21
to 3% of the gas escapes destruction after its use. Furthermore, the report failed to compare
NF3's effects with what it replaced, perfluorocarbon, another powerful greenhouse gas, of
which anywhere from 30% to 70% escapes to the atmosphere in typical use.
Comparison of LCD
• Packaging
In a CRT the electron beam is produced by heating a metal filament, which "boils"
electrons off its surface. The electrons are then accelerated and focused in an electron gun,
and aimed at the proper location on the screen using electromagnets. The majority of the
power budget of a CRT goes into heating the filament, which is why the back of a CRT-
based television is hot. Since the electrons are easily deflected by gas molecules, the entire
tube has to be held in vacuum. The atmospheric force on the front face of the tube grows
with the area, which requires ever-thicker glass. This limits practical CRTs to sizes around
30 inches; displays up to 40 inches were produced but weighed several hundred pounds,
and televisions larger than this had to turn to other technologies like rear-projection. The
lack of vacuum in an LCD television is one of its advantages; there is a small amount of
vacuum in sets using CCFL backlights, but this is arranged in cylinders which are naturally
stronger than large flat plates. Removing the need for heavy glass faces allows LCDs to be
much lighter than other technologies. For instance, the Sharp LC-42D65, a fairly typical
42- inch LCD television, weighs 55 lbs including a stand, while the late-model Sony KV-
40XBR800, a 40" 4:3 CRT weighs a massive 304 lbs without a stand, almost six times the
weight.
LCD panels, like other flat panel displays, are also much thinner than CRTs. Since the
CRT can only bend the electron beam through a critical angle while still maintaining focus,
the electron gun has to be located some distance from the front face of the television. In
early sets from the 1950s the angle was often as small as 35 degrees off-axis, but
improvements, especially computer assisted convergence, allowed that to be dramatically
improved and, late in their evolution, folded. Nevertheless, even the best CRTs are much
deeper than an LCD; the KV-40XBR800 is 26 inches deep, while the LC-42D65U is less
than 4 inches thick – its stand is much deeper than the screen in order to provide stability.
• Efficiency
LCDs are relatively inefficient in terms of power use per display size, because the vast
majority of light that is being produced at the back of the screen is blocked before it
reaches the viewer. To start with, the rear polarizer filters out over half of the original un-
polarized light. Examining the image above, you can see that a good portion of the screen
area is covered by the cell structure around the shutters, which removes another portion.
After that, each sub-pixel's color filter removes the majority of what is left to leave only
the desired color. Finally, to control the color and luminance of a pixel as a whole, the light
has to be further absorbed in the shutters. 3M suggests that, on average, only 8 to 10% of
the light being generated at the back of the set reaches the viewer. For these reasons the
backlighting system has to be extremely powerful. In spite of using highly efficient