Evidence Law I Tutorial Cases

.

1. KUMPULAN 4
Arahan:
1)Penetapanpelajarmengikuttopikuntukpembentangankeshendaklahditentukanoleh
pelajar-pelajardalamkumpulantutorialmasing-masingdengandipimpinolehketua
firma.
2)Pelajardilarangdaripadamemilihkesyangsamadenganpelajarlaindalamkumpulan
tutorialyangsama.Jikaada,markahtidakakandiberikan.Bagimengelakkan
pertindihandanmemudahkanurusanpemantauan,pelajarhendaklahmemaklumkan
kes yang dipilih kepada ketua firma.
3)Kesyangdipilihmestilahkesyangmerujukataumemetikprinsipyangdibangkitkan
dalamkes-kesutama(landmarkcases)ataukesyangmembangkitkanprinsipbaharu
yang berbeza daripada kes utama.
4)Kesyangdipilihharuslahdibacadengantelitidanpelajarperlumeringkaskan
keseluruhan kes dalam maksimum dua (2) halaman sahaja.
5)Ringkasan kes perlu merangkumi perkara yang berikut:
(a) Nama pelajar, nombor pendaftaran dan nombor firma
(b) Butiran kes seperti nama, citation dan mahkamah
(c) Fakta kes
(d) Isu undang-undang keterangan
(e) Penghujahan di pihak plaintif atau pendakwa raya
(f) Penghujahan di pihak defendan atau peguam bela
(g) Keputusan dan alasan penghakiman
6)Semuapelajarhendaklahmengemukakanringkasankesmasing-masingkepadaketua
firmaseminggusebelumsetiaptutorialbermula.Ketuafirmahendaklahmenghantar
ringkasankestersebutkepadaPenyelarasKursus,iaituDr.Ramalinggam
Rajamanickamseminggusebelumsetiaptutorialbermulamengikutkumpulantutorial
masing-masing.
7)Kaedahpembentanganialahkaedahbicaratuntas(pitching).Setiappelajardiberikan
masa selama 5 minit sahaja untuk membentangkan kes.




Tutorial 1 (Evidence Law)

2. Firma 7






No. Name Case Topic
1. Yap Han Xin (A166226)
Public Prosecutor v Manimaran a/l Mohana
Sundram & Anor [2018] MLJU 1035

Section 6
2 Komathi Raman
(A163611)
Aizuddin Syah Bin Ahmad v Public Prosecutor
[2018]5 MLJ 220
Illegally
obtained
evidence
3. Norainina Bt Shariful
Anuar (A162819)
Pendakwa Raya v Fong Kim Ho [2018]
MLRHU 152
Section 7
4. Nurul Rabiatul Nazurah
Binti Mohd Yusoff
(A163932)
SYAHIN HAFIY DANIAL BIN SOH AHMAD
LUPTEPI AMIN v MANSUR BIN YUNUS &
ANOR [2019] MLJU 914
Section 7
5. Nur Amira Binti Mohd
Saferi (A166230)
Mohd Ikhsan Ramli v Public Prosecutor ​ [2018]
MLRHU 1759

Section 6
6. Muhammad Akmal
Hakim bin Adnan
(A164306)
PUBLIC PROSECUTOR v JASENDRAN A/L
SANMUGAM​ ​[2020] MLJU 1193

Section 7

3. Firma 8








No. Nama Pelajar Kes Topik
1.
SHAHMUNI A/P
T.RAVICHANDRAN
(A163765)
DwiSupriyatnoMeovPublic
Prosecutor [2016] 1 LNS 242
Illegally Obtained
Evidence
2.
NORFATINAZERABINTI
NORHISHAM (A163070)
SitiNoorzianaJaafarvIntan
NadiaAbuBakar[2019]6
MLRH 91
Section 6
3,
WONG SHUN YONG
(A166833)
BadrulHishambinHashimv
PP [2020] 1 LNS 291
Section 6
4.
SITIAISYAHBINTIUMAR
BAKI (A166246)
Lingeswarana/lRamoov
PendakwaRaya[2017]MLJU
957
Section 7
5.
NUR AZILA BINTI
ZAHERMAN (A165600)
Pendakwa Raya lwn Ermiadi
(Warga Negara Indonesia)
[2019] MLJU 1744
Section 7
6.
AHMADSAIFULGHAZIBIN
MOHD LAZIM (A164478)
Mohd Khayry Ismail v. PP
[2014] 1 LNS 412 CA
Section 6

4. Tutorial 2 (Evidence Law)

Firma 7


No. Nama Pelajar Kes Topik
1. Yap Han Xin (A166226)
Muhammad Zakwan bin Zainuddin
v Public Prosecutor and other
appeals [2020] 8 MLJ 420

