MANAGEMENT OF THE MANGLED UPPER EXTREMITY A CRITICAL ANALYSIS REVIEW HAND DIVISION PLASTIC RECONSTRUCTIVE AND AESTHETIC SURGERY STUDY PROGRAM UDAYANA UNIVERSITY/ PROF DR I.G.N.G NGOERAH HOSPITAL JOURNAL READING
Combined injury involving 3 of the 4 tissues: vascular, nervous, soft tissue and bone Causes: falls from a height, MV collisions , industrial machinery, firearms, / explosions). Past 20 years, 30 scientific mangled upper extremity articles decision for amputation. Despite advance modern prosthetic technology salvage hand’s prehensile & sensory function improve QoL outperform prosthesis. This review overview of limb salvage for mangled upper extremity & critical analysis review of key evidence & controversies.
INITIAL RESUSCITATION & VASCULAR INJURY Principle: “No single limb is worth a person’s life”. First priority ABC (ATLS). C.ABC (C=catastrophic hemorrhage) Battlefield ATLS (BATLS) mangled upper extremity is top priority
INITIAL RESUSCITATION AND VASCULAR INJURY Bleeding control direct pressure/ pressure dressing. Tourniquets military combat & mass-casualty events (multiple sites, austere environment) appropriate use & careful timing (avoid nerve injury & ischemic complications) Large retrospective studies safe prehospital tourniquet, low rate tourniquet-associated complications. Overtightening is avoided & 2 hours ischemia times. Clamping of vessels should be avoided (poor visibility & damage adjacent nerves)
INITIAL RESUSCITATION AND VASCULAR INJURY Warm ischemia time > 4 - 6 hours ↑ infection & muscle death. ↑ time without reversal of vascular compromise compartment syndrome, progressive neurological impairment, & limb loss. Acute vascular compromise of the limb quick operative exploration & intervention Revascularization direct repair, vascular reconstruction/ temporary shunt. Ischemic limbs >4 hours prophylactic fasciotomies
INFECTION PREVENTION AND DEBRIDEMENT mangled limb irrigated, dressed, realigned, & splinted. Surgical debridement < 24 hours (well-perfused limb). “window of 8 hours” no consistent superiority in human /animal studies. Weber et al. (prospective cohort, 736 patients) same infection rate when initial debridement happened >8 hours after injury : 24 hours.
Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma (EAST) Gram(+) systemic ASAP after injury + Gram(-) for Gustilo Anderson type-III open injuries. Piperacillin & tazobactam similar ↓ infection , alternative for patients with allergies / contraindications to cefazolin plus gentamicin. Animal study ↑ infection rates if antibiotics were delayed >2 hours. Retrospective clinical study (137 patients OF ) ↑ infection rates if >1 h. INFECTION PREVENTION & DEBRIDEMENT
Tourniquet facilitate visualization of key structures & avoid iatrogenic injury Nonviable, nonfunctional, or grossly contaminated tissues should all be removed. Fingers with multilevel & multisystem injuries require amputation. Muscle viability may be tested via contractility. Excisional debridement should include removal of devitalized bone Preserve nerves & vessels INFECTION PREVENTION AND DEBRIDEMENT
After a satisfactory initial debridement, antibiotics may be discontinued Dellinger et al. ( double-blind RCT 248 OF patients) 24 hours / 5 days of antibiotics no significant difference in infection rates. (heterogeneity makes generalizations difficult). INFECTION PREVENTION AND DEBRIDEMENT
ACUTE AMPUTATION COMPARED WITH SALVAGE “the arm is progressively more valuable from shoulder to fingers; the leg, on the contrary, is progressively of less significance.” (Malt & McKhann - first successful arm replant) Often , salvage of a portion of the hand & upper extremity will be superior functionally to a prosthetic replacement alone.
