified project/program. This can be due to a failure to
quantify, identify, when the resources are required. ƒ
❖ Lack of appropriate organizational structures. ƒ
❖ Lack of appropriate managerial skills. ƒ
❖ Unforeseen circumstances, e.g. famine, war, etc.
86
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
The solutions for the above factors depend on the individual cause. The
implementer has to find the main causes and act accordingly.
He/She should act immediately on those areas under their control. Those areas
which are beyond their capacity have to be communicated to the responsible
bodies immediately.
Effective Performance Measurement Process
These measurement process needs due attention by any implementer:
❖ Incorporate stakeholders input
❖ Promotes top leadership support
❖ Creates a clear mission statement
❖ Formulate short-term goals
❖ Devises simple, manageable approaches; and ƒ
❖ Provides support and technical assistances to those involved in the process.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
The solutions for the above factors depend on the individual cause. The
implementer has to find the main causes and act accordingly.
He/She should act immediately on those areas under their control. Those areas
which are beyond their capacity have to be communicated to the responsible
bodies immediately.
Effective Performance Measurement Process
These measurement process needs due attention by any implementer:
❖ Incorporate stakeholders input
❖ Promotes top leadership support
❖ Creates a clear mission statement
❖ Formulate short-term goals
❖ Devises simple, manageable approaches; and ƒ
❖ Provides support and technical assistances to those involved in the process.
87
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER TEN
EVALUATION
Learning Objectives
At the end of this unit, the trainee will be able to:
• Define evaluation,
• Appreciate the purposes of doing evaluation,
• know the steps in evaluation,
• Identify practical problems in evaluation and find means of solving them,
• Know the similarities and differences of evaluation and monitoring, and
• Describe indicators and know the importance of indicators in evaluation.
Health services have become complex. There has been a growing concern about
their functioning both in the developed and developing countries. Questions are
raised about the quality of medical care, Utilization and coverage of health
services, benefits to community health in terms of morbidity and mortality
reduction, and improvement in the health status of the recipients of care. An
evaluation study addresses itself to these issues
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
CHAPTER TEN
EVALUATION
Learning Objectives
At the end of this unit, the trainee will be able to:
• Define evaluation,
• Appreciate the purposes of doing evaluation,
• know the steps in evaluation,
• Identify practical problems in evaluation and find means of solving them,
• Know the similarities and differences of evaluation and monitoring, and
• Describe indicators and know the importance of indicators in evaluation.
Health services have become complex. There has been a growing concern about
their functioning both in the developed and developing countries. Questions are
raised about the quality of medical care, Utilization and coverage of health
services, benefits to community health in terms of morbidity and mortality
reduction, and improvement in the health status of the recipients of care. An
evaluation study addresses itself to these issues
88
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Definition
It is the methodical process of determining the worth of a system, project, course
of action, campaign, etc. It involves the comparison of the actual performance of
the system.
It is also defined as a systemic way of learning from experience and using the
lessons learned to improve current activities and promote better planning by
careful selection of alternatives for future action or as asking, “Did we achieve
what we set out to do?” and comparing the present situation with the past in
order to find out to what extent organizing purposes have been achieved.
All in all it is determining the value or worth of the objects of interest (health
programs) against standards of acceptability.
Meaningful evaluation requires clear thinking, profound learning, modify/make
new plans, takes corrective actions and provide feedback on time.
It is carried out mainly as a way of looking at program activities, human resources,
material resources, information, and facts and figures; in order to monitor
progress and effectiveness, consider costs and efficiency, show where changes
were needed, and help to plan more effectively for the future. Hence, evaluation
is a continuous process.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Definition
It is the methodical process of determining the worth of a system, project, course
of action, campaign, etc. It involves the comparison of the actual performance of
the system.
It is also defined as a systemic way of learning from experience and using the
lessons learned to improve current activities and promote better planning by
careful selection of alternatives for future action or as asking, “Did we achieve
what we set out to do?” and comparing the present situation with the past in
order to find out to what extent organizing purposes have been achieved.
All in all it is determining the value or worth of the objects of interest (health
programs) against standards of acceptability.
