Law and Social Change
By
Prof.(Dr) Preeti Misra,
Head, Dept of Human Rights,
School of Legal Studies, Babasaheb Bhimrao
Ambedkar University, Lucknow,
E-Mail: [email protected]
Meaning of Social Change
H.T.Majumdar-
“Socialchangemaybedefined'asanewfashionor
mode,eithermodifyingorreplacingtheold,inthelife
ofapeople-orintheoperationofasociety.”(A
GrammarofSociology).
MaclverandPage-
"Socialchangereferstoaprocessresponsiveto
manytypesofchanges.Changesinman-made
conditionsoflife,tochangesintheattitude,and
beliefsofmen,andtochangesthatgobeyondthe
humancontroltothebiologicalandphysicalnatureof
things".(Society:Anintroductory,Analysis).
FEATURES AND DIMENSIONS OF SOCIAL
CHANGE
•Itisclearfromtheforegoingdiscussionsthatsocial
changeIsaveryvast,complicatedandmultifaceted
processhavinginnumerablecausesaswellas
consequences.
•Soanyattempttospecifyitsfeaturesanddimensions
undersomeheadingsmustbefutile.
•Since,what-everschemewegive,itwillbesubjectto
errorslikeomissionof-someelements,orunnecessary
inclusionofsomewhichotherwisecanbeexcludedor
repetitionofsomeelements.
•However,forthesakeofconvenience,onemay
beginasfollows:-
Social change is asocial
•“SocialChangearenotinanysenseaproductofthe
societyperseoraconsequenceofsomeuniversalor
unvaryinglawofsociallife".
•Itissomethingdifferentfromthechangesthattakeplace
inindividualorganisms.Organicchangesinvariablytake
placeinallorganismasanessentiallawandfollowsa
particularpatternof'birth,growth,maturityanddeaths.
•Societylikeanorganismneverdieswhichbringsabouta
completeendtoit.Newcivilizationandsocietiesget
ripenedinthewombofoldsocietiesandthereby
retainingsomeofitselements,maybeinatransformed
form.
•Thus,thesocialchangeisdifferentfromindividual
change-Itscausesandconsequencesarealwayssocial
whichmakeitasocial.
Asocial is not sociable, withdrawn, avoiding the society of
others. Antisocial is unable or unwilling to socialise in a
normal or friendly way, antagonistic, hostile, consistently
ignoring/upsetting the rights of others.
•Asocial behaviour is a personal refusal to interact with
other people. It is also used in terms (with medical
professionals) for those with mental illness (such as
myself) who choose not to be social with others because
of their shame or guilt (examples) associated with their
illness.
Social change is a Process of synchronization
•Socialchangemaybeviewedasaprocessofsynchronization.Any
changeinasystemcomesasaforeignandunwantedagentsince
theverynatureofsocietyistopersistitself,Ofcourse,changedoes
notalwaysleadtodestructionbutitdisturbsthe"establishedand
organizationallypreferredstructuresandprocessoflife".
•Theoldtrends,'patterns,ordersofsociallifecollidewithnewly
emergingones,creatingrevisionsandstrain'sinsociallife.Sucha
phenomenoncontinuesforatransitoryperiod.
•Graduallynewerelementsgetfusedintotheoldordereitherby
replacementorbymodificationorbytransformation,ofolderones.
Andtheprocessofchangebecomesasynchronizationofoldand
newthathelpthesocialstructuretomaintainitself.
•For,ifastructuredoesnotadaptitselftothenewcircumstances
andrigidlytriestomaintainthesamestructurefortoolong,itmay
altogetherlooseitsintegrityandidentityasasystem.
Speed and Rate of change is not uniform
•Socialchangeoccursatdifferentrateandspeedatdifferent
pointsoftime.Inotherwords,therateandspeedofsocial
changeisnotuniformandisverymuchconditionedbytime.
•Therateandspeedofchangeinmoderntimeisfarrapidthan
thatoftheancienttime.Suchavariationtakesplace-
becauseofanumberofinterrelatedcauses.
