Background History of Egalitarianism
▪Stoics who presented the first egalitarian framework.
▪The anti-egalitarian current of the Middle Ages struggled to
embedded Judaism and New Testament Christianity.
▪“The equality of all souls before God”constitutes.
▪Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, and Jean-Jacques
Rousseau –legitimate government authority is derived
from the voluntary contract of natural equals.
▪In Modern times natural or moral equality is given;
only inequality needs justification.
All humans are equal
Law of nature is
ordered
Capacity for virtue
derived
The Nature and Meaning of Egalitarianism
The cause of justice in the human
society is served if and only if
certain goods are provided in equal
or nearly equal measure to all.
5
welfare income resources
wealth opportunity
Definitions of the Concept:
•Gordon
•Landesman, 1983
•Narveson, 2002
•Arneson, 2013
•Hirose, 2014
Egalitarianism and the Intentionality of
Equality
▪Equality simply presumes universality or impartiality.
▪To follow Aristotle’s dictum, every likes must be
treated alike.
▪The principles of universality and impartiality.
▪Equal consideration presumes moral equality.
▪Four categories of difference that motivate social
inequalities:
Natural
endowment
Social
endowment
Brute bad
luck
Predictable
bad luck