Meaningful evaluation requires clear thinking, profound learning, modify/make
new plans, takes corrective actions and provide feedback on time.
It is carried out mainly as a way of looking at program activities, human resources,
material resources, information, and facts and figures; in order to monitor
progress and effectiveness, consider costs and efficiency, show where changes
were needed, and help to plan more effectively for the future. Hence, evaluation
is a continuous process.
89
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Evaluation: - cannot be expected to do anything
What it can often do is: -
1. To show the main achievements/findings;
2. To show where and how changes can be made;
3. To show how strengths can be built upon;
4. To provide information;
5. To increase skills for planning; and
6. To increase skills in decision-making.
The results of evaluation are expected to show:
What a program has been trying to do?;
What actually happened?
Where the differences/gaps between the plan and the Actions has happened
The reasons for the difference/gaps, and
What needs to be done?
Evaluation involves finding the answers to the following questions:
✓ Are workers performing well as planned?
✓ Is equipment functioning as effectively as expected?
✓ Are resources being utilized fully?
✓ Are records being maintained correctly?
✓ Are the collective actions of the workers producing expected results?
✓ Purposes of Evaluation
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Evaluation: - cannot be expected to do anything
What it can often do is: -
1. To show the main achievements/findings;
2. To show where and how changes can be made;
3. To show how strengths can be built upon;
4. To provide information;
5. To increase skills for planning; and
6. To increase skills in decision-making.
The results of evaluation are expected to show:
What a program has been trying to do?;
What actually happened?
Where the differences/gaps between the plan and the Actions has happened
The reasons for the difference/gaps, and
What needs to be done?
Evaluation involves finding the answers to the following questions:
✓ Are workers performing well as planned?
✓ Is equipment functioning as effectively as expected?
✓ Are resources being utilized fully?
✓ Are records being maintained correctly?
✓ Are the collective actions of the workers producing expected results?
✓ Purposes of Evaluation
90
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
The main purposes of evaluation may be generalized as:
• To note the shortcomings, deficiencies, duplicities, etc. in the system. Suitable
corrective actions need to be undertaken.
• To justify the governmental expenditure on a program by demonstrating its
worth and convincing the people that their money is being well utilized.
Stakeholders be it in health or other sectors, they need programs to be evaluated
and the necessary measurements to be undertaken.
Six general reasons why stakeholders may want programs to be evaluated.
1. To determine the achievements of objectives related to improved health
status.
2. To improve program implementation. Through it weak elements can be
identified, removed and replaced.
3. To provide accountability to funders, community and other stakeholders. An
evaluation may provide decision makers with the information to determine if the
program funding should continue, discontinue or expand.
4. To increase community support for initiatives.
Positive evaluation information channeled through the media can help sell a
program, which in turn may lead to additional funding.
5. To contribute to the scientific basis for community public health intervention.
Program evaluation can provide funding that can lead to new hypothesis about
human behavior and community change, which in turn may lead to new and
better programs.
6. To inform policy decisions. Program evaluation data can be used to impact
policy within the community.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
The main purposes of evaluation may be generalized as:
• To note the shortcomings, deficiencies, duplicities, etc. in the system. Suitable
corrective actions need to be undertaken.
• To justify the governmental expenditure on a program by demonstrating its
worth and convincing the people that their money is being well utilized.
Stakeholders be it in health or other sectors, they need programs to be evaluated
and the necessary measurements to be undertaken.
Six general reasons why stakeholders may want programs to be evaluated.
1. To determine the achievements of objectives related to improved health
status.
2. To improve program implementation. Through it weak elements can be
identified, removed and replaced.
3. To provide accountability to funders, community and other stakeholders. An
evaluation may provide decision makers with the information to determine if the
program funding should continue, discontinue or expand.
4. To increase community support for initiatives.
Positive evaluation information channeled through the media can help sell a
program, which in turn may lead to additional funding.
5. To contribute to the scientific basis for community public health intervention.
Program evaluation can provide funding that can lead to new hypothesis about
human behavior and community change, which in turn may lead to new and
better programs.
6. To inform policy decisions. Program evaluation data can be used to impact
policy within the community.