•Thisprocessofdiffusionsismoreeasierandfasterinmodern
timesthanthatofearliertimes,becauseofbetteravailability
ofmassmediaandworkofchange-agentsatdifferentlevels.
•Thisagainaddstothephenomenalgrowthofinnovationsand
discoveries,Further,thedemandforinnovation,mentalability
forinnovation,readinessforchangeetc.alsocontributes
towardsfasterrateofchange.
•Thesefactorsintheirturn,aretheproductsofrapidcultural
assimilationwithinventions,increasinglevelofconsciousness
andawarenessetc.
Social change is cumulative and follows a
chain-reaction pattern
•Theconditionsforaneworderispreparedwithintheoldorder
itself.Forexample,industrializationcameupasaresultof
newmodesofthinkingandnewinnovationsanddiscoveries.
•Thisdestroyedoratleastweakenedthedomesticsystemof
productione.g.cottageindustries,smallfarmsetc.
•Theestablishmentoflarge-scaleindustriesinparticular
centresbroughtwomenoutfromhometofactory.She
became-economicallyindependentandgraduallytriedtobe
freefromthebondageandcontrolofman.
•Theprocessdidnotendthere.This.hadafurtherimpacton
familylife.Centralisationofindustriesatsomepockets
resultedinurbanisation,heavyrural-urbanmigrationwhich
againnecessitated,newlawsandnormsforregulationof
urbanlife.Inthisway,thechainwentontillitaffectedthe
wholesociallife.
Social Transformation
•SocialTransformationreferstoanorchestrated,
systemic(Universal,total)andrevolutionary
overhauloftheglobalchurch,includingthe
“transformation”ofcities,societies,cultures,
marketplaces,andmore.
•Can be defined as “transformation of consciousness,” “a
newseeing,” “conscious evolution,” and a “paradigm
change.”
•metamorphosis: i.e., a complete change, such as a
caterpillar turning into a butterfly.
Legislation as a Factor Of Social Change
•Law a means of social control.
•In Ancient India-Two Mechanisms of Social
conformity are Dharma & Achara (custom)
•Dharma has four sources--Vedas, Shruti, Smiriti,
sadachara
•“Immemorial custom is transcendent law”—
Manu
•Many customs recognized in codified personal
laws-pluralistic, tolerant society-freedom to each
group to develop in its own way
Legalnormsmustbebroughtinconformitywith
socialnormssothatmajoritygroupmayadoptnew
socialvalues.
•As an instrument of social change, law involves
two interrelated processes.
•Institutionalizationofnewpatternofbehaviour
manifestingnewsocialvaluesbynew
enactments.Anydevianceispunishable.
•Mereinstitutionalizationisnotsufficient,asit
maybeletteroflawwithoutanysocialforce.
•Forlawtobecomeactivesocialforce,there
mustbeinternalizationofnewpatternof
behaviourintheindividual.
Models of Social Development
•(i)CapitalistModel
• Theethosofthismodelisfreedomtoentrepreneur
(ofopeningindustryorengagingintrade),toworker(of
sellinglabour),totrader(ofbuyingandsellinggoods),
andtoindividual(ofbuyingandconsuming).However,it
doesnotacceptequalityasvalue.Itregards
inequalitiesasdirectlyrelatedtotheindolenceof
individual.
•(ii)SocialistModel
• Thismodelisnotinfavourofdemocratization.It
wantsstatedominatedbyworkers.Thesocialistmodel
mayeitherbetheRussianmodelortheChinesemodel.
TheRussianmodelisheavyindustry-orientedurban
basedmodelwhiletheChinesemodelisindustry-
orientedruralbasedmodel.
Alternate Model of Development Adopted in
India
•Indianmodelofsocialdevelopment,basedonsocialist
ideologyandcalled'democraticcollectivism,'is
differentfromtheabove-mentionedmodels.Itisnot
basedonconflictbutonconsensus.Itisdemocratization
throughadjustment.
