Practical criticism
‘Applied Criticism’
A way of discussing particular works of literature
It does not give importance to
the biographies of authors,
the social context of literature,
literary history and
the psychological or moral effects of literature on the
reader.
Practical Criticism -- the detailed analysis of the individual
work itself.
It is held that each work has the “organic unity” of overall
structure and verbal meanings.
Words, images, and symbols in the work are organized
around a central and humanly significant theme.
Close Reading
“Close reading” of single texts -- the detailed
and subtle analysis of the complex
interrelations and multiple meanings of the
components within a work.
Analysis of the meanings and interactions
of words, figures of speech, and symbols
I.A. Richards’ Practical Criticism (1929)
William Empson’s Seven Types of Ambiguity
(1930)
The Process
Practical criticism is an attempt to analyze
and explain the effects of a literary work
such as a poem, a play or a novel by
reference to its
theme
subject
organization
techniques
style
The question “What is the poem about?”
leads us to the content or subject matter of
the poem
The question “How is the poem organized?”
makes us discuss the form of the poem.
Theme
A general concept or doctrine used in a poem.
The theme of Milton’s Paradise Lost is: “assert
Eternal Providence,/And justify the ways of God
to men.”
“Carpe Diem”, a Latin phrase which means “seize
the day” --life is short and time is fleeting -- an
appeal to the beloved to make the most of
present pleasures.
Robert Herrick’s “To the Virgins to Make Much of
Time” (“Gather ye rosebuds, while ye may”)
Edmund Waller’s “Go, Lovely Rose.”
Andrew Marvell’s “To His Coy Mistress.”
Imagery
All the objects and qualities of sense
perception
visual (sight)
auditory (hearing)
tactile (touch)
thermal (heat and cold)
olfactory (smell)
gustatory (taste)
kinesthetic (sensations of movement)
A Poem
She dwelt among the untrodden ways
Beside the springs of Dove,
A Maid whom there were none to praise
And very few to love:
A violet by a mossy stone
Half hidden from the eye!
Fair as a star, when only one
Is shining in the sky.
She lived unknown, and few could know
When Lucy ceased to be;
But she is in her grave, and oh,
The difference to me!
Practical Criticism
The second stanza of the poem includes such visible objects
as “violet”, “stone”, “star”, and “sky”.
Lucy’s natural charm, like that of the violet, was derived from
her modesty. She, too, was “half-hidden from the eye,”
obscure and unnoticed.
Lucy is then compared to the star. Lucy was completely
obscure to the world as the modest flower in the shadow of
the mossy stone. However, to the eye of her lover she was
the only star in his heaven.
In this poem, the imagery is the poem.
The imagery is not something “additional”—merely
decorative.
The poem renders the experience of love dramatically in
concrete terms.
Figurative Language
The language of a poem is often figurative.
It is a departure from the standard meaning of
words, or the standard order of words, in order
to achieve some special meaning or effect.
“Figures of Thought” or Tropes enable the poet
to achieve a departure in the meaning of
words.
“Figures of Speech” or Schemes help him
achieve a departure in the syntactical order or
pattern of the words.
“Figures of Thought” or
Tropes
Simile: a comparison between two different things
using the word “like” or “as”
Metaphor: a word or expression applied to a
distinctly different kind of thing or action
Metonymy: one thing applied to another with which
it is closely associated
Synecdoche: a part of something is used to signify
the whole
Personification: an inanimate object or an abstract
concept is spoken of as though it were endowed
with life or with human attributes or feelings
Kenning: a descriptive phrase in place of the
ordinary name for something
Conceit: a striking parallel between two very
dissimilar things or situations
Hyperbole: bold overstatement, or the
extravagant exaggeration of fact or of
possibility
Irony: a statement in which the meaning that a
speaker implies differs sharply from the
meaning that is directly expressed
Paradox: a statement which seems on its face
to be absurd yet turns out to make good sense
Periphrasis: circumlocution
Pun: a play on words that are either identical
in sound or very similar in sound, but are very
diverse in meaning
Understatement: something represented as
much less in magnitude or importance than it
really is
Figures of Speech or
Schemes
Apostrophe: a direct or explicit address either
to an absent person or to an abstract or
nonhuman entity
Invocation: a direct or explicit address to a
god or muse or some other being to assist the
poet in his composition
Rhetorical Question: a question which is not
asked in order to request information or to
invite a reply, but to function as a forceful
alternative to the assertion
Alliteration: the repetition of consonants at
the beginning either of a word or of a
stressed syllable within a word
Consonance: the repetition of a sequence
of two or more consonants, but with a
change in the intervening vowel
Assonance: the repetition of identical or
similar vowel sounds—especially in stressed
syllables-in a sequence of nearby words
Parallelism: a similar order and structure in the
syntax
Rhyme: the repetition of the stressed vowel and of
all the speech sounds following that vowel
End rhymes: such repetition at the end of a verse line
Internal rhymes: such repetition within a verse-line
Rhythm: stressed or unstressed syllables produce
a recognizable though variable pattern in the beat
of the stresses in the stream of sound.