91
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
The Process of Evaluation
It is spiral and the steps have to be followed properly.
1. Deciding when and how to evaluate: Planning
2. Selecting objectives and methods to be used: Planning
3. Carry out the evaluation: Data collection
4. Looking of the results: Data analysis
5. Using the results to improve the program: report and Application.
Planning:
Why do you need to plan evaluation?
Planning evaluation means: planning is an organized method by which you can
work out how you intend to reach your evaluation objectives and when.
Planning helps you to: ƒ
Select the priorities and objectives of the evaluation ƒ
Indicate the kind of methods you need to use ƒ
Decide what you need to do in detail ƒ
Decide the role each person will play in the evaluation ƒ
Indicate how long the evaluation will take and how much it will cost ƒ
See how one part the evaluation relates to the others ƒ
Increase skills in planning & organization. ƒ
Review the program goals and objectives
- Determine whether the necessary resources are available
- Determine the evaluation design ƒ
Determine whether the evaluation questions reflect the goals and objectives of
the program.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
The Process of Evaluation
It is spiral and the steps have to be followed properly.
1. Deciding when and how to evaluate: Planning
2. Selecting objectives and methods to be used: Planning
3. Carry out the evaluation: Data collection
4. Looking of the results: Data analysis
5. Using the results to improve the program: report and Application.
Planning:
Why do you need to plan evaluation?
Planning evaluation means: planning is an organized method by which you can
work out how you intend to reach your evaluation objectives and when.
Planning helps you to: ƒ
Select the priorities and objectives of the evaluation ƒ
Indicate the kind of methods you need to use ƒ
Decide what you need to do in detail ƒ
Decide the role each person will play in the evaluation ƒ
Indicate how long the evaluation will take and how much it will cost ƒ
See how one part the evaluation relates to the others ƒ
Increase skills in planning & organization. ƒ
Review the program goals and objectives
- Determine whether the necessary resources are available
- Determine the evaluation design ƒ
Determine whether the evaluation questions reflect the goals and objectives of
the program.
92
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Data collection: ƒ
How to collect: survey, records and documents, telephone and personal
interview, observation ƒ who will collect? Etc.
Data analysis: ƒ How to analyze; - who will analyze? Etc.
Reporting:
Who will receive the results? ƒ who will report the findings? ƒ How to
disseminate? Etc.
Application: ƒ
Determine how the results can be implemented
The General Approach to evaluate:
Five Steps:
Deciding- what aspects of programs are to be evaluated/measurecd?
Collecting- the information- evidence findings.
Comparing the results with targets/objectives.
Judging- target/objectives met.
Deciding to continue unchanged/changed steps and finally giving feedback.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Data collection: ƒ
How to collect: survey, records and documents, telephone and personal
interview, observation ƒ who will collect? Etc.
Data analysis: ƒ How to analyze; - who will analyze? Etc.
Reporting:
Who will receive the results? ƒ who will report the findings? ƒ How to
disseminate? Etc.
Application: ƒ
Determine how the results can be implemented
The General Approach to evaluate:
Five Steps:
Deciding- what aspects of programs are to be evaluated/measurecd?
Collecting- the information- evidence findings.
Comparing the results with targets/objectives.
Judging- target/objectives met.
Deciding to continue unchanged/changed steps and finally giving feedback.
93
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Who will conduct the evaluation?
The evaluator may be someone associated with the program or someone from
outside.
If someone trained in evaluation, who is personally involved with the program
conducts the evaluation, it is called an Internal Evaluation.
Advantages:
?????? Making it easier to collect the relevant information,
?????? Less expensive.
Major Drawbacks:
?????? Evaluator bias or conflict of interest.
An External Evaluation is one conducted by someone who is not conducted with
the program.
Advantage:
• Can provide a more objective outlook and a fresh perspective, and it helps to
ensure unbiased outcome of evaluation.
Disadvantage:
• More expensive.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
Who will conduct the evaluation?
The evaluator may be someone associated with the program or someone from
outside.
If someone trained in evaluation, who is personally involved with the program
conducts the evaluation, it is called an Internal Evaluation.
Advantages:
?????? Making it easier to collect the relevant information,
?????? Less expensive.