•Unlikethecapitalistmodel,itisnotcallousto,common
manandunliketheRussianandChinesemodels,itis
notbasedonsuppressionofindividuals.Itaimsat
creatinga'socialistpatternofsociety'.
•ItprotectstheinterestsofbothindividualandtheState.it
aimsatdistributivejusticepopularparticipation,and
socialintegration.Itdoesnotaimatabolitionofprivate
propertybutfocusesonthepublicownershipofthebasic
andmajorindustries.SocialisminIndiacertainlylacks
theideologicalcentralityithasinChina.
Alternate Model of Development Adopted in
India
•Atthetimeofindependence,thereweretwoschools
withintherulingCongressparty-onewhichsupported
socialismandotherwhichopposedit.Yetsocialismwas
adoptedasadevelopmentmodelforthefutureandas
thebasicstrategyfortherestructuringofruralsociety
andforexpandingstatecontrolofthemeansofindustrial
production.
•Thegovernment'sapproachtoprivateenterpriseandto
theroleofthestateinindustrialdevelopmentwas
indicatedinIndustriesDevelopmentandRegulationAct
whichprovidedthatnonewindustrialunitorsubstantial
expansionofexistingplantscouldbemadewithouta
licensefromtheCentralGovernment.Thisrulewas,
however,liberalizedintheeconomicpolicyadoptedby
thegovernmentin1992.
Goals of Social Change in India
•Atthetimeofpoliticalindependenceofthecountry,many
intellectualsfeltthatIndiahadfailedtomodernizeitselfnot
becauseitlackedthewherewithaltodevelop.But,ithadbeen
thevictimofcapitalistimperialism.
•Thesocio-culturaltransformationwehadinitiateddecadesago
andtheonewhichwewanttoplanforthecomingdecadesaims
atstructuralchangeswhichcouldmeettheemergingneedsand
aspirationsofthepeople.
•Thecollectivegoalswehadplannedtoachieveintheveryfirst
decadeoftherepublicweresocial,economic,politicaland
cultural.
•Thesocialgoalswere:equality,justice,freedom,rationality,and
individualism.Theeconomicgoalsinclude:distributivejustice
andeconomicrationalisminplaceofeconomictheology.The
politicalgoalswere:establishingapoliticalsystemwherethe
rulerisaccountabletotheruled,decentralizationofpolitical
power,andassociatingmoreandmorepeoplewiththedecision-
makingprocesses.Ourculturalgoalwasachangefromthe
sacredtothesecularideology.
Goals of Social Change in India
•Tocreateastrongeststate.Thiswasnecessary
becausehistorically,politicalauthorityinIndiahadbeen
fragmented.Afterindependence,itwasfearedthatthe
religious,linguistic,caste,tribal,class,etc.forcesmay
furtherattempttofragmentauthority.
•Strongfederalgovernmentwithsomeauthoritytostate
governmentsalonewouldthwartattemptsofsuch
fragmentation.
•Tomodernizetheeconomy.Thiswasnecessaryfor
raisingthelowpercapitaincome,formakingthecountry
self-reliant,andforhavinganindigenouscapitalgoods
sectorwhichisnotdependentonforeignprivatecapital.
Goals of Social Change in India
•Tocreateasocialistpatternofsociety.Thiswas
necessarytorestrictbutnoteliminatetheroleofprivate
capitalistsandemphasizepublicownershipofmajor
industries.
•Toreduceinequalitiesamongcastes,regions,and
classes.
•Topreservefundamentalhumanrights,suchasright
offreespeech,rightoffreereligiousexpression,rightof
politicalparticipation,andsoforth.
•Toestablishasocietywhereindividualswouldbe
motivatedbyspiritofselflessness,sacrifice,co-operation
andidealism.
Hindrances to Social Change
•CasteSystem
•Illiteracy,IgnoranceandFear
•TheValues
•ThePowerElite
•PopulationExplosion