Section 9
2 Komathi Raman (A163611) Khoo Teng Chye v Cekal Berjasa
Sdn Bhd & Anor [2015] MLJU 992
Section 10
3. Norainina Bt Shariful Anuar
(A162819)
Low Wei Beng v Public Prosecutor
[2020] 1 LNS 213

Section 8
4. Nurul Rabiatul Nazurah Binti
Mohd Yusoff (A163932)
Public Prosecutor v Mohd Imran
Mohd Ramly & Anor [2017]
MLRHU 351
Section 8
5. Nur Amira Binti Mohd Saferi
(A166230)
Mohd Aizuddin bin Khamis v
Public Prosecutor [2020] 7 MLJ
281
Section 9
6. Muhammad Akmal Hakim bin
Adnan (A164306)
RAVEENDRAN A/L NAGAPAN .v
PACIFIC & ORIENT INSURANCE
CO. BERHAD [2019] 1 LNS 1428
Section 10

5. Firma 8





No. Nama Pelajar Kes Topik
1.
SHAHMUNI A/P
T.RAVICHANDRAN (A163765)
MUHAMMAD SAMRI BIN HASHIM v
PENDAKWA RAYA [2019] 1 LNS
1855
Section 8
2.
NORFATINAZERABINTI
NORHISHAM (A163070
Murugan a/l Krishnan lwn Pendakwa
Raya dan satu lagi rayuan
[2018] MLJU 1
Section 9
3,
WONG SHUN YONG
(A166833)
Eastern Cargo Express (M) Sdn
Bhd v Fabina Properties Sdn Bhd
[2016] 09 MLJ 290
Section 10
4.
SITIAISYAHBINTIUMAR
BAKI (A166246)
OkonkwoUgochukwuStephenv
Public Prosecutor [2019] MLJU 175
Section 8
5.
NURAZILABINTIZAHERMAN
(A165600)
Pendakwa Raya lwn Rames a/l
Bathumalai [2018] MLJU 2057
Section 9
6.
AHMADSAIFULGHAZIBIN
MOHD LAZIM (A164478)
AKAR JUANG SDN BHD v.
KOPERASI PEMBANGUNAN
HARTANAH PUTRAJAYA & ANOR
Section 10

6. Tutorial 3 (Evidence Law)

Firma 7



No. Nama Pelajar Kes Topik
1. Yap Han Xin (A166226) Public Prosecutor v Ahmad Firdaus bin
Zulkifli [2017] 3 MLJ 492
Similar Fact
Evidence
2 Komathi Raman (A163611) Public Prosecutor v Batumalai a/l
Krishnan [2018] MLJU 646
Similar Fact
Evidence
3. Norainina Bt Shariful Anuar
(A162819)
Datuk S Nallakaruppan & Ors v Datuk
Seri Anwar bin Ibrahim and other
appeals [2015] 4 MLJ 34
Character
Evidence
4. Nurul Rabiatul Nazurah
Binti Mohd Yusoff
(A163932)
Public Prosecutor v Mohd Aizuddin Bin
Khamis [2018] MLJU 403
Character
Evidence
5. Nur Amira Binti Mohd
Saferi (A166230)
Public Prosecutor v Yap Chai Yee
[2016] 1 MLJ 1

Similar Fact
Evidence
6. Muhammad Akmal Hakim
bin Adnan (A164306)
Lai Weng Keat lwn Pendakwa Raya,
[2014] 2 MLJ 607
Character
Evidence

7. Firma 8









No. Nama Pelajar Kes Topik
1.
SHAHMUNI A/P
T.RAVICHANDRAN (A163765)
​MUHAMMAD RIDZUA N BIN AB
MAJID v PENDAKWA RAYA


Similar Fact
Evidence
2.
NORFATINAZERABINTI
NORHISHAM (A163070
Pendakwa Raya v Mohamad Jamadi
Bin Nordin [2018] 1 LNS 1222
Bad
Character
Evidence
3,
WONG SHUN YONG
(A166833)
Thankgod Chukwujindu Enenmuo
v Public Posecutor [2018] 1 LNS
763

Character
Evidence
4.
SITIAISYAHBINTIUMAR
BAKI (A166246)
PublicProsecutorvAliasbinMd
Yusof [2019] MLJU 153
Similar Fact
Evidence
5.
NURAZILABINTIZAHERMAN
(A165600)
Muhammad Zakwan bin Zainuddin v
Public Prosecutor and other appeals
[2020] 8 MLJ 420

Character
Evidence
6.
AHMADSAIFULGHAZIBIN
MOHD LAZIM (A164478)
Pendakwa Raya v Wong Chee Beng
[2016] MLJU 1227
Similar Fact
Evidence

