With Informed Consent.... ……It’s Not About the Form ….It’s more than a signature on a piece of paper!
What is Informed Consent ? The process of communication between a patient and physician that results in the patient’s authorization of agreement to undergo a specific medical intervention (American Medical Association) Failure to obtain informed consent renders any physician liable for negligence or battery and constitutes medical malpractice.
Why Do We Need Informed Consent? The Short Answer: It’s the ethical thing to do It’s a safety and quality of care issue It’s the law Regulatory Requirement Hospital Policy
Why Do We Need Informed Consent? The Slightly Longer Answer: Greater patient safety and satisfaction Attainment of higher ethical standards and organizational morale Closer adherence to legal requirements and reduced risk of litigation Increased levels of institutional quality (e.g. compliance with accreditation standards) Potential time and money savings related to reduced litigation
Who is Responsible for Informed Consent? The clinician has core responsibility…but…a team approach is required with contributions from: Entire clinical staff (clinician, nurse, technologist) Administrative and clinical leadership Legal counsel
When is Informed Consent Required? In most institutions, for: Surgery Anesthesia Other invasive or complex medical or radiologic procedures
What is considered an invasive procedure? Any penetration of the skin, use of radiation for treatment, or comparable invasive procedure involving interference with the body tissues. Also can be any other procedure that entails substantial risk to the patient. Angiographic procedures Anything with scalpels, needles Injection of diagnostic substances into body cavities, internal organs, etc.
What’s Needed for Informed Consent? The diagnosis, if known The nature and purpose of a proposed treatment or procedure The risk and benefits of proposed treatment or procedures Alternatives (regardless of costs or extent covered by insurance) The risk and benefits of alternatives The risks and benefits of not receiving treatments or undergoing procedures
Who Can Consent? Patient, if adult and competent Impaired due to injury, ETOH or medications of drugs Healthcare Power of Attorney or legal guardian In the absence of a legally authorized representative, a “statutory surrogate” may give consent.
Statutory Surrogates Statutory Surrogates Include, in order of priority, the following: 1. Patient's spouse, unless legally separated. 2. Adult child of the patient. If more than one child, consent of a majority who are reasonably available 3. Parent of the patient. 4. If the patient is unmarried, the patient's domestic partner if no other person has assumed any financial responsibility for the patient. 5. Brother or sister of patient. 6. A close friend of patient who is familiar with the patient's health care views and desires and is willing to become involved in the patient's healthcare and to act in the patient's best interest.
The sad part is that, many studies reveal that physicians often fail to observe the practice and the spirit of informed consent.
Why Do We Need to Improve Informed Consents? Even after signing a consent form, many patients still do not understand basic information about the risks and benefits of their proposed treatment options.
What are the Potential Consequences of Lack of True Informed Consent Increased chance of a patient safety incident or medical error Increased chance for malpractice cases Violation of professional and ethical obligations to clinicians to communicate clearly
What Can We Do to Improve Our Informed Consent? Simplify our language Allow time for questions Make sure the patient understands Plan for language assistance in advance of appointment Train support staff
Use of Interpreter Information must be verbally provided to patient in their native language; consent must be written in English. If patient/family refuses hospital interpreter and chooses to use a friend or family member; if must be noted in the medical record. If translation services are used the interpreter should sign as a “witness” and specify their name, title, date and time.
Signing and Witnessing the Consent The patient (or the patient’s health care decision maker) should sign the consent along with two persons should witness the patient’s signature. These witnesses are attesting to the fact that the patient signed the form only and need not witness the full consent discussion between the patien and the physician.
Misc. The identify and professional status of individuals responsible for authorizing and performing procedures or treatments must be on consent. Discussion…..