Chapter 4 construction law for Construction Or Cotm students

Construction law for madda walabu university. Instructer Andualem endris.
Posted by Okasha Aman

1. Dispute and Dispute Resolution
Mechanisms
Mada WalabuMada Walabu
UniversityUniversity
Construction Law
CoTM 4241
Chapter 4
College of Engineering
Construction Technology and Management Department
Instructor: Andualem Endris (M.Sc)
E-mail: [email protected]

2. What is Dispute?
CoTM 4241 2August 22, 2024

3. Disputes
•Dispute is a disagreement between parties
•Construction projects are generally complex,
for this reason, disputes are always present
•Involves many parties.
•When a project ends up in a dispute, the project
will fail to meet its original goals and
expectation.
CoTM 4241 3August 22, 2024

4. Disputes
•Clients will suffer from high legal fees, delayed
completion and occupation and general dissatisfaction.
•The contractor’s profits will diminish and to these will be
added additional legal fees.
•No winners under these circumstances
CoTM 4241 4August 22, 2024

5. Causes of Disputes
CoTM 4241 5August 22, 2024

6. Causes of Disputes
•May arise on a construction project for a number
of reasons:
Late or non-payment for works satisfactorily
completed when payment is due.
Inaccurate valuation of variations and works in
progress.
Delays in the supply of general construction
information
CoTM 4241 6August 22, 2024

7. Causes of Disputes …Cont’d
Late issue of instruction varying some sections of the
works, which disrupts the contractor’s progress and
program of works.
Shortcomings, omissions and errors in contract
documentation giving rise to ambiguities in contract
requirements.
Failure of contractor to construct the works diligently and
to program.
CoTM 4241 7August 22, 2024

8. Causes of Disputes …Cont’d
Increase in scope of work (changes, extras and errors)
without proper consideration for extension of production
time.
Acceleration to complete within original program without
proper agreement over the payment.
Poor workmanship and failure to use specified materials,
skilled operatives and recognized methods.
Failure to inspect works in progress regularly and
condemning only when works are completed.
CoTM 4241 8August 22, 2024

9. Causes of Disputes …Cont’d
•It can be deduced from the above list that the main areas
of construction disputes revolve around:
payments
contract documentation
Time and cost overruns
Construction information and site supervision
•Owing to their diverse status, the view points of the
project participants towards disputes areas vary.

CoTM 4241 9August 22, 2024

10. Alternative Dispute Resolution
Mechanisms (ADR)
CoTM 4241 10August 22, 2024

11. Dispute Resolution Mechanisms
•An introductory survey of the construction
industry’s commonly used dispute resolution
mechanisms.
•Negotiation
•Mediation
•Conciliation
•Dispute Review Boards
•Arbitration
•Litigation
11CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

12. Negotiation
•Dispute resolution between the parties involving
only the parties
•Informal
–Conversations, emails, texts, phone calls
•Formal
–Meetings, documentation, presentations
•Resolution
–Regardless of how you got there:
Put it in writing
12CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

13. Elevating the Negotiation
•Can’t settle at the jobsite level?
•Push the dispute “upstairs”
•Again, only the parties are involved
•May be multiple meetings
•Resolution must be written
13CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

14. Mediation
•Mediation: Bringing in a respected, neutral,
uninvolved person to help everyone reach a
mutually acceptable resolution
–The mediator DOES NOT decide
–Mediation may not resolve a dispute
•Key Points
–Voluntary
–The resolution is binding, but the process is not
–You set the rules
14CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

15. Mediation
•The Parties must agree to mediate
•The Parties must select a mediator
•The Contract may define mediation terms,
procedures, maybe even the mediator
•Select a mediator with whom you are
comfortable and who you believe will also be
credible with the other parties
•The mediator proposes several possible
solutions to the dispute.
15CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

16. Mediation – The Process
•Parties provide the Mediator with information to
understand the dispute
•The Mediator chooses to meet individually with the
parties, or to call all parties together in a “joint
session”
•After a sufficient exchange of information, the
Mediator breaks the parties apart and begins shuttle
diplomacy
•The Mediator works for you – make the Mediator
work, not just shuffle back and forth
16CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

17. Mediation – The Resolution
•Mediators DO NOT Decide
–The Parties decide
•The Mediator’s Proposal
–Not always offered
–May be requested
–NOT binding until all parties
accept
–The process is still voluntary
17CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

18. Conciliation
August 22, 2024 CoTM 4241 18
•Conciliation is a voluntary proceeding
•It requires that the parties be subject to a third
person (neutral or conciliator).
•The aim is to assist with legal or technical
aspects in the matter, in order to reach a
satisfactory arrangement.
•This practice is referred to as ‘reconciling’ the
parties in an attempt to find a common
agreement.