Major Drawbacks:
?????? Evaluator bias or conflict of interest.
An External Evaluation is one conducted by someone who is not conducted with
the program.
Advantage:
• Can provide a more objective outlook and a fresh perspective, and it helps to
ensure unbiased outcome of evaluation.
Disadvantage:
• More expensive.
94
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
General steps of evaluation
The basic steps involved are as follows:
1. Determine what is to be evaluated
2. Establish standards and criteria
3. Plan the methodology to be applied
4. Gather information
5. Analyze the result
6. Take action
7. Re-evaluate
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
General steps of evaluation
The basic steps involved are as follows:
1. Determine what is to be evaluated
2. Establish standards and criteria
3. Plan the methodology to be applied
4. Gather information
5. Analyze the result
6. Take action
7. Re-evaluate
95
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
References:
1. Marie-Therese Fewerstein, Partners in Evaluation, 1986, London.
2. James F. Mckenzie, Jan L. Smelitzer, Planning, Implementing and Evaluating
Health Promotion Program, third edition, 2001, USA.
3. Stephen M. Shortell, Arnold D. Kaluzny, Essentials of Health Care Management,
1997, USA.
4. Rosemary Mcmahon and others, On Being In Charge, A Guide to Management
in PHC, 1992, WHO, Geneva.Health
5. Charles Collins, Management and Organization of Developing Health Systems,
1994, USA.
6. WHO, Public Health Papers, Health Care Facility Projects in Developing Areas,
1984, Geneva.
7. Challi Jira, Health Planning, 2003, Jimma University.
8. Challi, Amsalu, Getnet, Health Service Management, 2003.
9. Challi Jira (2003): Health Planning for Health Science students Lecture Note
series –Jimma University –Faculty of Public Health.
10. Mc Mahn R. Barton G. Piot M (1992). On Being In charge –A guide to
Management in Primary health Care, WHO Geneva.
11. FMOH-HSDP II 12. Theresa J .K .Drinka and Philip G. Clark Health care team
work,2000,U.S.A.
Health Service Management by: ustad Mohamed Hassan
References:
1. Marie-Therese Fewerstein, Partners in Evaluation, 1986, London.
2. James F. Mckenzie, Jan L. Smelitzer, Planning, Implementing and Evaluating
Health Promotion Program, third edition, 2001, USA.
3. Stephen M. Shortell, Arnold D. Kaluzny, Essentials of Health Care Management,
1997, USA.
4. Rosemary Mcmahon and others, On Being In Charge, A Guide to Management
in PHC, 1992, WHO, Geneva.Health
5. Charles Collins, Management and Organization of Developing Health Systems,
1994, USA.
6. WHO, Public Health Papers, Health Care Facility Projects in Developing Areas,
1984, Geneva.
7. Challi Jira, Health Planning, 2003, Jimma University.
8. Challi, Amsalu, Getnet, Health Service Management, 2003.
9. Challi Jira (2003): Health Planning for Health Science students Lecture Note
series –Jimma University –Faculty of Public Health.
10. Mc Mahn R. Barton G. Piot M (1992). On Being In charge –A guide to
Management in Primary health Care, WHO Geneva.
11. FMOH-HSDP II 12. Theresa J .K .Drinka and Philip G. Clark Health care team
work,2000,U.S.A.
Tags
Download
Download Slideshow Get the original presentation fileQuick Actions
Statistics
- Views 13,817
- Slides 95
- Favorites 34
- Age 2920 days
Related Slideshows
36
Clinical approach Dyspnoea A simple and practical approach.pptx
ShajahanPS
30 views
238
Cancer Awareness therapy for public by Dr Kanhu Charan Patro
kanhucpatro
30 views
41
Prof Satyadas Memorial oration Kozhikode.pptx
ShajahanPS
26 views
26
Viral Conjunctivitis and it;s managment.pptx
ZaidAzhar
38 views
30
Essential Thrombocythemia 15 Years of Experience at the Hematology Department, Algies, Algeria.pdf
sbelakehal
34 views
10
Hypertension sign symptoms cmdt style with regime
androiddabest
35 views