8. Tutorial 4 (Evidence Law)

Firma 7



No. Nama Pelajar Kes Topik
1. Yap Han Xin (A166226)
Public Prosecutor v Norashikin
bt Yusof & Anor [2019] 7 MLJ
277
Section 27
2 Komathi Raman (A163611) Public Prosecutor v Sahifful
Filzuad Bin Sa’don [2018] MLJU
230
Section 27
3. Norainina Bt Shariful Anuar
(A162819)
Teoh Keat Keong v Pendakwa
Raya [2017] MLJU 220

Section 27
4. Nurul Rabiatul Nazurah Binti
Mohd Yusoff (A163932)
ZALIMAN BIN ZAKARIA v
PUBLIC PROSECUTOR [2020]
MLJU 1409

Section 24
5. Nur Amira Binti Mohd Saferi
(A166230)
Kalaivanana/lSubramaniamv
PublicProsecutor[2017]10MLJ
413

Section 27
6. Muhammad Akmal Hakim bin
Adnan (A164306)
Ridzuan bin Taib v Pendakwa
Raya

9. Firma 8





No. Nama Pelajar Kes Topik
1.
SHAHMUNI A/P
T.RAVICHANDRAN (A163765)
PP v Kong Seng Long [2020] MLJU
1067
Section 27
2.
NORFATINAZERABINTI
NORHISHAM (A163070
Pendakwa Raya v Mohammad
Yushairi Bin Saidin [2018] MLJU 225
Section 27
3,
WONG SHUN YONG
(A166833)
Pendakwa Raya v Prabhagaran
Kegobalu [2017] LNS 1365

Seksyen 24
& 27
4.
SITIAISYAHBINTIUMAR
BAKI (A166246)
LiangWengHengvPublic
Prosecutor [2014] 2 MLJ 855
Seksyen 27
5.
NURAZILABINTIZAHERMAN
(A165600)
Pendakwa Raya lwn Atchuth Ram
Nair a/l Kumar & Yugendran a/l
Mariyapen [2020] MLJU 1697
Seksyen 27
6.
AHMADSAIFULGHAZIBIN
MOHD LAZIM (A164478)
Public Prosecutor v Chong Fook Fatt
[2020] MLJU 1774
Seksyen 27

10. Tutorial 5 (Evidence Law)

Firma 7


No. Name Case Topic
1. Yap Han Xin (A166226)
Bandahala Undik v PP
[2014] 1 CLJ 708

Section 32
2 Komathi Raman (A163611) Techcrew Sdn Bhd v Nurhamizah
binti Hamzah & Ors [2020] MLJU
784
Opinion Evidence
3. Norainina Bt Shariful Anuar
(A162819)
Public Prosecutor v Hans Philip
[2017] 10 MLJ 17

Section 32
4. Nurul Rabiatul Nazurah Binti
Mohd Yusoff (A163932)
McLaren Saksama (Malaysia)
Sdn Bhd v Hong Leong Bank
Berhad [2014] 7 MLJ 104

Opinion Evidence
5. Nur Amira Binti Mohd Saferi
(A166230)
Public Prosecutor v Sinun bin
Bakusoi [2015] 5 MLJevi 1
Section 32
6. Muhammad Akmal Hakim bin
Adnan (A164306)
Leong Hin Enterprise Sdn Bhd v
Chevron Malaysia Ltd [2018]
MLJU 1747

Opinion Evidence

11. Firma 8





No. Nama Pelajar Kes Topik
1.
SHAHMUNI A/P
T.RAVICHANDRAN (A163765)
Mohd Awari lwn PP Section 32
2.
NORFATINAZERABINTI
NORHISHAM (A163070
PathamanabhanNallianenv.PP&
Ors [2017] 4 CLJ
Opinion
Evidence
3,
WONG SHUN YONG
(A166833)
LawJiannBiauvPublicProsecutor
[2015] 10 CLJ 419
Opinion
Evidence
4.
SITIAISYAHBINTIUMAR
BAKI (A166246)
PublicProsecutorvMohdYusribin
Yusof [2020] MLJU 209

Section 32
5.
NURAZILABINTIZAHERMAN
(A165600)
Mohammad Hezat Bin A Hamed and
2othersvPublicProsecutor[2020]
MLJU 736
Section 32
6.
AHMADSAIFULGHAZIBIN
MOHD LAZIM (A164478) TenagaNasionalBhdvPanareno
SdnBhd(VitalProjectsSdnBhd,
thirdpartyandSemantraNo-Dig
EngineeringSdnBhd,fourthparty)
[2019] 11 MLJ 795
Opinion
Evidence