19. Dispute Review Boards
•A contractually defined process
•3 members – all are neutral:
–Contractor nominated, Owner nominated
–Those two appoint the 3
rd
neutral
•Typically defined in the contract
–But can be established any time the parties agree to
do so
•Regular site visits
•Conducts hearings
19CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

20. Dispute Review Board Hearings
•Frequently “no attorneys”
•Parties explain their case to the DRB
•Exhibits, Calculations, Presentations
•DRB hears and receives the information
20CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

21. Dispute Review Board Decisions
•Check your contract – terms vary
•Typically non-binding but admissible
•Probably the best independent evaluation
you’ll ever get for your problem
21CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

22. Arbitration
•Arbitration is the submission of a dispute to one or more
impartial persons for a final and binding decision, known
as an "award."
•Awards are made in writing and are generally final and
binding on the parties in the case.
•Many times contract defined
•Always an option if all parties agree.
•Variety of associations provide, arbitration services.
22CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

23. Arbitrator Selection
•Big Benefit: You “choose” your Judge
•Must be confirmed independent and unrelated
•Look for folks who will understand your situation,
but without bringing too much bias and pre-
conceived resolutions
•Consider the expediency of a single arbitrator
versus the combined wisdom of a three-party
panel
23CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

24. The Hearings
•NO Ex Parte communications
•Arbitrator sets schedule
•Proceedings are formalized through rules
•Evidence is presented through sworn testimony
•Arbitrator may question the witnesses and the
attorneys
•Arbitrator sets, with party input, closing briefs,
submission timelines, and form of decision
24CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

25. The Decision
•The Final Decision is Final
•There are very few accepted ways to overturn a
Decision:
–The Arbitrator failed to hear evidence
–The Arbitrator was on the take, misbehavior
–The Arbitrator exceeded the powers granted to the
Arbitrator
•Other than winning an appeal using one or more of
those conditions – you are stuck with the Decision.
25CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

26. Litigation
•May be a Federal or State Agency Court
–For example: Board of Contract Appeals,
•In a courtroom, you get to choose
–Judge: “Bench Trial”
•Yesterday, the Judge sentenced a rapist to life, today, the Judge
is hearing you argue about money and time
–Jury: Your “Peers”
•Check that jury pool – do any of them really understand the
nuances of a construction project?
26CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

27. Litigation
•Getting There
–Many times contract defined
–Any party can initiate: “I’m gonna sue you!”
•Adjudicator Selection
–The Judge is assigned
–You may be able to choose a jury
•Hearings
–Strict rules of evidence
–The Court’s schedule – your schedule just doesn’t matter.
27CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

28. Litigation - Process
•Tedious
•Discovery – produce Everything
•Motions, Legal Positioning
•Pre-Trial Hearings
•Finally, the Hearing itself
28CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

29. Litigation - Frustration
•Cancel your vacation, you’re scheduled to be in
Court
•But the Court will delay, as you are “trailing”
•When you do arrive, plan on lots of vacant times
•Remember the money you are paying your team
to be there.
29CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

30. Litigation – The Decision
•Likely one party won’t like the Decision
•That party will then file for appeal
–Frequently used to encourage the “winner” to accept
an immediate but smaller resolution
•After years in Trial Court, now years of Appeals
–And you may be sent back for a new trial
30CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

31. Litigation Closure
I’m just so glad,
I won…
31CoTM 4241August 22, 2024

32. Assignment 2
August 22, 2024 CoTM 4241 32
•Briefly discuss the difference between
‘Conciliation’ and ‘Mediation’
•Differentiate between ‘Judge, and
‘Jury’.
Submission Date: January 09, 2020

33. 33CoTM 4241August 22, 2024
Thank You!Thank You!