The Mangled Extremity Severity Score (MESS )-(Johansen-1990) Used retrospective review to define 4 factors (skeletal & soft-tissue injury, ischemia, shock, & age). ≥7 amputation generalized to the upper limb. ACUTE AMPUTATION COMPARED WITH SALVAGE
Management individualized. Non salvageable injuries (bones , nerves, & vessels over a large zone of injury), unstable for prolonged procedures amputation. Decide salvage establish adequate vascularity, remove devitalized tissue & perform skeletal stabilization. ACUTE AMPUTATION COMPARED WITH SALVAGE
SKELETAL STABILIZATION If initial definitive fixation infeasible external fixation. External fixation 50 % nonunion , used as a bridge to internal fixation. External fixation for large osseous defect of the forearm When severe comminution of distal part of the radius is present, dorsal spanning plate fixation outcomes = non-spanning
Grossly contaminated OF should avoid immediate fixation was refuted by multiple studies; Wei et al. definitive fixation at the initial operation, did not ↑ risk of deep infection (adequate debridement ). Early fixation allows immediate reconstruction & use of nonreconstructible elements. (Tissue is scavenged from parts that will be discarded). Avoid grossly exposed implants prevent colonization. When soft tissues are unable to be primarily closed over the implant NPWT SKELETAL STABILIZATION
SOFT-TISSUE COVERAGE Soft-tissue coverage major obstacle in the management of the mangled upper extremity NPWT RCT in pigs after 4 days NPWT ↓ bacterial counts 2 weeks RCT in 54 patients NPWT ↓ deep infection in OF (28 % - 5.4 % ( p=0.024)) Extended time until definitive closure > 7 days ↓ benefit therapy. NPWT does not change surface area requiring soft-tissue coverage, but ↓ tissue edema, ↑blood supply, ↑formation of granulation tissue
Gustilo et al. leaving wound open 5-7 days, with serial debridements . Lister&Scheker emergency free flaps within 24 hours of injury, (29 of 31 survive) Hou et al. 32 patients delay in coverage of > 7 days ↑infection rates Wei et al. 80 patients type-IIIA & IIIB tibial fr no significant difference Godina ↓ complications with early flap coverage Coverage between 6 & 21 days is the ideal timing Derderian et al. (133 retrospective patients) ↑failure flap coverage within 6 days (9% : 3 %; p<0.05 ) & ↑infection ( p<0.05). Most authors suggested coverage 3 & 14 days after the injury; SOFT-TISSUE COVERAGE
No bone / tendon is exposed & soft tissue bed is amenable for a skin graft. F lap reconstruction cover exposed implant, tendon, &/ nerve. Local muscle flaps, ( brachioradialis / flexor carpi ulnaris ) cover small defects, & local / regional perforator flaps avoid sacrifice of a major artery in context of compromised vascularity of a mangled upper extremity. Local tissue not available pedicled flaps from trunk require no microsurgical techniques & can cover defects up to 30 x 15 cm. However, period of immobilization between flap inset & division can mean delay in therapies. Free flaps, technically more demanding, offer advantage of being a single stage. Flap options Patient preferences, body habitus, & other injuries, surgeon’s experience & comfort SOFT-TISSUE COVERAGE
RECONSTRUCTION OF NERVE, TENDON, AND BONE Nerve & tendon reconstruction is determined by the ability to achieve tension-free nerve coaptation &/ direct tendon repair at the time of the initial operation. Free innervated gracilis finger flexion / extension when insufficient donor muscles for tendon transfer, bipolar latissimus flap may be used to restore elbow flexion. Finger pollicization / toe transfers r ecreate a thumb. Bilateral upper-extremity amputations hand transplantation
REHABILITATION AND PSYCHOLOGICAL SUPPORT Despite best salvage & reconstructive efforts, some patients will require amputation Maintaining passive ROM throughout reconstructive process ensures nerve / tendon transfers have best chance of success. Early active ROM should be initiated where possible to prevent tendon adhesions. PTSD & depression may require psychiatrist evaluation, CBT, focused rehabilitation & group therapy
CONCLUSIONS Highly individualized approach. Initial management, debridement, & provisional fixation have important impact on the final reconstruction. Prehospital tourniquets is safe as long as early deflation & control of hemorrhage surgically / with pressure dressings occur within 2 hours. Antibiotics initiation & timely surgical debridement within 24 hours. Strong evidence supporting lavage fluids without additives & no evidence high-pressure / pulsatile lavage improves outcomes. If debridement is adequate, early fixation of fractures is safe. Early soft-tissue coverage (24 hours & 1 month) Secondary reconstruction should be tailored to the patient’s injury and needs.